Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Maddox

This is a great looking, and comfortable boot. I had a pair in grey and so when I saw these I was very happy. I knew the fit and style suited me, so when they arrived I compared them to my others, and surprise they were the same manufacturer!

First, I bought these boots in the Saddle color, and I loved them so much that I ordered the black. The ankle is so soft on these boots and at 12½" there is room for nice socks. I love these boots!

This bootie is wonderful! So soft and comfortable on my foot and ankles. I am slightly bowlegged and it is hard for me to find boots which do not hurt my ankle bones. I am so excited to find this one!

I love these boots. I was looking for something to wear at work with pants that had a small, but stylish heel. I searched and searched and am very happy with my purchase. They are super comfy. I have a slightly wide foot so they are a little snug but they are stretching. It is nothing I would return them over.

I bought these to have a stylish bootie with a relatively low heel. These fit the bill perfectly. I can wear them all day and be comfortable. The leather is good but not great quality - but appropriate for the price. A comfortable yet stylish bootie for the price.

These are good-looking boots on, & a comfortable, true-to-size fit. They look great with leggings, jeans, & dress pants -- good all the way around (I can't say that about many others pairs of shoes or boots in my closet!).

The quality and style are very good and it fits true to size. I wish there were more boots and shoes with with 2 to 2 1/2 heels.

I agree with one reviewer. Not sure about this boot yet. I love the strap style and toe. The inside platform lowers the feel of the heal. The toe fits well but the heal is loose. And as another reviewer commented - the width of the shaft is odd. They are comfortable and I love the style. But for all of the above reasons the jury is still out on this pair.

These were beautifully made and have really nice lines. But I was hoping for more of an oxblood color and the heel of the left boot was a little more loose than the right. weird.

Great little boot and love the neutral color. I can envision wearing this with skirts, leggings, or skinny jeans. Thought it looked a little weird with regular pants and probably too wide at the ankle for boot cut, but still a good buy. Provides a moderate level of comfort, but probably not a good touring boot or travel shoe. Day at the office, fine. If you're looking for a well made ankle boot with a classic silhouette, this is it. The black color would lend a more formal look.

I ordered these in a size 6.5 in black suede. It's my fault for not reading properly but I felt that these boots were way too low. I wanted something with more of a heel. They also felt on the large side to me. I wear a 6.5 in most things including Frye boots but the 6.5 was definitely too large. Overall these are a cute boot and great for the price but I felt they felt a little lightweight in my hands and too low.

Very cute shoes, work well with skirts and pants. They run a tad large, but since it was not available anymore in a smaller size I'm still keeping them! (Can't be too picky at a size 12!)

They look nice and the quality seems to be good. Unfortunately, they are too narrow for me. My foot was quite pinched in front. But my foot is probably on the wider side of medium.

I haven't had ankle boots in a long time, but I just thought these were really cute. I'm glad I tried them, they are adorable, and comfortable enough.

Cute, stylish and comfortable. Rated 4 stars instead of 5 because it's a little wide in the ankle area. Looks nice with skirts. Not as flattering with slacks.

I bought these in the burgundy. They are pretty comfy, I have managed to do quite a bit of standing and walking in them, even though I have a low tolerance for heels. I was looking for the burgundy/oxblood shade, and these are perfect and easy to pair with all sorts of colors. I agree about the feedback on the skinny jeans in the review above. I have paired these with both skinny pants and even a dress with tights. My beefs? The ankle is a bit wide, and the zipper tends to slip a bit, but all in all a good buy.

Beautiful leather, however, the straps at the ankle are not so great compare to the rest of the shoe. It's almost construction paper-like, but a tad bit thicker. The shoe is comfortable. I was able to walk/bus in downtown San Francisco with little problem. The heel is the perfect height for introductory heel-wearers. The con, my foot kept slipping forward so my pinky toe and ring toe (?) was kinda rubbing the top of the shoe at some points. Also, I wish the top was narrower. Yes, you can adjust the strap but doing so and not unbuckling it when you're not wearing the shoe will leave extra wrinkles. To fix the wide ankle opening, you can tighten the strap, wear thicker shocks, leave it as is, or try tucking into your skinnies into them. However, I had a hard time doing so, so I just pull the pants over my boot as I don't wear "super" (super) skinnies. Also, the show is a bit narrower than regular shoes. Other than that, great buy, comfortable for a tad bit steep price.

First 'real' shoes I have worn since I walked 60 miles in 3 days and destroyed my feet (yes, the Breast Cancer walk) and I found these very comfortable. Love the style. Wore them with boots socks, mid- thickness and they fit great. If I had on hose type socks the ankles might be a little loose but I prefer boot socks so it works. I can see why skinny jeans not tucked in could be an issue with the boot top but I'm not the skinny jean type so I love them. It isn't so clear in the photo but the toe is a darker color.

I bought these 2 years ago and they are spent. I wore them a lot for work as they are great with work pants and loved the rubber sole but the zipper on one broke and the sole of the heel is coming off now. So sad, not sure I will replace with the same.

I really loved this style and wanted to keep them. But the heel is leather, with an extra strip of leather, all the way down the back. I knew the first time that I drove in them, or stepped in a grate, they would be ruined. If you are not hard on your shoes, you will love them. They are really beautiful but impractical.

I have small ankles so these booties were too wide at the ankle for me. They looked odd with leggings or a dress because the gap around my ankles was to big for my taste yet they aren't wide enough for skinny jeans to tuck into them. They would look cute with boot cut jeans that fit over the boot but that isn't the look I am going for.

Ordered my normal "B" width. The width seems narrow and I can tell that it won't be comfortable. The leather is very flexible, so I'm wary of hammer-toe evidence becoming apparent with wear. Ankle width is very wide, so it looked funny with skinny jeans tucked in at leg opening and obvious if you tried to wear the skinny jeans over the boot.

I loved the boot but they were tight without socks so there's no way that I could make these work throughout the winter. They also were just too low for my liking. They felt comfortable though. Sadly, returning them and will not likely to purchase in a larger size!

Ok looking bottles nothing to die about it, I keep it because feel good but, the quality is no to good, just look like any regular boots nothing to brag about it.

I was pretty disappointed in this boot. It is much cuter in the pictures than in person. It also felt very narrow and stiff.