Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

These are a great shade of navy, and the suede is flawless. Got lots of compliments on them at work. Bought them to go with navy tights and a cute dress. Very happy! Very comfy! Didn't even need to break them in.

I ordered these in a 10W, but then had to return for a 9W, which turned out to be a perfect fit. They are very comfortable and chic. I feel sure I will wear them a lot once the weather warms up a bit. These are nice Spring booties in a pretty neutral shade.

I *love* these boots. I have wide, hard-to-fit feet, but these are very comfortable without sacrificing looks. They go with everything, have just enough heel and are just all around terrific. For size perspective, I wear a 7C in sneakers, but bought these in 7.5C because of the somewhat pointed toe, and I have a comfortable amount of room without them slipping around. LOVE them.

I love these boots, had to break them in at first. Color is great, goes with everything. Can be worn for winter or spring.

Great boot but too narrow for me. There is also no cushion and would require an insert to wear all day. Usually go up a size in boots to 11 (wear 10 normally) and have success but these just didn't have enough room so will be sending back.

Without exception these are the most comfortable boots that I have ever worn. In addition, they are timelessly stylish and elegant - they are great with trousers, jeans or leggings. I have ordered them in two other colors (equally great), and I am about to order another black pair to keep in the back of my closet so that when these wear out from constant use, I will have new ones to replace them!

Perfect bootie. I love the pointy toe and moderate heel. Easy to wear with skinny jeans and also look nice under a boot cut jean. A nice, neutral boot!

These look so fantastic. 8½D Black Suede with brown heel. As others have said it is a basic sole: not a ton of cushion, but just fine for me. The heel height and width is perfect and the tapering to the toe looks great but does not cramp the toes! These are a bit on the narrow side for a W, but the suede feels like it has some give. The zipper seems sturdy, zipper hardware is long and easy to grab, and the shiny gun metal looks snappy. This is a well designed, attractive boot. I am keeping it!

I love these boots! So much so that I bought them in putty, navy and moss green. I tend to have wide feet and need arch support - I ordered my regular size in a medium and they are super comfortable! I get so many compliments when I wear them. I have never bought three pairs of the same shoes in different colors - but these are wonderful and stylish.

I LOVE these boots. I have three pairs (putty, black and grey). They are so comfortable right out of the box. I am on my feet most of the day and walk a lot and these boots are comfortable and stylish.

These boots are super cute and comfortable. While the width was fine, I needed to go up a half size to get the right length. I am very happy with my purchase and I would purchase additional shoes from this manufacturer.

I ordered my usual size 8½ regular width and the booties were too long. I exchanged them for size 8 and I decided for the first time to try wide width since I noticed that option. I have flat feet and bunions, and the wide width really helps! I love these boots because they are so comfortable and stylish. I have the Louie style too but the Petty is more versatile & comfortable. I wear Petty with dresses/skirts and skinnies. Zappos' return policy and customer service is the best in the business!

This boot is very comfortable. Considered getting them in another color. I wore them all day the first time I had them on with no problem.

They are beautiful boots, ran a little wide but were great with socks. Unfortunately my big toe that I broke a few years ago did not appreciate them so I am returning them.

These are beautiful. The only knock on them is that the soles are very slippery. You could not wear on a rainy day, for example. I have seen this with most ankle boots lately, and some tread added subtly on the sole (a shoe repair shop can do it) fixes the problem.

This is my second pair of Sam Eddelman shoes. They are so comfiortable and will last for a long time.

These boots are beautiful and I would have loved to have kept them but the right shoe feels at least half a size too small. Seriously. The left one was perfect but the right one was really uncomfortable. I am assuming that it is a manufacturing defect. I will exchange them for another pair and hope for better results!

Just absolutely amazing. These boots fit great. I needed something besides a heel to wear with slacks. These are perfect. They are stylish and go great with jeans too. They slip on, but need to be zipped along the inside. I would for sure purchase these in another color.

These are comfortable. The color is exactly as pictured online. Another reviewer said it looks more gray but it does not.

Love these boots! I have them in 4 colors and cannot say enough positive things about them. I ended up sizing down from my normal 8 to a 7.5. This may not be necessary for everyone (I have slightly narrow feet and found the 8 stretched out too much for me in a matter of hours to be worn comfortably). I wear these boots all the time, for long periods of time (12-14 hour work days), and find them to be very comfortable and stylish.

Love them! Put suede protector on them right away. They need a little breaking in, they are more comfy with socks. Zipper is kinda uncomfortable on ankle without socks, but I think as I break them in it will get better. Love the style & quality.

These boots are fabulous! They are comfortable and the color is great. I get so many compliments on them. I ordered a second pair.

This a beautifully crafted short boot. The fit is wonderfully true. I have lots and lots of foot problems--including one foot that is fused in 4 places. So, coming across anything that is wonderful and I can actually get on my feet and then walk comfortably all day in, I joyfully celebrate. This boot ticks all my odd boxes and gets complements from others. One word of warning though, on the first try, these boots don't go on easily. But I don't give up easily--so after the first wear, that issue disappeared.

I LOVE these booties! I own them in another color as well. I ordered a size 7.5 and had to exchange them for a 7. They are so comfortable you can wear them all day out shopping the first time you put them on! My exchange process was seamless. Zappos offers the BEST exchange process ever and a special thanks to Joshua who was the customer service rep I spoke with!

Unbelievably comfortable! These boots fit perfectly. They arrived within to days after I ordered them.