Customer Reviews Jack Rogers Georgica Jelly

I love the way these shoes look. Much better than flip flops. My problem is that the seams of the rubber are on each side of the thong. They were very uncomfortable for me. Not like the leather thong at all.

I have a leather pair of Georgica sandals and they fit perfectly but the jelly style's foot bed is too long. It shows quite a bit of sandal beyond your toes and when they are bright white like these it is very noticeable. Have to return these.

The shoe is really cute, but I had to return them because the toe area had way too much room, and the heel didn't leave enough room. So I ordered a size 8, which I am in just about every other shoe, but in the Jack Rogers Georgia sandal, my heel was falling off the back, yet I had excess room in the toe area, and I don't think I have short toes. These didn't fit so well in my regular size, but I fear that if I go to a size 9, that will just leave that much more room in the toe, making it look ill-fitting, but maybe worth a slot because this is a cute shoe - a great alternative to the over-logo-emblazoned Tory Burch sandals.

Cute but so uncomfortable I had to return

I really wanted to like these. They were just too narrow to be practical.

It must be a Jack Rogers thing. These sandals hurt. There is zero support. Just hard jelly plastic that does not give. I had to buy stick on insoles to wear to my family reunion. That only worked for about 2 hours. The jelly is hard. No squish in traditional jelly's Super good looking shoe. But not a shoe to walk in for a day in Miami. Painful feet. Painful low back. I buy flats instead of heels to enjoy comfort. With these, stilettos are more comfortable to walk in.

The fit and comfort are better than I expected because classic Jack Rogers have not been comfortable. Because of the price, I thought I'd give these try. Just after a few wears and so early in the season, the detail became undone. The customer service was outstanding to replace the shoes.

I loved the style of these but I am having to return them. The length is true to size but the they run very wide if your foot leans more towards narrow. The plastic is hard between the toe and due to the top portion being wide, it was painful and difficult to keep them on.

I received these shoes late August, and they broke within three months. A shoe with this price tag they should not fail three months in.

This is my second pair and I have had issues with the stitching coming apart with both pairs. I contacted Zappos to return them and they were tremendous with their help!

Completely not what Jack Rogers is known for - terrible sandal!!!! I already have 2 pair and these are not what comes from Jack Rogers!!!! Design is messed up, width is terrible - very loose!! I will not buy Jack Rogers from Zappos EVER AGAIN!!!! Terrible misrepresentation!!!!

After reading the other reviews I'm thinking maybe there was something wrong with the pair I purchased. I really like the style of the shoe, however they are way too wide and thus difficult to walk in, the strap that sits between your toes has a raised seam on it and gave me blisters. The stitching around the round top piece and the side straps is coming undone after 3 wears. I was really disappointed.

I bought these because they were so cute, less expensive than the leather and wider (I have a wide foot). Sadly, I didn't buy them from Zappos and so I can't return them (big mistake, not buying from Zappos). They are so wide that my foot slides all over the place, big toe off the shoe and they won't stay on my foot. Awful. I bought two more pair because I liked them so much but I'll be returning them and ordering the leather from Zappos.

There's scratches on the decorative front piece. Also, one of the decorative front pieces is larger than the other (it looks odd). Very disappointed & not what I expected!