Customer Reviews Patagonia Maui Smooth

I've had the shoes for a couple months and thus far they have been great. Really comfortable right out of the box and still comfy now. A little snug on the top of the foot at first for my normal size, but there has been a slight loosening which has made the fit better.

An unusual thing. First, the image is brown, but the shoe is really more gray than brown; can be worn as if it were either. Second, I bought a size 10D and I usually buy a 10.5EEE shoe. It fits lengthwise when wearing socks, loose without socks, and is plenty wide for me (comes only in D width). Third, it is very lightweight with a modest amount of foot support. Mostly around the house or driving on short errands, comfortable in that role; would not recommend for walking distances.

Front of shoe is quite wide, but the heel is loose and sloppy. Fabric is thin, construction is not great for the price. Nice for folks who want expensive yuppie shoes though.

Had to return - I was surprised at the total lack of structure in the heel; they collapse and this makes them unusually difficult to just put on even with a shoe horn. Very disappointed; The look and color was just what I wanted.

These shoes were underwhelming in person. And they felt too tight around my little toe - my toe wanted to poke a hole out the side even though they fit well otherwise. Overall, meh.

Pata-Gucci at it's best. I could see way too much of the glue that attached the fabric to the sole of the shoe, and the fabric itself was already worn beyond what I'd expect from a new pair of shoes. They're actually fairly comfortable, but I'm not exactly in the business of buying comfortable shoes that appear to only have a life of 1-3 months. Pass.

I really wanted to love these shoes. But I wore a hole through both soles within a year of non exclusive use. As back story I had bought another pair of Patagonia shoes before this, and worn a hole through the sole of those within 5 months, of again non exclusive use. Later I talked with a sales person in a store and they mentioned that the shoe I had was made for "limited walking," and suggested the Maui Smooth as a daily walking shoe. I don't walk more than a mile or two every day, and while I like the shoe, the soles are very soft and I've found wear far more quickly than one might expect.

These wore out very quickly, toe through the sole. Also quality was pretty cheap, the price tag was absolutely not worth it.