Customer Reviews Crocs Carlie Mary Jane

These are my first Crocs and I picked a winner! As other reviewers mentioned, these are great for high arches and the problems associated with them. I wear an 8 1/2 and the 9 is a perfect fit. The heel strap is loose but is not a bother when it slips down. I walk dogs in my spare time and these are perfect for the job. Easy to rinse off, etc. I bought the brown and they are a good neutral. Style is flattering and youthful.

These shoes are fantastic! They are extremely comfortable and go with just about anything. I wear them to work almost every day. I usually wear an 8.5 but since they don't come in half sizes found it was better to go up to next size (9) rather than go down a size (8). I also couldn't say enough about the customer service with Zappos. They are the best company to deal with!

Really comfortable shoe. I wear a 9.5 shoe and ordered a 9 Crocs. 9's usually fit but this one ran short so I'm returning them. Too bad because they're really comfortable.

Love these shoes! They are comfortable, cute, and go with just about everything. I did have a problem with the heel strap slipping down all the time. They're OK to wear with the heel strap pushed up on top of the shoe; they just don't feel as secure on my feet that way.

I usually order wide 6.5. No half sizes so I ordered 6. Fits with exception of the bridge, the strap across the top is too tight for me. Cute shoes though, would work well with many outfits.

This is an adorable style. I bought them immediately because I knew that I could not live without these cute little summery shoes. But as others have said, size up, probably half a size. I am a very consistent 6, but these are a little snug on me. I should probably have gotten a 7, and might just invest in another pair. I cannot wear the strap on my heel, I have to wear it up top (clog-style), and even then, my toes are right at the very end of the shoe. There is not much wiggle room. But they are super cute. Until I get a bigger size, I will continue to wear these just for the cute-factor.

Beware if you have bunions! This shoes/sandals is not for you if you have bunions, as it will hurt right on that spot. This shoes hurts my bunions even though I did not walk far at all. Too bad, since this shoes is very cute, stylish and comfortable (except for the bunion spots). Very sad I had to return it.

Adorable! I love the fact that they are not a dark black, and everyone comments on how comfortable they look with the rounded toe. I must caution future wearers that they seem to run 'snug.' If you have a wide foot, size up.

I bought the Crocs Carlie Mary Jane for my upcoming Disney World Trip. I was looking for something comfortable, durable, that could withstand rain and fit easily as I was just diagnosed with MS and having trouble walking. The style is probably as cute as you can get while still being a Crocs shoe. I am almost always a size 7.5, and in the past have always purchased size 7 in other Crocs styles. I read a lot of reviews on this style and decided to purchase the size 8, and I am glad I did! The shoes fit PERFECTLY, so definitely size up if you wear a half size. The shoes are comfortable, but not as squishy as the original Crocs. The back strap does not stay up on my ankle so it is almost just there for decoration. The top part of the T-strap design hugs the foot really close. I'm not too worried about that because it will probably expand more with use. My main disappointment was in the quality. The shoes arrived with visible glue marks and seemed like some of the black rubber insets in the sole weren't glued in tightly. Overall they seem to fit the bill and I anticipate they will work well for my trip!

These shoes are pretty comfortable. True to size. Can wear them all day. Down sides: the black/gray color rubs off on the feet on a hot day. Also, the strap in the back moves around a lot, so I usually just keep it forward.

I just love Crocs. They are the most comfortable shoes ever. I have trouble with my knees and lower back but with these shoes I have no pain. The only problem is, because Crocs does not do half sizes, I had to order half a size up which is loose, This would have been fine if the strap could be tightened. As it is now, the straps fall off my ankle and the shoes are too loose. But they are still comfortable for my knees and lower back. I wish Crocs would make half sizes.

My feet aren't quite a 9.5 so I ordered a 9, and my toes were all the way to the end. Rather than send them back, I gave them to my mother -- they fit her perfectly!

These shoes are cute and comfortable. Don't be afraid of the neon-blueish color you see on the computer screen. They really are more muted than they appear online, especially the top portion of the shoe (they don't look like clown shoes!). Overall I like this new Croc design, but I wish the back strap stayed up a little better on my ankles. In other words, I would like for there to be a way for Crocs to make this an adjustable strap because it slides down a bit. All in all, I don't regret buying these and will probably get another pair in the bronze-ish color. Hope Crocs makes them in a red/burgundy soon.

These are very cute and comfortable but Not for the wide foot or a person with corns.

While this style of Crocs is cuter than the traditional style I found them uncomfortable. The side plastic ended up rubbing against the side of my foot. The were super cushy though.

I so wanted to love these. They were adorable and I put them on right away. But after 20 minutes of wearing them around the house, I was feeling the top of the T-strap press into my foot. I have a high instep, and these were just not working for me. I took them off, and you could see the shape of the strap pressed into my skin. Bummer. Sad that I need to return them. I'd love it if Crocs would put a buckle on so that I could adjust them just a little bit wider at the strap area.

Caution: The heel strap does not stay up! However, I am keeping them because even as clogs, they are very comfy. Plenty of room for the toes, but toe box stops just short enough that it does not squeeze the height of my foot. Insole feels slimy by my feet don't slip around. I would like more color choices and an adjustable heel strap.

This is a really comfortable pair of shoes and style is really cute. However, I have to donate this now since it causes an allergic reaction to my feet. My feet after a few days of wearing it (may be for too long), are peeling. I am still dealing with that peeling after one month. It's not athlete's foot since I don't have blisters, no rashes, no itching, just peeling. I put antifungal cream, powder, benedryl, whatever I can think of and it's still not healing. So annoying.