Customer Reviews Magnanni Santiago

Amazing times 3! I absolutely love this shoe. It's super stylish, the color is wonderful, and it's a serious neck breaker (people turning heads to get a second look). I ordered my true size and it fits perfectly. Although it's comfortable, it's not the most comfy dress shoe I've ever owned. However, owning this pair has only made me more determined to own several more pairs of Magnanni Dress shoes.

These are awesome! They are totally cool and sophisticated, making me feel like a million bucks. I added a croc belt and Mercedes S500 to round out the ensemble. Grab a pair of these bad boys before they are gone.

These are awesome! The color is this picture is way off, more a light tan with darker brown toe tip. Get compliments all the time. Do yourself and favor and grab these. Next day shipping from Zap always helps. Enjoy!

As usual with Magnanni, this is another beautiful shoe, well made, exceptional style, and the usual for this brand - stiff leather, but Magnanni's break in after a couple of days of wear. Also as usual, I ordered a 1/2 size smaller than my usual size for a good fit. I do think that the Cognac color shown here is actually the "Catania Cognac", where Catania is a type of leather, and looks darker and more reddish in the images I've seen online, while the "Cognac" color is what I ordered and received. The "Cognac" color is closer to a slightly dark tan with a very light red glow, and darker highlights, especially the toe box. Maybe. The Cognac color as shown on Magnanni's website looks lighter that the shoes I received, while the shoes I received are lighter than the image shown here. In any case the color is gorgeous, and the attention to detail in the broguing and overall design is typical Magnanni.

Elegant. Day or evening. Color is lighter than shown. Order 1/2 size smaller. Received many compliments!

I've worn these shoes out three times and three times I've received compliments from total strangers. These shoes are sharp and priced well. I have several Magnanni shoes and they're all the same size, so fit was no problem for me. As for comfort, they're about average as a dress shoe goes. I'd buy them again.

Great shoes. I get an overwhelming amount of compliments whenever I wear them (it is actually pretty annoying at this point). As far as fit goes, they are true to size. I will note that they take one or two days to break in, they are stiff. but after that, they are comfortable and if you don't mind lace ups, I highly recommended!

These look like a million bucks! They feel pretty darn comfy and get tons of comments from people. Paired with jeans or a blue suit and a sweet Audi A7, you'll be the classiest guy around.

These shoes are awesome! They are very sleek. They make a statement but are not extremely loud. Wear them with a suit or jeans. Remember to go down half a size.

I own three pairs of Magnanni with the Santiago being one of the most often worn. The cognac color is on the bright side, and draws compliments everywhere. Magnanni shoes are very lightweight, delicate, and best when snug-fit. The sole below the long toe of nearly all Magnannis gets chiseled upward simply by walking on a sidewalk a few times - easily solved with Topys (thin textured rubber applied to the forepart of the sole by a reputable cobbler), and now they don't slip on wet marble either. Without a Topy, you will need to really watch the sole to make sure it doesn't wear through to the midsole. These aren't a novice's dress shoe. Use "Bick 4" to condition without darkening, and keep them on shoe trees. I own many other brands of dress shoes, and Magnanni is the most impressive to me in terms of craft and fit. Magnanni tends to use the same last for all it's shoes, so sizing is generally easy. All three of mine are the same size, same fit (like a glove!), and I had to order one full size smaller than my usual for a snug fit.

Doesn't crease easily, took 2 full days of wearing it to actually crease. Creases don't look bad at all. I hate shoes that crease in a way that makes them look old. Also the color is amazing. Compliments all the time. A very standout shoe. Also very comfortable for a true dress shoe.

This is an exceptionally stylish shoe that's a total magnet for compliments from both women and men. It looks very expensive, and the materials are top notch. I've had these shoes for about a year and a half now, and have been wearing them more and more often frequently because of the need to impress people at work with my appearance. This shoe totally makes any outfit. The best use for this shoe is to wear it to a client meeting for a couple of hours a day. It works well if I I drive to the client meeting in my sneakers, change into the Santiagos for the meeting, and then change back into my sneakers for the drive back. This shoe simply is not very comfortable. It's rigid, and it never breaks in past a certain point. If I have to wear them all day, my feet will be screaming for mercy towards the end of the day. I love how this shoe looks, but comfort is simply not there. Unfortunately, I don't see myself buying another pair of Magnanni's because of the comfort issue. I need a dress shoe that is comfortable enough to wear all day.

The shoe is beautiful. It is a tad long in the toe. Allen Edmonds and John Varvatos fit my feet better, but I will keep the shoes because they are so distinctive. I recommend at least a half size smaller than your normal shoe.

These are beautifully made and stylish. The color is lighter than the pictures, though. The leather is very hard and therefore requires and extended break in period. My ankles really did not like how hard the leather was. Other than that (and if you can put up with the break in), these are great shoes.

Great looking shoe. The color is phenomenal - compliments a light grey suit beautifully. I am a little put off by the design on the cap toe. It looks more "distinguished" in the picture. When I look down at the actual shoe, I feel like I'm looking at a doily pattern. The shoe is also a little snug at the ball of my foot, but I'm still breaking them in... so maybe I'm jumping the gun.

Love these shoes but only after a bit of back an forth to get the sizing locked in. They feel great and look awesome. I get compliments every time I wear them. I recommend getting a full size smaller!

Very good looking, well made shoe. Unfortunately the 12 Wide is not wide, more standard width and quite stiff, had to return.