Customer Reviews Jessica Simpson Calie

I bought these for a friend and she stated they were too small, she wears an 11 and they do not have them in a larger size. I had to send them back. They were beautiful otherwise.

Such a cute shoe but even the wide was way too narrow. I could barely squeeze in and was spilling over at the sides. I normally order wide just to have a little extra space but didn’t work out that way for this shoe. Such a disappointment.

These are BEAUTIFUL but uncomfortable. It’s only after stretching them, and almost giving up that they are growing on me from a fit perspective. They’re stunning, just not at all comfortable. If you get these make sure to break them in before you take them to work or the office.

I loved the look of these shoes. Sleek and cute. The feel was a different story. I am a frequent heel wearer, who can tolerate just about anything for fashion. Not these, however. After having them on for 20 minutes, I was miserable. They are so painful on the balls of my feet I cannot bare the thought of wearing them out of the house. I am sadly returning these.

Beautiful shoe. True to length but very narrow fit had to order a wide for comfort. Not the most comfortable heel, will likely wear when sitting most of the time. No arch support.

They are cute but not comfortable. I feel as if my foot was coming out of the sides of the shoes. I have normal width feet, so I’m not sure what that is all about. I will not wear these if I’m planning to dance, stand, or do a lot of walking.

I got the nude patent. Super cute looking but so uncomfortable. If you have a desk job they work, but otherwise don't buy them.

runs small, I usually wear a 5 but i have a wider foot, i ordered a 5.5. I could not even get my foot in this shoe!

For me, these shoes felt true to size. I bought these shoes to replace my old Calie shoes which are several years old and very well-loved. I had hoped to wear these for my wedding because of the comfort and style. Sadly, these shoes may have the same name, but they are definitely a different version. There is a height difference when compared to my old Calies; while the old shoes are a total of 4 inches high (I'm now guessing they must have a 1/2 inch platform to explain how comfortable they are), this new version is a total of 4 1/2 inches high with a 1/2 inch platform. That 1/2 inch may not seem like that much, but for my 8.5 size foot, it makes it far too uncomfortable to wear. I'll be returning these and looking for a new brand.

I wanted to love these heels. Style wise they are perfect and the price is great too. However the fit is all wrong. I can barely get my foot into the shoe and yet when I finally do there is a huge gap behind my heel, so I know the size isn't the issue, it's the shape of the shoe. I kept them because they are so cute but it's definitely not a pair I can wear for long periods of time.

The shoes were so cute but I ended up returning them because they were just too uncomfortable around my heel. The sparkles were really rough on the skin. Just sliding them on and off was uncomfortable.

SO cute, but so terribly uncomfortable. Really, a great looking shoe.

Very cute but I can't wear them very long before they hurt my feet. I'm either an 8.5 or a 9, I went with a 9 and they're a bit big. So I'd say true to size.

it is too small for the size 5.5. So sad!

Such cute shoes! Unfortunately, they were very narrow across the bridge of my toes, so they're going back. I tend to ride right between a M and W, and this was pain to even put on with nylons on. No give at all. You sort of expect that with a synthetic, but this was too much to be borne. The length (size 12) was perfect for a heel - just enough give, but not enough to rub. Similar fit issue is found with Nine West--length is great, shoe is gorgeous, but runs narrow.

So uncomfortable! I hate these. They were tight from the beginning. It sucks because these are so cute. I could deal with the arch, but the tightness was unbearable. I've worn these once.

Beautiful shoes but too small. I ordered a 7.5 which is my size and it was too short. I exchanged it for an 8 and it's still too short. I'm afraid to order the 8.5 since I have narrow feet and I'm worried it will be too loose on the side. Sadly, I'll have to return them and content myself with admiring these shoes online.

While this is a beautiful shoe, and it pairs great with work attire or a nice seat of blue jeans, it is not at all durable. This is my 3rd pair of these nude patent leather heels, and I've been through 2 pairs of the same style in black as well. They start to crack/split around where the start of your arch is by the 5th or 6th wear. They are great for special occasion use, but not for every day office wear.

Adorable, but painful. I'm between a 7.5 and an 8, and I had to send back the 7.5 -- they're really narrow throughout the entire length of the shoe. The heels are also a strangely uncomfortable height. I'd love to have these because the style is perfect, but I think I'll look for a similar style in a different brand. Shame, because I like JS shoes.

Super cute shoes but very uncomfortable. I wear a variety of high heels for different occasions and these are by far the most uncomfortable shoes for their style/height. I know by the end of the night I will have blisters - and they are my correct size.

So, I really am on the hunt for a beautiful nude pump, but these don't cut it! In person, the rounded snub nose toe was just not elegant enough for me, the patent was perfect, but the size was more than a half smaller than my normal size and pinched every time I walked. HAD to send back, still on the hunt for a beautiful nude pump!

These shoes run smaller than normal. When I got them out of the box I was in love. The shoes are beautiful and was exactly what I was looking for. However, they killed my feet and we're not comfortable at all.

I could not get a correct fit with this shoe, which is disappointing as they are very nice in person! They're a great nude shade that I think would work on many skintones. I am lily-white and thought for sure they'd be too dark, but they looked fantastic. If they had fit I would've dealt with the fact that the have a SERIOUS ARCH. If you don't wear heels normally, get something else, because you're going to walk like a newborn deer or break an ankle. I'm 8.5, sometimes a 9 if I think a shoe runs narrow. The 9 fit my width well but was too long, so I exchanged for the 8.5. Unfortunately that size also gaped at the back, but I didn't have enough room in the width to try sizing down again. If you have long narrow feet, snatch these up because they're versatile and a great price!

I have a really small feet and it is extremely a headache to find pumps to fit. I ordered 2 pairs in nude patents in size 4 and 4.5 to see how it fits. These shoes do run small! Even 4.5 is small for me. I'm returning both and ordering size 5 hopefully it fits. The shoes is very well made for the price.

These shoes are a little snug (I am comfortable in size 6, but I have to put a little more effort to slip these on). I had a previous version of the nude patent Calies, but got a new pair when the heel broke on my old pair and it would have cost almost as much to fix as to buy a second pair. Everything seems the same across the new pair and the old pair, except for one HUGE difference. The Calies that are being made now get beat up very, very easily. After just a few weeks of wearing them to and around the office, I have a bunch of spots where the nude exterior has chipped or scratched away to reveal the white underlayer. My old Calies that I wore much more extensively don't have a single one of these marks, and I put them through a lot worse. I bought a black pair, too, and am so glad I started wearing the nude ones first, because while I can overlook the visible defects in the neutral color, the white spots would really jump out on the black shoes and I would have to stop wearing them. I'm going to return the black ones and get a refund. Also, I noticed that the Calies are now at a lower price point than when I bought my first pair. This is probably associated with the lower quality.