Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Pierce Boot

These are the Boot of the Season. Every time I wear them people stop and ask where I got them. They fit nice and are more comfortable than most Over the Knee because the back is open at the knee so you can bend the knee.

I bought these boots on a different site (but am a huge fan of Zappos). They didn't have my size. Not only are these boots comfortable but can be casual or dressed up. Love!

These boots are sharp! I bought the olive gray color and I just love them. Wonderful quality and comfortable right out of the box. The vintage looking color is so unique and beautiful. These are dead on to size and just perfect for my skinny calves with jeans tucked in.

I adore these boots! I saw them online and read all the positive reviews and had to have them in the olive color. I ordered them on Monday morning and received them Tuesday afternoon. I was so excited so I ripped the box open immediately. They were adorable! The color and the quality of the boot was amazing. I tried them on and was also amazed at the comfort of the boot. I love them so much I am thinking about ordering the brown color. I don't think this boot is made for petite women. I am 5'9 and that's how I think I am able to pull them off. Again, thanks to Zappos for the wonderful customer service.

These boots are really rich in quality and style. They're the perfect grey-ish green, so they go with just about any color. They run true to size and have an average calf allowance so I can tuck in jeans without a problem. They do run slightly narrow.

This boot is gorgeous! I purchased in the very lovely olive green color. It is distressed a bit so each pair of boots will be unique. The color is not overly green so they will definitely go with just about everything. I cannot imagine they would not just go. They are comfortable and to size. I have small calves so there is room for jeans. Ladies if you have large calves these are probably not the boots for you. My calf measures 14" around at its widest. I think probably a calf up to 16" would work. Over that and there would likely not be enough room for jeans, but maybe leggings. You can only find the olive green color here so if you want them get them while you can. I could not be happier with mine!

I got these shoes just before my trip to NYC looking at all this wonderful review, but unfortunately these shoes didn't fit me. They were too tight for me around the calf area. Returning them; style is good but didn't work out for me.

Things I love: the details and height of the shaft of this boot. Things I don't love: The insole is not very cushioned and the toe box is a little tight. This tightness has stretched out a bit with a few weeks of wear, and I've never gotten any blisters or anything but I just wish they were a little more comfy.

I got these in whiskey and they were so pretty. The leather quality is great and the buttons are really cute. However, they are just so baggy in the calf area. I have pretty small calves, but these just looked ridiculous on me. For the medium to large size calves out there! I'm 5'5' and they were a little bit too above the knee as well. I returned them for the Frye Shirley over the knee and they fit perfectly.

I went through a HUGE pain trying to get these in the right size. THEY RUN A HALF SIZE LARGE. I ordered 9.5 and when they came they were too big, but could have been fixed with thick socks. I am not a fan of thick socks so I had to order the 9. I love these boots. I am 5'8" and they hit right above the knee. The olive is a nice, unique color and the brown is beautiful.

I just received this boot and it was almost the one. I have athletic calves and was a bit concerned they would be too tight. The boot was easy to put on and surprisingly comfortable. Very soft leather with no break-in time needed. The snaps are real functioning snaps as are the buckles. My only problem was the color of the leather. It was more on the taupe side that the true brown I was looking for. Unfortunately, my search isn't over. This is a very comfortable boot… but for the price tag I need the perfect shade of brown.

Beautifully made, however, if you are under 5'4'', have skinny legs, and lack cankles, they don't work. SO MUCH boot around the ankles! Returned. :( The olive color would go with anything.

These boots are very stylish, but the black leather looks a bit too glossy for my taste. I really loved the buttons down the side, though. Made it look different than your average boot. My only complaint is that it made me look like I had cankles and this could be because I have incredibly small ankles, but it definitely bunched up a lot more near the ankles than I would've wanted it to. Overall very stylish boot, though. In terms of comfort, I would say it's average. It lacks cushion. Unfortunately, I've decided to return these and go with a different pair of boots.

Great boot very stylish and comfortable, true to size. As always the Zappos service, 5 stars! Thank you Zappos.

Very stylish, but not as comfortable as I would have liked. There is no way I would ever wear jeans tight enough to work with these boots - I think they would be better with tights. There is also a lot of slippage in the foot.

This boot was super cute. I liked the detail and it seemed to be very comfortable. Word to the wise, however. I am 5'6", 150 lbs. I have very athletic legs and thighs and I have tried a few different styles of over the knee boots and have come to the conclusion that this style does not work well on a person with larger thighs. I think the boot is supposed to flare out at the top (knee) and because of the size of my thighs there is no longer that flare. There was only a little room so the effect is lost. A very sad realization because I love this style. This boot would look great on a person with smaller thighs.

These boots are really cute, but the toe box is too narrow for me, even with nylon socks. I wear a 7½. Everywhere else fits very nicely. Have to return them. For people who like their toes to be comfortable, these boots are not for you.

Disappointed. The 'Olive' boots that I received were brown - a rather dark brown, were sized wrong, and not all that well made. Too bad; cannot recommend. They go back to Zappos.

These boots rank in my top 5 pairs of boots. The leather is so beautiful and the detailing is so awesome. These boots turn heads and get a lot of comments. I just recently ordered the similar Paulina in black. Should have them in time for Christmas. Perfect fit and true to size.

These are in my top 5 pairs of boots. So awesome. I always receive compliments when wearing these and everyone wants to know where I got them. I say Zappos!

Not happy with the length at all. If you are average height (5'4") these boots practically come to your mid thigh! Returned immediately. Although the leather and craftsmanship were commendable.

Save your money! Looks good from afar, but if standing next to you, anyone can tell the boots are of cheaper quality. The leather is on the stiffer side and the buckles in the back are flimsy. Disappointing!