Customer Reviews Frye Jillian Oxford

Very nice leather, if it feels small I think its because it is supposed to fit like a glove which it does. Oddly, the toe box doesn't come up very high, giving it an odd shape in front. Wish they used regular round laces instead of leather cord.

Love this shoe! Beautiful simple lines...no clutter...very flattering on the foot and beautiful leather, slightly delicate. Unfortunately it is a little too narrow for me which is odd and sad because Frye usually runs generously. Maybe it's because it's such a long toe bed? Such a shame. It's exactly what I wanted. Great summer light color and slightly more dressy than a slip on. I have re-ordered it in a full size larger to see if my high instep has thrown off the size. I wish they would make this in a wide. Phooey.

These are beautiful shoes and I really like them. The only thing for me is that they are quite flat and look quite flat, lacking a nice arc that provides arch support and also flatters the foot. But they are pretty comfortable.

These are very nicely made, but I had trouble with the size. Ordered a 9.5, which is usually the upper end of what I wear, and they were too tight in the toes.

Beautiful color and beautiful shoe. They do run a little bit small I'm usually in between a 6 1/2 and 7, and the 7 fits fine (my feet are on the narrow side though. My only complaint is the leather is very thin at the toe and has no reinforcement, so my big toe had already begun to stretch an impression into the leather (not attractive) after a couple wears. I plan to see if my shoe repair person can reinforce the toe somehow, otherwise these would be unwearable in a month.

Alas it was not meant to be. These streamlined oxfords are gorgeous but not for me. They are designed for a narrower foot with a low rise and arch. I always take an 8 regular in Frye and sometimes it's a little big. The 8 in these didn't fit comfortably so I ordered a 9 to fit across the width but then my toes didn't quite fill the pointier toe bed which left a dimpled place in the end. Phooey because these are great looking and very Italian in styling. They don't have much padding inside or in the soles but I wouldn't have cared. Very soft leather so not for hiking around.

Cute shoe, nice soft leather. However, I have a fairly narrow foot and the bottom of my foot sits outside of the sole in this shoe. Hope that makes sense!

These shoes are so cute in photo but they are small and super narrow. Unfortunately, the size was so way off for me that I could not even put them on. Having relatively narrow feet, this was a surprise for me. They did not look very narrow in photo. Sadly, they are going back.

This is a beautiful shoe: well crafted, supple leather, unique and attractive shape and cut. Unfortunately, the size was way off for me. I typically wear a 7 1/2 or 8. I occasionally wear a 7, but I've never been able to wear an 8 1/2 and that's what I would've needed. Even then, I'm worried my feet would have looked like stuffed sausages in these shoes. :(

Sometimes it seems like there are two different Frye Companies. This shoe is much flimsier than the Paige, Carson or James Oxfords. The suede feels and looks gorgeous, but the construction of the sole and the sizing are disappointing.

Super small, super narrow, super girly. Not what I was looking for, and not worth the money for my taste. An oxford version of a ballet flat is the best description I can muster.

These shoes look great on the site, but the front toe box collapsed soon after I got them. Even worse the front of the soles wore down very quickly. The shoes look beat up and are unwearable. I was very disappointed with this shoe, considering Frye's reputation for quality. I own probably five pairs of Frye boots and a half dozen Frye oxford shoes (winter and summer styles). It appears that has Frye has expanded its models, the quality has been going down. Too bad. It had been such a great brand.