Customer Reviews Crocs Carlie Mary Jane

These are adorable! I got them to wear around in my little garden area. They breathe, are comfy, and cuter than the old school style. A bonus, the strap can be moved to the top of the shoe so you can slip in and out of it more like the original clog.

These are really cute shoes! It gives the illusion of being barefoot because the toes are slightly visible through the top. They are very comfortable and I have problem feet like hammertoe, bunion, etc. Nothing I want to show off with sandals.

These are so cute! I mean they aren't like going out clubbin' cute, but they are cute! I have a pretty good case of plantar fasciitis, and there isn't enough arch support for me, so I have to return them. Cute new style though!

Great for gardening and around town, but back strap on one shoe falls down.

These shoes ran narrow for me and hurt my feet, next time I will have to have a wide in this style.

When I got this shoe, I loved it...and I own several other Croc styles. But when I walked and wore it for a day it was a painful experience. The cut of the shoe at the opening over the toes cuts into the bone of my big toe. I tried them with and without socks, but still not good. The problem is the hard edge of the opening sits right on to of the "knuckle" bone of the big toe...cutting into my skin. I would return them but I already wore them thinking the rubber would soften up. They sure look good, but are not wearable for me.

I thought these were cute, but not as comfortable as I hoped. The back strap just would not stay up as pictured and felt very floppy. I ended up sending them back, thinking they were perhaps defective, but the new pair sent was the same. I wear a size 8 and the size was accurate. Zappos customer service was exceptional, as always.

I am in love with these shoes. I cannot stop wearing them. They are very comfortable, cute, and easy to clean. I work at a restaurant and I love how easy they are to clean after my long days. A lot of my friends comment on them. I highly recommend them.

I love all Crocs and have seven pair right now. Just received the Carlie Mary Jane yesterday and love them. Please bring back the hot pink version. I need them in a size 10. Please!

I loved these when they arrived and noticed that when I walked in them the shoes were rubbing on my instep bone of my big toe and made it red it was not hurting but I thought that maybe after hours of wearing it my rub raw disappointed and had to return.

This shoe is awesome! They are not like the typical crocs shoe; it is like comparing an innerspring mattress to a Tempur-Pedic. My first pair is still going after 2 years. A great shoe for on the go, gardening, or just being on your feet for long periods. Zappos is amazing. Don't miss out on this great shoe.

These darling shoes are so comfy! Love the color, too. I'm on my feet all day at work and these lightweight shoes treat my feet right and look good doing it.

I absolutely loved how these felt and looked. The minute I put them on I was like, "Oh, yeah! Can I get another pair?" They still have the same Crocs comfort without the bulky look.

I really like this Mary Jane; the heel height is perfect for me. They are very comfortable and easy to carry around. Even though these are very comfortable I found that the width is not as wide as I would have liked. I am hoping to stretch these out a little, because I really like them. I bought two pair.

So comfortable and so stylish! Not your clunky croc. Translucent brown color will span seasons, and look good with a tan. You can flip the back strap up to wear as a clog. Makes your foot look tiny, too. Will be my go-to shoe for work and casual. I just ordered the aqua because I liked the brown so much.

I hated how summer sandals got so stinky but I also hated the original Crocs design. But when I saw this totally cute version, that solved everything. I have worn these every day this summer! When I shower at night I just get in there with them and rinse them off so they're always clean. No stink!

These were great but they did give me blisters the first few days. I can wear them okay now, but I have to be careful with the back straps. I love this elevated Crocs version, and the width is not too wide for my medium feet. This kind of MJ is not very flattering to the feet, but I bought them for the higher heel. It's comfy if you don't consider the back straps, and it's my go-to shoes this summer.

I am in love with my Crocs these are my first pair of Crocs and I love them. The style is so cute and the comfort is great! I can walk all day. The service at Zappos is outstanding. I ordered the Crocs Saturday, received them on Monday. I am waiting for the brown to come in; will buy the brown.

Order a size up. I usually wear a 6 or 6 1/2 but ordered the 7 and it fit. I have a very high instep but the strap across the top was just long enough to accommodate this. Cute shoe and not as clunky looking as some of the other Crocs.

I love these Carlie Mary Jane Crocs! They are a perfect fit and wide enough in the toe box that my toes are comfortable. They are like walking on air. Apparently I was very fortunate to find my size 10 at a store in my home town. When I tried to buy another pair I found this style is only offered through size 9. Why is this shoe not available in size 10. So sad.

I am completely happy with this Croc. It gives almost an inch in height, gives room for my larger boned feet, and yet is very form-fitting (unlike the original Crocs). I specifically purchased them for work because I am always on my feet. They are very 'cushiony', which gives me 'happy feet' at the end of the day. It says black on black, but is actually grey on black. Buy a size up.

Love..Love..Love these shoes! I am a Crocs convert having found the Patricia II and now these. I have tried numerous shoes/sandles through Zappos (thank you very much Zappos!) with little success. Then I found these Croc Mary Janes. They are truly so very comfortable--even on hard concreate Mall floors. They feel especially comfortable to change into when I get home. Do yourself a favor...and try them. Fit is true..you can wear the heel strap up or down. Pretty cute too. I am hoping they come out with some new colors ..i.e. soft brown or a true black.