Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ Slip

Light weight, very comfy. Good traction. I feel safer walking in these than my Bugaboo boots!

They were okay, but not great. Good toe room, but overall not as comfy as one would think judging by their looks.

It seems to be a pretty durable boot but the shaft was pretty stiff & a little uncomfortable. Otherwise the foot bed fit snug and was comfortable.

Beautiful boot, but a snug fit (with thin socks). True to length not tight in the toe area. I have high arch so it is snug in that area of the foot.

Very happy with this purchase, my first ever from Zappos (what a great site! will be using them again in the future!). The boots are great, I'm trying to get used to how they look from above when I'm wearing them. I'm not used to such a uniform shoe encasing my foot. Kept me warm all day hiking around Victoria, BC...almost too warm at times? Looking forward to wearing them come winter in Iowa.

I really liked the look of this boot, but the shoe part was far too tight vertically. The top of the shoe dug into the top of my foot. So unfortunately they are going back.

I hesitate buying footware without trying it on, but I liked the looks of this boot. Unfortuately, they are extremely difficult to put on, they are very tight and the boot is so tight I have to wear a very thin sock. They are so tight around the ankles, there are pressure points that hurt after a short time. I am not happy with the boots.

I ordered my true size and half a size bigger, I went with the bigger one and couldn't be happier. These boots are great and I love that I can actually drive in them.

I ordered these boots, the lace-up version and the Sierra Summette. I like the look of these the best, but they were too roomy even with big socks. I ordered my size (10.5) and my foot slipped around inside. Without laces there is no way to address that, so I returned them.

Yikes! I agree with the review that said the top of the shoe digs into the top of your foot. At first I thought it was my socks, but even putting it on without a sock it really pushed/dug into the top of my foot. Pretty painful. It's too bad, because the rest of the shoe is comfortable/fine, but there is no way I could wear this for very long because of it digging into the top of my foot; it hurts right off the bat.

Cute surface design, like the height of the boot, cozy & warm inner lining, sizing was roomy with no need to go up or down, plenty of room for winter socks. I did not like the way the top of the boot is lower in the back. Would've preferred it to be straight across. I'm sending it back because of this. Easy to get on pull on design.

I had to return these beautiful boots because I couldn't even get one of them on. The ankle section and box from the top of the food to the bottom is just way too narrow for my feet! The one that I did get one felt very stiff and not good for walking at all. I'm so disappointed after all the great reviews. I have zero complaints (of course) about Zappos and will just have to try again.

This shoe was a disaster! I had to throw them out - and buy a pair of boots on the road - on the third day I wore them while on vacation. The top is part of the shoe is too narrow and the opening is too tight. Bad design. Surprised that Zappos would sell such shoddy quality.

Last year I bought the version of these boots with the laces as opposed to the slip-on, and they were great, but unfortunately they recently got ruined. During my search for a replacement, Zappos was out of the lace version, so I decided to buy these slip-ons because really, how different could they be? Answer: a lot. I'm a size 8 1/2 or 9, and the 9 in the lace version of these boots was a tad big, but comfy with thick socks. The 9 in these doesn't fit in any way, shape, or form. It's a tad snug in the toe box, even with super thin socks, but where it's really crushing (literally) is at the top of the foot-- thus, I don't really think this is an issue that would be alleviated by sizing up. Also, for a lack of a better description, the front part of the shaft "puckers" out in an extremely unattractive way when the boot is on, so that even if these fit, I think they'd be going back. I'm super disappointed in these overall and a bit surprised by just how differently these fit when compared to the lace-ups. The lace-ups are warm and waterproof, and I'm sure these are, too, but they're so uncomfortable that I don't think it really matters. They're getting returned.

I really wanted to like this shoe, because I've always had a hard time finding a pair of proper winter boots. Online, this shoe is seemingly stylish, but don't be fooled. This shoe is extremely bulky and very tight around the upper part of my foot. I does a good job at keeping my feet warm and dry during the winter, but the style and fit are disappointing.