Customer Reviews Frye Veronica Short

I purchased these boots a little over a year ago. I was very hesitant about them because there were reviews saying they were uncomfortable and too tight/stiff. Personally, I'm someone whose feet often ache in my shoes- whether it is boots or sneakers or flip flops. I think it's my arches are too low or something. I wear a 7.5 with a wide ball, narrow heel, and wide calves, and the 7.5 fits perfectly. These are, hands-down, the most comfortable shoes I own. Even out of the box, they were supportive but not stiff, and I can wear them all day long without my feet getting sore. The upper part of the boot is soft but not too slouchy, so it keeps its shape but doesn't rub my calf at all. The heel has a nice weight so the boot feels substantial but not too heavy, and it has a nice "clop" as I walk. Just a beautiful, quality pair of boots, and my favorite shoes to wear.

These boots are like butter. Absolutely gorgeous leather, in a color that goes with everything (cognac stone antiqued). I ordered 1/2 size up, as others suggested, and they fit perfectly. I'm a big lover of Frye boots, and have found that these are much more comfortable out of the box than some of the other styles. The rounded toe box is a bit wider than the campus and harness styles (great for me, because I've had to have the others stretched by a cobbler to achieve a true fit). The cost was high for me (for a pair of boots), but I tend to use things until they're no longer useable, so, knowing Frye quality, I plan on having these forever. If you're on the fence - go for it! Truly a beautiful, made-to-last boot. And great Zappos service, of course!

I have this boot, got it on sale here at Zappos about ten years ago. It is the Engineer 12 r w, which is a little more industrial looking. Anyway, absolutely love them. The finish is really cool, never have to polish or shine them up. Just rinse off and lubricate the leather soles and you're good to go. I have them on as I'm writing this!

I thought these were going to be the most comfortable boots I've ever worn. I put them on and was truly disappointed. They felt tight around the toe area, my heel slipped against the hard back, and there is absolutely no arch support. I'm sure the leather needs to be broken in and after time I'm sure it would happen but my feet would be ruined trying.

I ordered these in 3 sizes due to people saying they stretched out. I ended up with my true shoe size of 8.5 for these. They relaxed after a couple wears into the perfect fit and I wore them a ton. I hope to have these for years to come.

I LOVE LOVE LOVE these boots! I've been searching for ages for a comfortable stylish boot at this height. Finally found it! When the boots arrived, they were tight, not comfy at all. And my heal slipped. I read thru customer reviews and multiple people reported noticing the same situation when the boots were brand new. I read over and over again that Frye boots need to be broken in, so I kept them. Breaking in only took one day. Have faith! Now I absolutely love them .. comfortable, stylish, just the right amount of presence so that they're cool without being clunky or too over the top. Beautiful leather, very well made. I just went back to Zappos and bought them in a second color. Absolutely adore these boots!

Love this boot! 10 fits like a dream on my 9.5 wide feet. Required some breaking in to accommodate the bunion on my right foot. Leather foot liner keeps coming unglued, but other than that I have zero complaints.

Gorgeous boots! I was hesitant to keep because of the heel slippage combined with the cost. But I read to break them in two weeks with thick socks and also adjust the buckle. So far so good. I also was concerned because other reviewers complained about the quality since now being made in Mexico. I can assure you the quality is good. They are also authentic because I called and verified that Zappos is an authorized retailer of Frye. Frye has a year warranty if the boots do not meet standards. I have wanted a pair of Frye boots my entire life. These are beauties.

Beautiful boot- all leather (and smells great!). Made in Mexico, but seems like great quality (despite an earlier post). These are my first Frye boots and they do have a break-in period. I went with my regular size (8) and although they seemed tight in the toes, I feel them loosening up and they are becoming extremely comfortable. I like the nonslip soles, but not sure why the heel slips? Otherwise, love them! (And love the discounted price on Zappos!)

I bought the same pair of Frye boots (except in brown) years ago. I remember they stretch so if they’re slightly tight, just keep wearing them, they’ll end up fitting your foot like a glove! I have been really wanting a black pair and finally got them on sale. They are just as amazing as my first pair and they last forever - I actually think they get better with age. :)

I am a true size 8M, I have a wide toe box, deep arch and narrow at my heel. As with all of my Frye boots I order my true size and they are a bit tight at first and then stretch out to fit like a glove. Believe me that they will be worth it after you wear them several times!!

Oh my! These are the cutest Boots! To say they are well made is not enough and the price here at Zappos is FANTASTIC!! Right now the Veronica Short at Frye.com they are $ 229.00 on sale, WOW! I am a solid 8 1/2 and my feet are on the wide side but no worries, I unbuckled them and with a little effort my foot snuggled right in and you can tell with the quality leather they will conform with your foot! I would say they are very true to size.They are as soft as butter and have all the Frye quality built in these boots! I got them in Cognac and am so happy with the color. They are in no way on the burgundy side like the picture on my laptop but instead a beautiful rich true brown with some darkening on the toe and heel, they are very feminine and look awesome with my skinny jeans. There is a difference in the Frey Veronica Short which these are, they have a 9"shaft and the Veronica Shortie is about an inch shorter. These are the perfect height to me not a tall boot, not a mid boot, but are in between the mid and the bootie, PERFECT! You know the second you see them that they are top of the line and they just look expensive! If you are considering these, get them! I am gonna love mine for years and years, they are made to last! Thank you Zappos for the price, the excellent service and the super fast shipping, I am now a life time customer!

I got the dark brown soft vintage leather. Yes, they are awesome. I do own another pair of Frye boots, and I am equally as pleased with this purchase the first. There is nothing than can top the smell of real leather and true craftsmanship. They run half a size big, but not to the point where I want to return and size down (same with my first pair). I like having the option to wear a heavier sock on colder days. The quality can not be matched. Everything about them screams quality and endurance. I love them. They are a true staple for a woman of fashion's wardrobe.

I felt like I was too old to suffer in shoes that weren't really comfortable, but these boots have shown that to be not true. These boots are really terrific looking. They're a lot more feminine and refined than the photo would suggest, and the leather is of very nice quality. I like the height and overall, how they go look with straight jeans or a skirt. With all that said, I had a lot of trouble getting the right fit on these, and they still aren't the most comfortable shoes in my closet -- I love them for how they look, not how they feel. My husband bought me my normal size, 8.5, for Christmas. I almost cried from pain when I tried them on -- they were so short that my heel was rubbing up against the back, and the wider part of my foot was so compressed that my toes lost feeling in about a minute. (I have, on occasion, chosen a W over the M, so the width issue wasn't as much of a surprise as the length.) We called Zappos and in a day (yes, Zappos is incredible!!), a 9 had arrived. They felt better, although still a bit narrow. I kept wearing them (when I didn't have too much walking to do), and they have stretched out. (My last pair of Fryes ultimately conformed to my foot, and I suspect these will too. The leather is beautiful, but not really supple.) They feel better as the day goes on but never amazing. It'd be great if Frye made these in a wide.

I have the "Veronica Shortie" in the slate color and absolutely love them. I'm now interested in trying these. I would like to point out, however--in reference to an earlier review by another reviewer--that there actually is a discernible difference between the "Veronica Shortie" and the "Veronica Short," and that is the sole. The "Veronica Short" is a bit more rugged.

These boots fit me but are do seem small for the size. I wear a ten and they barely fit. The next size up was much too big so I am toughing it out but for for the price I wish I had a better fit. Also, they have a narrow toe box.

These boots are really cute and well made, but I'm a size 8, ordered an 8, but these were far too narrow. The sides of my foot were being squeezed. I don't normally need a wide width. They weren't comfortable enough to grit my teeth and wear to wear in. Returned.

Love the pic's and they are great looking boot's. But the most uncomfortable shoes I have put on in years. Ouch. super hard and zero movement. Going back to Italian boots.

My absolute favorite pair of boots! The shaft is just a little slouchy, which I love. The footbed is comfy and the leather is beautiful. Frye boots are my favorite for style and quality. Comfy right out of the box and even more so as your foot sinks into the footbed over time. I've gotten so many compliments on these boots.

Felt stiff out of the box- wore around the house for 15 minutes and they softened. Felt perfect- wore all day yesterday on my feet on concrete floor and felt great- look awesome with leggings.

These boots are great quality and so gorgeous! I love the beautiful leather. They go with everything.

I am so happy with these boots and with Zappos customer service. These are my first Fryes. I'd been eying them for a while but was hesitant to spend the money. When the exact boots I wanted (dark brown vintage) went on sale the week before my birthday, I jumped on them. I wear 8/8.5. Ordered the 8 because I read they ran large and stretch. I received them the day before my birthday, and they were beautiful, but unfortunately they were too tight. I wanted to make sure I got an even exchange so I wouldn't lose the sale price when I ordered up a size, so I called Zappos customer service and talked to the nicest rep (while on hold I listened to the joke of the day -- I don't remember what it was, but the fact they have a joke of the day on the customer service line while you wait made me smile). It was after 5, so she said she couldn't get the 8.5s to me by the next day for my birthday, but I'd get them the day after, which I did (plus free shipping, free exchanges, how can you beat that?). The 8.5s fit, but they did give me blisters the first week, so I was nervous they wouldn't work. However, after I broke them in that week they fit great and I wore them almost every day after that, with skinny jeans and skirts and dresses now that it's spring. To top it off, I got a handwritten birthday card in the mail from the customer service rep at Zappos saying she hoped my new boots worked out! The whole experience proved to me how awesome Zappos is and will make me a loyal customer -- not only are these my new favorite boots, but I got them for a great price and with excellent customer service.

This boot looks great on - loved it, but when I walk, the heel grabs my socks and drags them down into the shoe. So have to return.

Best boots ever. I typically wear a 9.5 or 10 in normal shoes. I got the 9.5 and it fits perfectly. I also have the tall Veronicas in brown, and they fit the same. I wish they didn't cost so much, but my old feet can't wear cheap shoes anymore.

These boots are great! I ordered the burnt red vintage in an 8.5 which is my size in pretty much anything. I had to return them for an 8, which I haven't received yet. The 8.5 left room for my heel to slide up in the back and I knew it would cause blisters. The foot part is a very solid make and the leather on the upper part of the boot is very soft and smooth. Great boot, just go a half size down!