Customer Reviews Patagonia Wintertide High Waterproof

These boots had a weird fold in the lining just above the toes, which makes them impossible to wear. I was hoping that it was just my pair, but another reviewer mentioned it as well. Otherwise the boots were beautiful and warm, I was really upset to have to return them.

I bought these in addition to the Colombia Minx boots which are extremely similar. I will be keeping the Colombia boots and here's why: I like the look of these a little more, but from a distance they look almost identical. BUT, the Colombia boots weigh less and are less rigid, making them substantially more comfortable.

Loved the appearance of this boot BUT the sizing is WAY too small. I wear an 11AA they felt like a wearing size 10 or smaller. If they came in a size 12, I would've ordered that to try, but they do not. The medium width was fine for my narrow foot with a nice pair of thicker wool socks. This size 11 will be returned. :(

These are really cute, and they seem warm but they just did not fit right. I ordered a full size up and they were still small. I like the height of the shaft, and they are really easy to get on and off. I would go up at least a size to a size and a half!

These boots are nice looking but run incredibly small. I wear a 9.5 narrow dress shoe and a 10 in boots and running shoes. I read reviews before I ordered these and ordered a 10.5 as people said they ran small. I would need an 11 or even an 11.5 to make these work with wool socks. They are narrow which is perfect for me but be aware of the length when you order!

I wear a 5 shoe but with winter boots I like to wear a heavier sock. In reading other reviews I ordered a half size larger. Even with a thin wool sock, not my Acorn Fleece socks, they were way too small and short in the toe box and I have a very boney foot. Going up a size would then be too lose in the heels. Unfortunately, sending them back. I was hoping for the warm, waterproof boot.

This seems like a great boot, but runs small. I wear a size 11 and I have other shoes from Patagonia that fit just fine, but these are way too small.

Too short. I usual wear a 7.5 to 8, but even an 8.5 was too short. I probably need a 9.5 even.

My feet freeze in these! Don't know why was I assumed Patagonia made warm boots. Was in a hockey rink for two days and couldn't feel my toes. Took feet out during the ride home, and you could still feel the coldness!

So disappointed with the sizing. I was really excited about these...I wear a 10, even the 10.5 was way too small. At this rate I think I would have needed an 11.5. Love the style, and I think they would have been comfortable it they would have fit!

I don't know how I missed this information in other reviews but the tongue gusset on this boot covers only the first few eyelets. Even in Washington, DC we get snow above this level and no gusset means wet feet. Patagonia is making snow boots for Florida.