Customer Reviews Athena Alexander Rally

This shoe is really cute and felt comfortable walking around the house. I have not worn them outside yet, so I don't know how comfortable they are for all day wear. I ordered the red patent leather and the foot bed is red. I would have preferred the black foot bed as shown in the picture, but not a deal breaker. I am a size 9M but based on reviews ordered a 10M, and it fits perfectly. I recommend ordering a full size larger. The red color is a true red.

Wonderfully cute and reasonably comfortable. I need a narrow shoe but was able to make these work fine by adding a pad under the ball of my foot. Zero arch support for me but I didn't choose them for that; I can wear them for 4-6 hours comfortably.

As many of the other reviewers commented, you are advised to order a size larger than you usually wear. This shoe is the ticket for comfort and style for work or an evening out. The Rally is very comfortable to walk in and perfect if you are on your feet a lot at work but still want a bit of a heel.

I wanted to love these shoes but they are just way too small. I normally take an 11 and never have any problem, as I am a pretty straight forward size 11. However, the 11's were small, so I exchanged for the 12's (43 in European size) and they were still too small/too short. Very odd. Otherwise, a great feel and look, darn it!

I really wanted to like this sandal. The heel height is perfect. Not a fan of the shiny material, but I could live with that. I did not like the fit. The sandal's width fit my foot perfectly, but I left like too much of my toes were showing. I have very long toes. So it made them look even longer. I guess I am used to sandals that do not show so much "toe cleavage." Had to return.

I really liked the cherry red color. I was hoping I'd love them. But they were very tight on my feet and felt like plastic. I returned them.

I have this shoe in a size 11 which is what I ordered. I am returning this shoe since it is a full size larger than the one I own. It is marked as an 11 but fits like a 12. Disappointing .

This shoe is super cute. Based on the reviews I ordered a size up. I am a true size 8 and all of my shoes are a size 8 except my running shoes. Based on the reviews I ordered a size 9 and it's a perfect fit. This is my only size 9 I own. The red is cute and more of a blue red than an orange red. The heel height is perfect and not too tight across the top since I tend to have a high instep so I was pleasantly surprised.

Nice looking sandal but too narrow. It's not very comfortable so I had to return it. Should definitely size up.

The shoes are gorgeous and just what I was looking for. However, the shoes are really small. I normally wear a 10 medium and the shoes definitely fit more like a 9 in the width and the length.

I had to check and make sure Zappos didn't send me the wrong size! These are super small and very, very narrow. I ordered up a full size and still had no luck. Very cute, especially if you happen to have small, narrow feet.

These are cute shoes, but they are very narrow! I normally wear a size 7, but ordered an 8 based on previous reviews. I could not slide my feet into them. They are very cute, but sadly have to go back.

This is such a pretty shoe, but it is extremely narrow. I even ordered a size larger because it did not come in wide widths and I could barely get my toes through. Boo hoo.

The shoe is cute but the top digs into my skin. I won't even bother to try walking in these because I don't want my feet cut up. Returning.

So disappointing. Do not buy this shoe. It runs 3 to 4 sizes small. I ordered an 11 and my friend who wears a 9 couldn't fit into my "11".