Customer Reviews Cole Haan Gramercy Oxford

I love these shoes. They are incredibly light and comfortable, and look really cool too. They do run narrow, so if you have narrow feet, these are perfect. If you have regular feet, consider ordering the wide width instead of sizing up because the length is plenty long. These probably won't work for wide feet, but the leather is soft and thin, so they will probably stretch out after wearing them a while. I usually wear 8.5-9 depending on the style, and the 8.5 in these fit great with a little extra length.

This is a gorgeous and beautifully made shoe that through no fault of its own can't accommodate my problem feet. I'm a size 8.5 sucker for any buck or wingtip oxford in unconventional or traditionally feminine colors, but I order size 9s in order to have room for my orthotics. I gritted my teeth when I bought these, because they're a serious splurge for me, but the quality is definitely there. Cole Haan is saving me from myself by making shoes on a last that leaves very little toe room for Bunion Girl, even post-bunionectomy. And fitting orthotic devices in there along with my foot? Forget about it.

I absolutely love these shoes because they are fabulously narrow! These are the first Cole Haans that have ever actually fit me perfectly! I purchased a size 8 in these and usually wear a 8½ in Cole Haan. They are the perfect shoes, no slipping. They fit like a glove. I have narrow feet and can usually only wear J Crew flats or Naots. I cannot wait to wear these all the time! I am so happy. I had these shoe in the gray color last fall and wore them in Athens and Rome on cobblestone and brick for 12 hours straight with no issues. I now have the ivory and pink.

These are cute shoes! The white turns grey within three wearings. It is disappointing since they were so expensive. They are not worth the purchase.

Absolutely lovely shoes! They do fit my narrow feet when I wear a slim sock with them. It's nice to have stylish shoes instead of elderly-looking shoes, which is usually the case with a 10 or 10.5 narrow foot!

These shoes look comfortable and fancy, so I ordered them. After I got them I still think they are comfortable and cool. The color is very lovely, and they look expensive. I recommend them. My size is 8½ or 9, so I ordered 9. I you have two sizes, I think it is good to order larger size of them.

These shoes run very narrow. All of my Cole Haan loafers are regular width, but in these shoes I had to order wides. I wore these with a suit for a wedding and have gotten many compliments on the style. They are also incredibly comfortable due to the cushioning. I worry a bit about the light nubuck getting dirty, but I sprayed them with a protectant and will hope that does the trick!

Very stylish, good-quality shoe; I wish I could keep them. Love all the colors. They're lightweight and have a cushy rubbery sole. However, they just don't feel quite right on my narrow, hard-to-fit feet. The contact between the shoe and my feet is inconsistent, both as I walk and when I'm standing still.

So, comfortable! Amazing arch support. Lining inside is all buttery leather, a dream to wear without socks (although you might want them on hot sweaty days). Size 11 fits very well. My only gripe is the nubuck is hard to keep clean and wear in the rain. But I've decided to just "go with it" and they aren't too messed up by the rain. These are now officially my favorite shoes. I'm buying another pair in another color to conserve for the future!

Man, these shoes are sharp! As soon as I slipped them on, I knew I could confidently recycle the box, because they were obvious keepers. Soft, supple nubuck-type leather, good support, perfect fit. The wingtip style gives a solid menswear appeal, while the flexible white sole and white laces make them sporty and cute. The color is a real hot-tomato red, striking and bold with an otherwise all black-and-white outfit. I need all my shoes to look good and work well in an office environment, walking, riding a bike, and standing all day at a computer. Gramercy is my first-ever pair of Cole Haans, and if it's typical of the brand, I will definitely be back for more. A note on fit: I wear an 11 Medium in most shoes (usually a 42 in Euro sizing), but I have a high instep, and many styles that fit me in length and width are too tight across the top for me. The 11M in this shoe fits perfectly, including over the instep--and that's with the laces pulled up snugly. Customers with a lower instep might find this style a bit gappy on top.

These are one of the absolutely most comfortable shoes around. They are super fun in style. I'm a pharmacist who stands for 12 hour work shifts and still have happy feet, with style, at the end of the day.

Adorable and super comfortable. I get compliments every time I wear them. True to size, I would say on the narrower side, I don't normally buy narrow shoes, but I would say my foot is on the narrow end of a medium width, and they are perfect for me.

I love these shoes. I wasn't expecting them to be comfortable right out of the box, but they feel awesome, and I can't wait to wear them!

I go through shoes pretty quickly, I got bass saddle shoes and the soles broke within a month. I've worn these almost everyday since I've gotten them and they're holding up really well. They also are easy to clean, I spilled some juice on them and was able to clean them by just dabbing with water. I get a ton of compliments on them too. They run narrow as others have said, but once you start wearing them they conform to your foot well.

As others have commented, these shoes run narrow. So instead of going up a half size try the C width. While I normally wear 6.5B, I ordered instead 6C which is perfect. Due to the soft suede, the shoe breaks in very quickly. They are super stylish and eye catching.

Quite simply, one of the best purchases this year. Comfort, and quality, par excel lances. I saw the red pair on a student, and instantly wanted them. She said I could rock the red ones too, but I’m a woman of a particular age, and grey is my signature colour. See…this is why I love Zappos. Placed the order on Monday, got the shoes Tuesday, rockin’ them on Friday. The best thing of all, Made in the USA! gotta love that!

These are great shoes. Very stylish. Narrow for my foot, so I'm ordering wide. I typically do not need a wide shoe, but feel these will be more comfortable with a little extra room.

Oh, how I wanted to keep these! These are gorgeous shoes, but not for those of us who have wide feet - especially across the ball of the foot. I ordered the black with pink soles, and they were so chic. Unfortunately these run narrow for those of us who struggle to find shoes that are wide across the ball of the foot. I am so sad to send them back.

Love these shoes! Gorgeous color (true to the photo) and the pop of orange makes them fun to wear. I normally wear a 6.5 to 7 M (average width). Based on the previous ratings, I decided to order a Wide in size 6.5 and they are a perfect fit! I wear them without socks and they're super comfortable. With the cushioning in the inner soles I feel like I'm walking on little pillows.

Red nubuck oxfords? Is there any way these could be less than awesome? Admittedly they are expensive, but they are comfy and the style is eternal. Definite keepers.

These shoes are typical Cole-Haan, comfortable and lightweight. The color combo is what makes them really pop! The fit on me is similar to the Skyler and Alisa, but--on me--maybe a little bit wider than the Lunar Grand (sometimes the Lunar Grand are a little narrow on my foot). I do have problematic toes on one foot, so it says a lot that I can wear these for relatively long periods of walking time. They're not really cheap, but if your feet hurt...they suddenly get a lot less expensive.

After reading all the other reviews, I decided to get a size wider. So instead of 5 B I got them in 5 C. And they are so comfortable for me!

I love these shoes! After reading some of the other reviews, I first ordered up a half size, which was too big for me. So I returned them and reordered my regular size 5 1/2, which fit perfectly. I did pay attention to the comments about the width as well, and ordered the wider "C" width. Good decision. They are sublimely comfortable, will give me a little room if I want to wear socks, and look fabulous!

Way too small! I wear a six and the six and six 1/2 are small. Love the shoe. Gonna try a bigger size...7.

Bought these for a trip with lots of walking. I have a wide foot at the toes so I was concerned, given the reviews and they are all absolutely correct! They run very narrow, BUT the leather is soft and I'm breaking them in at work this week because OMG (and I don't OMG often) I have never felt such comfort in a stylish shoe! The support and cushion... I feel like I could easily go running in them! Perfect for a trip with lots of walking. I wear a 7 1/2 and that is the size that I ordered and the length feels true. They are tight across my arch (which is high) and it's a bit of a struggle to even pull them on, but with a super thin no-show sock it's easier, and I know this will improve with wear. (I don't want to cut the elastic inside as others have suggested because I like that they are snug and that you don't even have to tie them.) They weigh next to nothing. I got the Rooftop/Sunlight color and they will go with SO much. The picture is accurate as far as the color goes. My husband even enthusiastically commented on how cool they are! Then there's the price. I actually got mine directly from Cole Haan as Zappos was out of my size and oddly enough I caught them on an amazing double sale. These are not at all in my price range at full price and so I'm sad that I have been teased by the goodness of this brand! BUT, if they are in your budget, GET THEM! Even if you have a wider foot. I'm confident they will break in and be the perfect shoe! If they are not in your range... look for them unil you find them on a good sale, it's worth the hunt! (Also of note, I have now done two waterproofing treatments and the color hasn't changed at all.)