Customer Reviews Dunham Lexington Mudguard Oxford Waterproof

One of the cloth eyelets pulled out the third time I wore them. Zappos replaced them at no cost to me.

I need a shoe with a wide toe box. The shoe (10, 4E) was not as wide as other Dunham shoes I have worn in a 4E. I am also currently trying the Midland Oxford and that shoe has a wider toe box than does the Lexington Mudguard. Both are length 10, width 4E It is a nice shoe though.

Pretty comfortable shoe. Not quite wide enough, will try the 4E.

Second pair of this shoe that I have purchased as I need a B width. I had to have both pairs "stretched" to get about a 1/2 size more length. Not true to size. Otherwise they are sturdy and provide good support.

After about age 30, my feet became wider and more finicky. D width and quick fits are long gone memories so most sneakers and fashion plate options have been out for 20 years. New Balance for sneakers and their subsidiary Dunham for casual/dress shoes are about all I wear now. The 4E gives me plenty of room at the ball of my foot without being too loose at the heel. It's also a shoe I wear with both long pants or shorts since it resembles a hiker. The shoe runs a bit short. I had to get a 10.5 in this shoe, while the Dunham Burlington (my work shoe) was a 10.

Sleek design. Really like the look of these shoes. Arch support okay. Nice snug fit and a serious tread. Do not like the laces. They are too short and unusually thick making them difficult to tie. I plan to replace them. I picked these over several New Balance and Propet shoes.

I usually love Dunham, and take the same size in all their styles. These are great looking, and fit everywhere except the toe box - it’s way narrower on the outside than other styles and rubbed on the small toe.

I bought this sneaker because I really like New balance products. It's been a while since I bought new balance, and I now understyand they have changed their sizing. I bought these based upon my previous pair and since their change, I have found these are way narrow than other 6E sneakers from other brands, Quality is excellent. I an so sorry I had to return these. I really wanted them to work out. Zappos customer service is always EXCELLENT. I am looking for a replacement product.

I wear a size 9 B (Narrow) and have difficulty finding shoes I like. I found these and they looked really nice. After receiving them the right shoe had issues with the inside of the arch bulging. My socks were slipping around and so was the insole. I was very frustrated and thought maybe they were defective. As an option I took some Superfeet insoles from my hiking boots and inserted them into my Dunham Lexington Mudguard Oxford shoes and Wow, what a difference. I purchased some Superfeet Copper Insoles for these shoes, another pricey investment. They still are not what I would call 100% perfect but I think after they break in some more they will be better. I probably should have just returned them .

Tried these for men's 13 narrow - just didn't feel as good as others in the Durham line. The orthotics didn't fit well in, heel loose for a 13 N. Just uncomfortable - too tight on top, shoe laces to short. Just didn't feel that great - have to return - Zappos is the greatest for returns, exchanges and choice of shoes!

I ordered a size 9 with 4EE and Zappos sent me size 9 2EE

Not a very comfy shoe, seemed lumpy in the foot bed. A tad narrow too. Not bad looking but didn't have the feel and support I was looking for.

Ordered shoe size 9.5 - 4E - these shoes were maybe a size 7 although the label on the tongue had 9.5.

I received these and first thing when I put them on, one of the metal eyes fell out when tying the laces. I was able to repair it and wore the shoes several weeks and there were very comfortable - but tonight as I put them on, one of the web eyelets tore loose. It looks like the threading stitch missed catching it and was just glued. Bottom line, comfortable shoe, looks good but poor quality. Lots of hassle ordering and getting the right size for one big frustration.

Shoe does not support me adequately. It leads to over-pronation, either because of the design or poor manufacturing.