Customer Reviews Minnetonka Casey Slipper

Ordered these for my BIL and he seems to be happy with them. They will mat down a bit and stretch, so pending how you like your slippers to fit will determine the size you should order.

I have worn this style slipper for years. They run a little snug, although, after wearing them for awhile they stretch out. Half a size larger would be better but they only come in whole sizes, that is why I order an 8. One other thing, the bow tie has always come undone so I am having to re-tie it during the day. If you can live with that, then you will really like these comfortable slippers.

These are comfortable house shoes. The interior liner flattens out a little bit and I think the shoes probably stretch some so I'd get a little bit smaller than what you're used to wearing - I usually wear a 9.5 and went with the 9s, which has worked for me.

Bought these for the boyfriend for Valentines day. He's usually between a 12 and a 13, so I went with a 12. They fit a little tight at first, but stretched out as he wore them and now they are perfect. They are study and warm, and the rubber sole is perfect for if he needs to take a quick trip outside.

Replacing old best claws and these are excellent. Nice and comfy and looks very durable. Wish they had half sizes, but i still have a comfy good fit.

Like how they look, like how they feel, but they were way too large. I wear 10.5 Pumas, but had to get these in size 9 to keep them from slipping off my feet.

I followed the advice of other reviewers and ordered a size down. That was a mistake. I wear size 10 and the size 9 slippers were way too small. The color on mine was also an ugly orange-ish brown (I don't know if they're all like that or mine were an off color.) Also the lining was white, not dark grey like the picture.

These are fine slippers- not something you'd really want to take out of the house, and not exactly the most stylin' objects on the planet, but warm and comfortable, well fitting, and well-made. Perfect for padding around, taking laundry down to the basement, and so on on cold days.

Decent slipper. After wearing awhile they stretched out a bit. Tightened the lace and then no problem. I like the bottom. Good for going in and out of house. I would buy again.

I wear size 9-1/2, so I purchased the size 10. I tried them on wearing sheer footies. I found they were far too tight across the toe box.

These were for my son, he wears a size 9, but these were too tight on him, he could not wear them!

They were to narrow. I think it's more me than the slippers. i am having swelling in my feet. I had to return them.

Comfy but too big

OK I guess. Have owned much better and more comfortable house shoes.

What's with all men's "slippers" having an indoor/outdoor sole? These soles are so tough, it's not comfortable like a slipper is meant to be. If I wanted an outdoor shoe, I'd buy one.

A solid size too big.

Hard to make moccasins more than moderately comfortable, anything like stylish, etc., but these are OK: serviceable, keep my feet warm, my toes from getting banged on chair legs.

I thought I would try this style of Minnetonka slipper because I had good luck with other styles. Everything was fine for about two months and then the stitching on the right slipper started to come apart. I complaint to Zappos and they replaced the pair with no further hassle. They did not even require a return of the defective pair. I will wear the pair with the hole until they fall apart and then switch to the replacements. I am somewhat dissatisfied with the product but very satisfied with the service.

The slipper is of high quality and for the price it's good. The down side is if you require the leather tie to be tightened to fit, it breaks. The tie is poor quality and breaks easily if pulled on. Mine broke and Zappos was quick to send me replacement, which also broke. I restrung it with new leather tie from a local leather goods store and now I love the slippers!

These slippers fit well and are comfortable. However, after only two years, they have holes in the toe area and the leather came away from the stitching around the toes. My last pair of Minnetonkas lasted 20 years. What gives?

The sole of these EE wide slippers were 1" narrower than my husbands old slippers. They are not made to fit a wide foot or offer any room for your toes.

The lower padding was gone after a few weeks and the toe blew out after 2 months of wear.

Third try with this manufacturer and I give up. Bottom line is there has always been something wrong with them. This item felt like two entirely different widths. It forced me to check the widths for each slipper thinking maybe someone made a mistake. One slipper felt like a wide whereas the other felt narrow. Measured widths and they were different but they are supposed to be the same width. Something is just off about this brand. I do not recommend them or any of their products.