Customer Reviews Jessica Simpson Astor

These shoes are super cute! They fit true to size. I like how the peep toe shows my first 3 toes. They are not too high if you are used to pumps. The platform is fine, just a little getting used to it. I ordered in the black patent and they are perfect. If I needed another color pump I would probably order this one again.

I could not have found a better pair of nude patent leather stilettos like these. Especially for the price! The shade is exact the color I have been looking for, the front stack heel makes it comfortable to wear, and the wooden heel/frame of the shoe goes well with the nude patent. Originally, I was avoiding a nude patent shoe with the wood trim on it because I thought it looked cheap. But this pair looks great and expensive even though I didn't pay that much. I AM SO HAPPY I FOUND THESE!!!!!

I LOVE LOVE LOVE these shoes, they are sexy and I always get a lot of comments when I wear them. They are pretty comfortable too, as comfortable as 4 inch heels can be, I guess. I wish they came in smaller sizes. In normal shoes I were about a 6, I got the 5.5 and they were still really big, so I had to get them altered at a shoe repair place. They finally fit pretty good.

These are actually comfortable! With the high platform, the heel height isn't so severe. The wide peep toe keeps your toes from bunching and the slingback saves you from blisters. They are shiny and don't scuff easily. Look great with jeans, dress pants and my little black dress!

My friends told me about how comfortable her shoes are and they were right! I got these shoes in nude color and they go well with a lot of my dresses! These shoes are very comfortable because of the stack heel, so I just ordered another pair of Jessica Simpsons black Lenora pumps!

I absolutely love these shoes, but I am so scared to wear them out! I am completely comfortable with sky high heels but usually I am wearing platforms so these really caught me by surprise. They are a bit tricky to walk in but that is only because of me, not the shoes. I just need to get used to the heel height. The color is awesome, bright red without being a tacky red, and they are so sexy. I love them! Now I just need to get out there and wear them!

This is an extremely sexy shoe (my husband loved them on me). I was not initially a fan of Jessica Simpson's style of footwear, however I recently purchased a pair of her black patent leather, peep toe pumps in a store and loved them! I've been looking for red pumps for awhile and was excited to try these when I saw them on Zappos. The color was a deep beautiful red - just what I was looking for. And the platform made the heel height bearable. However after just 10 minutes walking around my house, my toes were screaming! The peep toe/toe box area in this particular shoe seems a bit narrow and was just too uncomfortable. The shoe might stretch with wear, but I'm not willing to make the sacrifice. Sadly, I have to return.

I love the look of these shoes, but my toes felt squished up in the front, and the cut-out at the toe pressed against them uncomfortably.

Cute and comfy. The only reason that I'm sending these back is because the elastic on the slingback is loose.

I loved the neutral color and how it virtually extended the length of my legs. I found the heel height, slingback, and platform comfortable. However, my toes felt totally cramped at the opening, but they may stretch with wear. The nubuck definitely needs to be protected prior to wear, especially given that it extends all the way to the sole of the shoe. Beware of water, grass, and stains of the like. The shoe seemed to clean easily with a formula especially made for nubuck/suede.

I love these shoes. First I bought them in red and loved them so much I got the black ones. The red ones are so comfortable I can go all day in them, but for some reason the black ones are not as comfortable. They seem to fit tighter. Not sure why there would be a difference. For that I'm docking a star.

I ordered this shoe looking for a wine color heel for my wedding shoes. They were the right color, and pretty comfortable for their heel height, but I had to return them for a few reasons. First, they show a lot more toe than I like for a peep toe. Second, while the 1.5" platform makes the height manageable, it also gives the shoe a Stripperella feel, which didn't feel right for a bride. I think if I bought these for going out shoes they would be perfect, but those two things made me have to return them.

Great shoe! Love the platform. It adds inches without too high of an arch. Looks beautiful! Fit seems true to size.

I love these shoes and I received many compliments about them! I am not used to walking in heels but because of the platform, walking was easy. They are very comfortable - I was in them ALL day. Great buy, great look!!

I purchased a very similar high heel peek-a-boo toe, Sandlewood colored suede shoe from a Banana Republic store. My shoe was closed in the back rather than a sling strap. I wanted to see if these compared for nearly half the price. I found the Astor model by Simpson felt cheap compared to the 'Dagmar' model by Banana Republic. I had more trouble walking in these due to the very steep incline of the shoe and I didn't like the 'stripper' feel to them. I ended up keeping the Banana Republic shoes because they felt classier and I returned these. I do think they are a good price but the platform makes them extremely high and a bit hard to walk in. I purchased a 8.5 and generally wear between a 8.5 to a 9.

This is a very sexy looking shoe! However it is a very painful shoe too. Although coming from someone that is usually in flip flops. Did OK for a wedding but by the end of the night ouch! Problem with shoe is the platform is not completely sealed. So my feet were being pinched into the crack between the platform and the upper part of the shoe. The height is not a problem. Jessica just needs to glue the platform to the upper.

Cute shoes and comfortable but the leather started peeling away from the shoe the very first time I wore them. Sending them back.

I purchased the black patent astor shoe to go with a fiery red dress for a graduation. I kid you not when i say I put the shoes on in the car, walked about a block to an indoor opera house sat down and saw that in those few steps the patent material on the right shoe was peeling off. the side of the front platform and the patent material on the side were tearing. I wrote a letter to the company to report this and they said it was just normal wear and tear. Really, from just having them on for a maximum of 2 whole hours? I have been wearing heals for a long time and know how to walk in them so that they don't scuff, I have heals from BCBG for over 2 years that have ZERO scuff on them. The damage was definitely not user error, it was CHEAP MATERIAL!

Zappos is the best in customer service. These shoes are a perfect fit and very beautiful. I don't know about walking around in them for hours, but they feel great so far!

Bought these shoes for my mother's 70th Birthday Party. They are amazing! Zappos service was quick and I love the shoes. They lasted longer than I did at the party.

I bought these shoes in navy blue in March of this year. They are comfortable, elegant and move easily from day wear to evening wear. I recently bought them in red. They are fabulous!

Really cute shoe! The suede is so soft and the color is a really nice nude and I love the slingback. But Jessica Simpson does this thing with her shoes where the bottom curves up and gives you an angle to rest the ball of your foot on. You can kind of see it in the picture that the shoe doesn't sit flat in the front. It makes them feel unstable.

Very cute shoes. They can be dressed up or you can go casual. They did need a bit of a break-in period but now they are very comfortable

I bought these in black patent for NYE, and while the platform is more comfortable, they also need Dr Scholl's or foot petals. At the peep toe, it really pinches/rubs, almost as if they are a half size too small, causing blisters. And the strap slides down a bit, which also caused a sore. I really like them and will keep them, but cannot wear them more than once a week, or for more than a few hours. Hopefully the toe area will stretch a bit, so they will be more comfortable for a longer period of time.

Sexy and beautiful shoes. Ordered the powdered pearl patent - basically a light pink that looks sweet. I would recommend if you have medium or tan skin so it pops. The downside is that it is pinchy at the big toe, so not very comfortable for wearing all night.