Customer Reviews Baffin Judy

Runs very small. If you are a half size you have to go up 1.5 sizes. If you are a whole size you can go up a full size. Extremely warm, comfy and cute.

I've been searching for years for a tall winter boot that fits over my big calves. This technically fit -- but the faux fur trim accented the widest part of my leg in a way I didn't like. Other than that -- super warm, easy to get on, like the red. It's not meant to be cute, I get it, but there is absolutely nothing stylish or ladylike about these.

These are very cute, however, the shoe insert causes them to be too small. I am a 7½ and I ordered an 8 and my toes butted up against edge of insert. I am sending them back. I was hoping to find some cute boots for my upcoming ski trip. I think the entire brand will fit the way that I described.

These are great boots overall and the warmest winter boots that I have ever owned. They do seem to run small, the size 9 was slightly too short so I went with the 10, which is slightly too large. The downside of the boots is that I would prefer a snugger fit - they are a bit wide and bulky, and being slightly long, is pulling socks down unless I wear tight, thick socks. But there is some arch support and much more shock absorbency and comfort than most of the other name brand snow boots that I have tried on this year.

Comfy boot, I am 7.5 size and ordered an 8. It was a tiny bit crowded in the toe, but a 9 would be way too big for me, bummer there are no 1/2 sizes. Nice tall boot (good for keeping out deep snow), very warm & cozy inside and liked the light weight. but - they were like walking in ski boots. They didn't really flex with my foot so would not be great for driving or walking longer than a short distance without feeling like I was stomping all over the place. Returning.

This is a beautiful but they run short. Unfortunately, I have to return them because they do not have the next size. They're really comfy and seem like a very sturdy snow boot. You may want to order a full size up if you plan to wear thick socks.

I normally wear a 7 or 7 1/2, depending on the style. I ordered these in an 8. At first they felt too short and narrow, but after wearing them around the house for a while I saw that they would be fine. I wore them with a thin wool sock yesterday as I did errands during a snowstorm and I found them to be comfortable, warm, and with good traction. My only problem was that they could use one more toggle near the fur. It was a bit too large around my thinnish calf, therefore allowing falling snow into the boot.

These are very cute for a snow boot.. These Baffin seems to run a little tight in both length and width. If you like a little more room in your boot, I would go with a Sorel.

At first glance, I loved these boots! I did hope for more fur on top, but I got them anyway. The lining of the boot was absolutely wonderful! Nice and soft, cushiony if you will. My one issue with these is that they buckled it seemed near the ankle. Maybe I am just too short to have a mid calf boot. But I have never had an issue with any boot like this prior. I might have been able to deal with it if I absolutely had no choice, but it bothered me too much. I was concerned it would start to wear away over time before I got good use out of them.

Because of some previous reviews I ordered a size 10, because I wear a size 9. The size 10 was way too big for me and am sending it back.

These boots look stylish in the picture, but they were really clunky-looking when I put them on. I think if you're looking for a heavy-duty snow boot, they're good, but if (like me) you're looking for something that works to wear just casually around town in the snow/slush or for more "serious" outdoor use, a Sorel or North Face boot might be a better choice. They definitely run on the larger/wider size. I usually wear a 6.5 or 7, so I ordered a 7, but might have been better off with a 6. (If I liked them!)

Disappointed in this boot. Fits small and there is a seam that runs down the middle of the footbed! Uncomfortable, sending back.

Felt like Frankenstein wearing these mammoth-sized boots! Heavy, clunky and stiff. Disappointed with the overall style and fit, but definitely grateful for Zappos free shipping and return policy. You guys rock there and will keep me as a customer who brags about your service to friends and family.

Very nice looking, and I have no doubt that these would be very warm. I took the advice of other reviewers and ordered a larger size, but unfortunately my problem was with the shape of the boot. I have a narrow heel and medium-width forefoot, but these boots have a narrow toebox and wide heel. When I tried them on, my toes were squished but my heel was flopping around. I know that with Baffins, the liner should mold to your foot a little bit, but I could tell that the discrepancy between the toe and heel would never be quite right for my foot shape. The other thing I noticed was that the shaft of the boot looked a little floppy. Maybe that's just because I have an unusually skinny ankle, but no matter what I don't think this would give you any ankle/leg stability.

Beautiful, beautiful boots. I cried when I tried them on and the size 11 was too small! Normally size 11 is too big!