Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

This boots are really cute and I thought they were pretty comfortable when trying them on. Unfortunately, I ended up returning them because I don't like shoes with hard soles that make noise when I walk. If that's something that doesn't bother you, I would definitely recommend these!

I've had a black leather pair of the Petty for years and I am obsessed. I finally got around to ordering another pair of these boots (the putty suede color) and I can't believe it took me so long to order them! First of all, the color is amazing. The Petty is perfect for wearing every day, with any outfit. They are comfortable to wear all day, even working 9+ hours on my feet. My only complaint is that they take a little while to break in, but once they do, they are perfect.

Love the color and style of these shoes! They are a little narrow but absolutely stretch a little with wear! Perfect for me and for work!

This is my second pair of Petty booties and I love them, but have found these a bit more difficult to break in then my first pair. I have worn them about 4 times and they still are a bit stiff on my foot. I am a size 7M in all Sam Edelmans (I looove their flats), but these seem to fit a bit different. In any event, these are the perfect black suede bootie.

Very nice boot. Good quality. Great neutral color and comfortable fit. I wear them for up to 9 hours with no discomfort. Arch support is moderate, and I have high arches.

Good fit, comfortable even when I spend the whole day on my feet. I've got ridiculously wide feet and these never feel like I'm getting pinched. To illustrate that point, this is the 4th pair of size 7.5 wide black booties I ordered and the only ones to feel good. I wish they were smooth leather, but they look great with my slacks so I can't really nitpick.

I ordered an 8.5W in this shoe. It's cute, but it's too long in length and too narrow in width. I'm not sure if it's pinching because the wider part is at a point farther on down past where my foot is wider because it's too long. I'm going to try an 8 and see if that will work.

Love these boots. The only thing is they are a pain to get in and off...to the point I don't wear them if I am going over to friend's if I know I need to take them off. I do have to say after wearing about five times it has gotten a little easier.

Beautiful style and wide width fits nicely. Looks great with pants and heal is nice height. The soles are really hard, however, and I will be buying some type of inner sole for comfort.

Very stylish Boot. The Neck of the boot is a little wider than expected. Quality leather. Very comfortable .

The ankle boot appears well made. Fit was a bit large, but for me, the top of the boot cut into my leg so cannot work for me.

Runs very large. Probably order a whole size size down. Leather nice quality but very stiff.

Love this bootie! I've had my pair for over a year, they wear very well. They are my everyday boots, mostly wear with skinny jeans, sometimes they work well with a dress too. Definitely plan to buy a new pair once mine give out (if they ever do!)

Love these shoes. THey can get some slight dents/wrinkles getting them on and off but they are so so comfy and stylish and a fantastic price!

Was not comfortable.

Beautiful bootie, I got in the color Putty but plan to order in black leather soon. I am usually a 7.5n but since this brand runs long & narrow I ordered a 7w. The 7w were comfy but my heel slipped out a little & there was still room at the top (my toes arent long) so I ordered a 6.5w to compare & I am going to stay with the 6.5w. I might try an insert to see if that helps with the hard insole.

Shoes were not comfortable. Nor were they as appeared on line

I want to start by saying I love this shoe. Though this is probably a 5 star comfort shoe for most people, I have sort of problematic feet--bunions and neuromas--which make shoes problematic, as well. But, this was the third boot I ordered, and finally found one that would work! I like the heel height comfort-wise, but bc it's a little low, it might lack a little in style, though the sort of forward tilt to it adds some points in that area. Super bonus points for wide width availability!!! ð???ð???ð??? Disappointed however that the insoles are not removable. For people with foot conditions, this is almost a necessity and makes a shoe much more customizable and therefore wearable. This is why I did not give the shoe 5 for comfiness. I have worn this shoe with skinnies, leggings, and dresses. They go anywhere and with almost anything from super casual to dressy casual. One final concern is with the durability of the suede. I should've pretreated them with suede protector, but they already need to be cleaned, and showing a bit of wear on the inside of the heels. Overall, a good cute shoe that comes in wide but isn't the granny style that most Wide width availability shoes come in! You should buy this shoe, honestly! I â?¤ï¸?you Zappos!

I love that Sam Edelman offers quite a variety of their shoes in wide sizes. These booties are stylish and fit as expected (9W). I will say that I found the leather a bit stiff, and oddly enough there is slight rubbing on my ankle bones which I have never experienced with my other pair of Edelman's. I've only worn them twice, so I am hoping they will stretch a bit. Please keep selling wide stylish shoes Zappos!

Very cute boots but a bit stiff at the top and hit my heel. I would have kept them but unfortunately they didn't fit properly

Great fall shoe! Looks good with jeans and skirts!

Ordered in putty suede. Loved the style of the shoe, color was a bit different than what's online. Returned for a different color. Can't wait!

These are great! Perfect height to give you a little lift but not make you TOO tall (if you're tall and hate wearing heels). I'm still breaking the shoes in so they're a bit stiff, but I expect they'll be more comfortable down the road. I thought the pebbled leather would bother me but they look smoother when you're looking at them on.

Very cute bootie, goes with everything and great for fall. I recommend using suede stain repellent.