Customer Reviews Athena Alexander Roxi

I love these sandals. They are perfect for everyday use and also for evening because of the sparkle. I get more compliments on these then most of the shoes I have and I have a great shoe collection.

Love these sandals! Followed the advice of previous reviews and ordered a size up...perfect! So comfy. Can't beat Zappos for speedy delivery and free s&h! Thanks, Zappos!

I LOVE these sandals! I first bought them at a dept. store, then I HAD to have them again and bought from Zappos! I'm so glad they had them! They are so comfortable and I get many compliments on how they sparkle!

I have an typical/average width foot and I'm pretty much always a size 8.5. This shoe is super comfy but I understand why so many reviews suggest ordering larger. My toes and heel come exactly to the edge of the size 9. I don't want to exchange for a size 10 because I don't want it to look sloppy on my foot. But looking down at my foot, not much of the shoe is visible other than the strap. They are cute and I am happy with them, but sure wish they offered half-sizes. Because I feel like a 9.5 would be perfect.

I bought a pair of shoes last year in navy for summer, I was so surprised at how comfortable they were, but when I went back to the store to get another color they were out. I was so happy to find them here, and purchased my 2nd pair. I agree that you need to size up.

I love these sandals so much that I bought them in two other colors as well. They are comfortable and have become the go to sandals for pants and skirts. The coloration goes with anything! They are clearly five stars in my book!

I have bought at least 4 pairs in various colors. I love them. I can walk all over any City with sidewalks all day. Very cute and I always get compliments. I just bough a pair to replace my black.

LOVE this shoe! Had a pair two years ago and wore them out. I was thrilled to find them again at Zappos. Far and away the most comfortable and versatile sexy summer shoe I have ever owned. Great arch support with smooth straps that don't rub or scratch. I wear them all day with no blisters, no tired feet. Plus, sparkly but still a little casual, so They work with jeans or a long flouncy cotton skirt as well as with something more formal. I wish they came in more colors... Would love a hot orange pair!

I love these sandals, I have a pair in the bronze and my sister loved them so much that I ordered her the black pair. She said the size was too small and contacted Zappos who sent her the correct size immediately! I love Zappos, I have never experienced a company that is so customer friendly!

Zappos offers excellent customer service. I ordered the wrong size and when I called them. I received the right size the very next day. They gave me two weeks to return the wrong size and all shipping was free. Great shoes and great service with no shipping.

I liked these sandals a lot. They are super cute and comfortable. They run small.

I LOVE these sandals! I can wear them with jeans or with dress pants, in almost any color. They are so comfortable, and I get compliments all the time on how cute they are! My current pair are getting worn. In terms of size...I usually wear an 8.5 or 9, when I bought these in a store, there was only a size 10 available, and it fits perfectly. As you can tell by the other reviews for this shoe and most Athena Alexander shoes, it probably is best to buy a full 1-1.5 sizes up.

I was looking for a cute pair of wedge sandals for the summer, and really liked these. After reading the reviews, though, I was unsure. Since I usually wear 7.5-8M, I ordered a 9, knowing I could return them if necessary. The 9 fit well, though they are a little more narrow than I would have anticipated had I not read the reviews. By going up a full size, the width issue was pretty well compensated, in my case. The strap fits lower across the foot, so that may be uncomfortable for some. It has not been an issue for me, though. Overall, these are versatile, comfortable sandals that can be dressed up or down. Just be sure to take the reviews into account when choosing your size.

I love these sandals. I wear them to work (I live in Florida so I just can't wear closed toed shoes in the summer). I have the Pewter color which I think goes really well with my black, brown, and khaki dress pants, very versatile. I have also worn these sandals with jeans, and they look super cute. They are also really comfortable. They would be a great sandal for traveling, except that they are kind of big. I typically wear an 8.5/9 and I have these in the 10, and they seem to be a perfect fit. I don't know that I could go down a size without my foot spilling over the shoe.

I love these shoes. Bought a pair long ago and just had them re-soled and shoe repair person did such a terrible job I had to hope these shoes were still around. I am on a waiting to see if they get black ones but bought pewter anyway and they are great but hopefully will get black also. I go down in size for dress shoes everything else is perfect.

The sandals fit just fine, but when walking, they make a klop-klop sound which is a little annoying if you are in a place where it is quiet and You need to walk across the room, especially on hardwood floor. They are man-made souls so they don’t feel like a natural gait when you walk as opposed to leather. I only wear them at home

Comfortable. It hurts a little between the toes if I wear them long hours. Overall good shoes. I had to saw the sparkly parts because it came off.

True to size. This color not very well made, but comfortable. The ivory ones are better quality (I ordered this shoe in two colors). Not sure why color would make a difference. Had a small tear when I received them and Zappos immediately took care of the issue, sending me a new pair. They are holding up well and cozy!

I love these shoes. They are very attractive...with just the right amount of sparkle. This is my 2nd pair of these shoes...a new puppy ate the first pair last season. So glad they are still available. Very comfortable shoe as well.

Beautiful shoe. Extremely comfortable. Everyone stops me to ask where I got these sandals. One caveat: The elongated toe section is easy to catch under a stair tread. This, coupled with the thin strap holding the upper band to the base of the sandal (which is integral to the sandal's lovely appearance), makes it way too easy to separate the two sections of the shoe. I have twice destroyed a pair of these sandals simply by walking too quickly up a wooden flight of stairs. But I have so rarely found a sandal that combines such style with such amazing all-day comfort that I am now on pair number 3. I wear them everywhere. Everywhere, that is, except on wooden flights of stairs.

I wanna thank the ladies who recommended going up a size. A half size probably would be perfect, however if I had gotten my true size 8 my smallest toes would most likely hang over the edge of the shoe. The distance from my toes to the front edge is perfect with about 1/8" extra length from heel to back edge. I can live with that... As far as comfort, my bone spurs just spring off the base of this shoe "pain free" when I step. I will enjoy wearing these stylish cutie petuties this summer.

I should have listened to previous reviews. These shoes run very small. I have a small foot (wear women’s size 4). The size 4 in these sandals is probably a size 2 ½ - 3. My foot was hanging over the end of the shoe. Not sure if I will order again (larger size), because I also feel the material and construction of these sandals is not worth the price. The little diamond studding on the strap was already starting to “lift up” at the one end (seemed flimsy).

I love, love, love these shoes. I had the same ones for about three years and wore them constantly. They look equally as good with shorts and dresses. They tore at the insertion between the toes eventually, and I couldn't find them again for a while. When I found them again, I snatched them up, but they tore immediately at the same site. I have returned and rebought them several times after immediately tearing at the same site. IDK what happened. Did they start making them more cheaply? I have looked everywhere for a similar style, black with crystals and short heel to no avail. I guess I'm gonna try again based on first experience.

I bought a pair of these when they first came out a couple of years ago and I loved them! When they broke, I was so excited to have found them again. But they run small! I already sized up for my old ones, and these are even smaller. I don't really get it. I normally wear an 8 and am debating getting a 10. I held the old ones up to the new ones and they were different in length and width! Weird.

I adore these but there is no way they are size 12! Seriously! They were even a bit short on my daughter who wears size 11. I hate to send them back, but I'm not keeping a pair of expensive sandals that are too short.