Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

I usually wear a 9 or 9.5 medium, ordered these in 9.5 medium, putty color. They were very cute, but they weren't as comfortable as I'd hoped (based on so many positive reviews). I could have used a wider toe box and a narrower heel. For comparison, I also ordered the Blondo Valli (in 9 medium), and they were much more comfortable. Kept the Blondos, sent the Edelmans back.

Purchased 6.5 wide and they were very narrow, more narrow than an average M width shoe. Loved the look and feel of the shoe and sad to have to return.

I love the look of these booties; even my husband commented how much he likes them (and he never notices my shoes!). The length is true to size. I wear an 8, and bought an 8. However, I have bony feet (a tad on the narrow side, but not narrow enough to buy narrow width shoes), and I found the heel to be just a bit loose, while the width across the ball of the foot was very snug. I wore them with thin socks at first, and then switched to some a little thicker and that helped to stretch that area a bit so that now they are more comfortable. No regrets!

Love the color and heel height!! Cute shoes wear them all the time. They could use some more cushion and support but I just added an insert.

Cute shoes just wish they had more cushion and support.

Very cute and comfortable right out of the box. Perfect with tights or leggings. I'm able to wear these all day. The sole is slippery so do need to be careful or use sandpaper to scuff up the sole. Not good for ice or snowy sidewalks.

I just received these boots, and straight out of the box, as comfortable as can be! Someone reviewed the soles were hard and bottom appeared cheaply made. I have to strongly disagree. I bent the soles and they are very flexible, and the bottom is fashioned well and neatly, in conformity to the rest of the shoe, and no gaps whatsoever. The zippers allow for easy insertion of my feet. I also received these within three days, so kudos Zappos!

I love these boots even though they don't fit quite as well as I would have liked. I have a narrow heel and have a hard time fitting shoes. These boots look great so I will be wearing thick socks with them.

I thought my search for simple, elegant and cool looking blue suede boots was over when I scored these boots. But the vote is still out.... They are well made and do fit true to size AND, the foot bed is narrow as some other reviewers have mentioned. It is unrealistic to expect that a pair of solidly built boots is going to feel great on the first try when I have been wearing open toed shoes for 4 months! So, I am going to wear them around the house a few more times before making up my mind. They really look awesome but if they pinch, what's the point? Ya gotta walk!

Size runs big! I had to order a full size down in these shoes. I did end up loving them once I got the right size and it didn't look like I had clown feet. I am normally a 6-6 1/2 but I had to get these in a 5! The putty color is great and matches a lot. They are well made and a good shoe for the price. Definitely consider ordering a size down though. Zappos was great through the exchange process and shipped the smaller size the same day I requested the exchange, before I even shipped the others back, so that was nice.

These are moderately comfortable straight out of the box, but they'll widen a bit as you wear them. I have a narrow foot and found these quite snug around the outer part of the foot when I first put them on, but now I wish I had gone down another half size because they've loosened up (I ordered a 7.5). If your foot is narrow like mine you could go down a 1/2 size. These are great with coloured tights (I own them in black and putty colours) as well as skinny jeans. These are gorgeous and the suede is high quality - not a day goes by without someone asking me where I bought these shoes.

Comfortable and good looking. I did not give a 5 because I would have preferred them to be somewhat lighter in weight.

This is such an attractive ankle boot, but my feet run wide and it's too tight. Why isn't there a wide size - aargh!

Unfortunately, they run 1/2 size too small. I like the look, but they didn't fit as expected, and I am a size 9.5. A size 10 may fit the toe bed, but my narrow heel will cause my foot to slide. Returning these cute booties.

They were nice but very stiff and the sole was slippery

Normally I take a size 10 M. I ordered a 10 W as suggested by website. These boots are very narrow. Beautiful and great arch support, but soooooo narrow.

Shoe was cute, but there is no padding on the sole and zero arch support. They were also a challenge to get on, even with a zipper. I could already tell that the heel support would breakdown quickly from trying to jam my foot into them, so back they went! Once they are on, they felt tts.

Even when you want basic, unadorned booties, these were too basic. They looked as if they'd been on my shelf for three years, not used too much and not loved. Just okay. Okay is okay if you like total bland. Also, I found them too narrow for my usual M width.

Very cute booties, far too tight in my toes! They started getting numb. Unusual for my foot. Too bad because they look perfect.

These booties are cute but not comfortable. They’re heavy and feel clunky, and the way the shaft is structured rubbed against the back and side of my ankle. Maybe that will get better with time, but I can’t say- they’re getting returned.

I have purchased three pairs of these boots over the years and love the style. If you have to walk very far they get uncomfortable as the soles are pretty thin. My latest pair has started peeling around the heel. Older pairs had actual stacked heels, this latest pair must have a plastic heel wrapped to look like a stacked heel. So disappointing that they are being made more cheaply. They were my go to. Not any more.

I really wanted these to be comfortable, but they're not. I like the color and style, but these are very stiff and inflexible and strangely pronate in at the ankle. Unfortunately, I had to return them.

I loved the look of these booties in the photo, but when I received them, realized they are actual cow hair! I didn't realize that "brahma" means the hide of the cow (or a Hindu god), so be aware that you will be getting a more "animal-like" product than with leather or suede.

These boots just didn't do it for me. I ordered 1/2 size up and they were still way too narrow for my foot. I have very average feet so being narrow is not usually a problem. I'm having to return them.