Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari - Birko-Flor™ & Birkibuc™

I’ve had two pair and both pair the strap that goes over the toe has broke. Same right foot so I couldn’t even make a pair of the shoes because I have two left foot shoes.

I loved these and wore them heavily for nearly 1.5 years. Then the toe loop broke. Not the quality I expected, will look into leather instead- I try to be sustainable so vegan shoes sounded great and were super comfortable but replacing shoes annually doesn’t feel super sustainable. Hoping leather will last longer.

I was extremely disappointed in the quality of the make of the sandal, because the shorter strap that crosses over the big toe pulled out - Zappos was wonderful in replacing the pair....but then it happened again with the second pair. For the price of Birks, this should not happen!

I really love them however the footbed is rough on the inner part of the right shoe that rubs my foot. I cannot wear them.

These are great Birkenstocks however I have only had them two years and the strap on the left shoe broke. This is unheard of for Birkenstocks. I have worn Birkenstocks for decades and have pairs that lasted 10+ years. Two years is barely getting started with a pair of Birkenstocks. Very disappointing.

I am disappointed in my purchase of Birkenstock sandals. This is the first time I ordered a pair and I expected a much higher quality sandal. The footbed (which is most of the sandal) is flat, thin, and has no contours to support my foot. I feel as if I am walking on the ground, which for me is not comfortable, hence, why I want to wear a good sandal with arch support and more sole between the sandal and the ground.

Love the sandals but I’ve had the shoes for one month and one of the straps just broke. For the brand and cost. Need these to be replaced

I need more support

No thanks! These HURT! Isn’t Birkenstock known for comfort? These are my first pair and I dislike them very much. I only put them on the try on and didn’t even walk around my living room and my feet were already hurting. It was like walking on soles of wood. I think they do have arch support but it rubbed on my arch. My feet did look super cute but sadly these just weren’t for me.

I have a small foot and and need the arch support. So I had to go with the children's size in these. But they are very stiff and uncomfortable. I would not want to put my child in these as I am sure they would make blisters.

Me personally did not like these. They are very hard and no cushion. The look and fit were great, just didn't like how hard they are

There is something wrong with right shoe. Does not fit correct.

The size and fit were very good. The leather nice and soft. But the description says a birko floor. I have been wearing Birkenstocks for 6 years. I was very disappointed after wearing them to realize these do not feel like a birko floor at all??

Strap on right shoe was defective as it did line line up correctly with the buckle which resulted in a noticeable gap when tightened. I had to return.

Love the shoes, but I was disappointed that the toe band broke after only about 4 months of typical summer wear. I've been a life long wearer of birkies and was definitely expecting a longer life span

I am finally writing about the Mayari. I’ve had four pairs of these over the years and every single one breaks at the toe strap, rendering them useless. The only pair I have that have not broken are the full leather ones, which are stiffer and not as comfortable but at least they last more than a year.

My first pair of Mayari were great, but I believe these silver ones are defective. The right shoe fits just as all my other birks fit, but the left puts pressure on my foot at the front strap as though there is a defect in manufacturing. The last pair of birks I ordered online also had something wrong in the manufacturing, really disappointing that the quality has gone down so much. Used to be able to rely on these always fitting as expected right out of the box. Sorry to have to return because I have looked everywhere locally for the silver mayaris.

This totally didn't work for my feet. My heel wouldn't stay in the back of the shoe. Really strange. I have the white mountain version and love them. Think I'll buy those again for $45.

Was too big for my narrow foot and didn’t feel comfortable Felt that soles were too hard to walk on

I am disappointed with the Mayari. . The leather feels more like a manmade material, not the like the soft leather Birkenstocks I have been wearing for 40+ years. I have always loved the comfort and longevity of Birkies. But the leather that is now being used - for the Mayari anyway - is nothing like an "oiled leather."

These sandals do not accommodate my bunions on each foot. Sorry!

Normally these sandals last me 2-3 years. This pair in particular had the toe strap snap on me. I primarily just wear them around the house. First time this has happened.