Customer Reviews Crocs Shayna

Love this croc. Just girly enough to make it cute yet comfortable like the original.

I love my new purple crocs! They are comfortable and stayed on my feet while I ran through the airport to catch a connection flight. Zappos makes finding just what you want easy and I got these so fast. I get asked all the time where I found these and tell everyone they need to check out Zappos.com.

Love them! I've never been a Croc person, but I was looking for a good shoe for kayaking. Something that would stay on, comfortable, slip resistant, and drain easily. It's all, and it doesn't look as bad as I was expecting. Might even order another pair in a normal color.

Shoes are very cute and comfy. My only problem was that it started to cut into the side of my foot. I brought these on a trip to Florida with me and it was my fault for not breaking them in first. I would definitely recommend these shoes.

Love this shoe. Could not wear the original Crocs because the toe shape crescent hit my middle toes; but this gently rounded toe is fabulous. I wear a size 8 barefoot in summer and use a size 9 with heavy wool socks to jog in the winter. Very good jogging shoe for "barefoot" style jogging; flexible, light, and straps keep it stable with no slippage. This shoe is slimmer fit than the Crocs Mary Jane.

I've been looking for a shoe to wear at home that was a sturdier than a traditional slipper. This is the third style of Crocs that I've tried for that purpose and the first that I'll keep. The others were way too wide, though I think my foot is a normal width. The Shayna fits like a normal shoe and feels like it has some support. (Normally wear 8 or 8.5 and the 8 fits well.) Also, love the dahlia color. Happy with this purchase and Zappos fast shipping!

Very cute and comfortable! I bought these for my daughter. Both she and I are size 5.5 - and the size 5 was a little small. I will order her a 6. They seemed to run a little less wide than the basic croc, but the material was similar (very soft and light). There is some arch support, but not a ton, so I don't think they would for me.

I bought these Crocs to replace my old Mary Janes, which had become a sloppy fit. The Shayna does fit more snugly, there is a spot near the instep which rubs a bit. Completely comfortable with socks, though.

Great color and so cute. Pretty comfy to walk in. A little tight over the instep, but my feet are higher and wider than most folks.

Love the espresso color and the maryjane style, as well the cushioning and width. They are too short and the strap pushes on your heel so that your toes jam up in the toe box. Crocs are just not designed for my feet. A size larger would have presented the same heel strap/toe problem, so I just decided to keep them and remove the heel strap. Zappos zipped these babies out to me faster than the anticipated ship date - they continue to be superior when it comes to customer service!

I thought that this more feminine Croc would be nice. I ordered 5 styles of Crocs to try and none of them fit me! With this one , my foot slides forward, making me hit the front with my toes, and have a gap at the back. Since the straps aren't adjustable, there is no way to remedy this. I tried with and without socks. I think that if your foot is just the right size for the shoe, it would be a nice casual shoe, but if it isn't, too bad.

The heel strap on this is molded in place and does not move at the rivet. It runs smaller than the original Mary Jane with a movable heel strap.

I really wanted the Mary Jane in black as I have two pairs already and love them. The shoe has been restyled and it is shorter and narrower. I have tried to talk myself into keeping them but they are just too tight. My toe is pushing against the shoe. I would advise people to order one size up to save your company's expenses. Sorry.

Very cute, but runs a bit narrow. Definitely not enough room for a sock. Seems narrow where the front band crosses the top of the foot, and there's not much extra space between the top of your foot and the shoe.

Very cute for my ten year old, too "cutesy" for me at age 40. I tried these on in a store in purple, they felt good, but I didn't like the color. I ordered the same size through Zappos in brown and the rear strap held my foot so far forward, they crushed my toes. The sole of the shoe is the correct size, but the strap is too tight. I pulled the strap out to loosen it up, that might do the trick but I won't mess with them anymore because I feel goofy, maybe I just need a bigger size.

I had a pair of the original mary janes and loved them. This style is even cuter, but the fit is odd. Making the back strap fixed instead of pivoting means it tends to push the foot forward. I had to return these because the area around the top strap was too narrow on the sides for my foot. I could tell it was going to rub constantly. Loved the look though.

The footbed size seems perfect, except that something about the shape of the shoe pushes your foot forward. So, when you stand still and upright the shoes fits, but as soon as you step, the foot moves forward in the shoe, making it seem way too short.

I had to return these because I need one size larger than my regular size for this brand. They are cute, but run small. I got them because I am pregnant and need something flexible but supportive for work when my feet swell. I have wide flat feet and will have to get the next size up.

I've been wearing the traditional Crocs (Caymans) for years and they are sooo comfy. I can walk for miles in them. Not that stylish or feminine however...so I got these Shayna's. Cute and feminine? Yes- very. Not as wide as the others. They LOOK good- but they are NOT very comfortable! No arch support- the heel is much thinner than the original. I walked less than a mile in these and my feet were aching.

Hate the new unhinged back panel. It sits too low on my foot and my foot easily slips out of the shoe.

I love Zappos, and Zappos was amazing when these shoes broke the 1st week my 9 year daughter wore them to camp. The hole where the croc button/snap is located ripped and the strap that goes over the foot was just hanging out there. I called Zappos and they were great sent me another pair very quickly at no additional charge. I thought it was just a fluke, but then last week the same thing happened with my 7 year old's Shayna's Crocs, although that time it was after 6 weeks of wear. Maybe the snap hole is too close to the top of the shoe so when the kids do what they do with their feet it rips them...we have had other Crocs and this never happened with them. But it happened 2 times with this style to 2 different kids. I would buy from Zappos again in a heartbeat, but I would stay away from these Crocs if your kids are going to run around in them.

I normally wear a 7 and that's what size I ordered in these. They fit great and feel about the same as the (really super-ugly) classic Crocs do. I think these are adorable on my foot. I'll have no problem wearing them in public. I have really flat feet (and plantar fasciitis) and usually require a shoe with some type of arch support. These don't have any at all, and yet, my feet are comfortable and happy. I was looking for a cute shoe which offered the same comfort I experienced with the classic Crocs. I got just what I wanted!

These shoes are so comfortable I'm going to order a pair for my daughter as well. I absolutely love them!

Very comfortable and even more stylish than picture shoes. Matches with just about anything. I took these on vacation and walked long distances in them, they're perfect for doing that barefoot in the summer, as they're very comfortable and not too hot. I can comfortably wear a thinner pair of socks with them, thicker socks are a squeeze. For two weeks I had to put a band-aid on the part of my left foot at the part where the Mary Jane strap meets the right side of the shoe to prevent blistering, but after that it seemed to conform to the width of my foot and it's okay now.

Love these Crocs! My pregnant, swollen-part-of-every-day feet are singing at the end of the day after chasing my 5 year old around. Seriously comfortable. Not nearly as clunky as the originals, but roomier than some of the other models. I walked all through Chicago with these over the weekend... not one complaint, only a suggestion: Maybe make a Croc with a slightly more prominent ache support.