Customer Reviews KEEN Paulina Mary Jane

I love my new Keen Paulina Mary Janes and have worn them every day since I got them back from the shoe repair man who stretched the front seam a bit. I\'ll order another pair just like them.

Love, love, love these shoes! They are pretty snug in the toe box when you first get them, but don't worry, they will stretch out. I am a Keen shoe addict, so was pleased that these are the same great quality and comfort as my other Keens. The only complaint I have is that the right shoe makes a squeaky sound every so often, but not enough for me to return them, though. I wear them as much as I can. I think they are really cute and super comfortable! Go bold and get the "Madder Brown" color...I\'m glad I did!

Totally amazing shoe for its comfort and style! This my first pair of Keens and I think they are more comfortable and easier to walk in than all my other shoes. For walking long distances for travel or all around New York City, I have worn Naot, Dansko, Birkenstock, and Clarks, but I think these are really the best because the pigskin leather is really soft (no break-in period at all), and the covered toe prevents pebbles from getting into the sandal, and the sole has really good traction. I highly recommend getting these if you are looking for a comfortable walking sandal. And, Zappos service is exceptional, as always.

Perfect fit. Bought it for a trip to the Caribbean, and planning to walk on rough terrain. Very comfortable. I think I could walk a long time in this shoe.

Love the way this sandals feel! They were comfortable since the moment I started to wear them, which is what is most important to me. They are well made and carefully finished. My only reservation is that they look to me cheaper than what they cost.

I love this shoe. I needed to make the move from winter to spring but didn't want to give up wearing Keens. This style is great for being casually dressed up at church or just with a pair of shorts to take your kids to the park. They are very comfortable and easy to walk in. The only downside is that I wear them without socks and they leave the sides of my feet a bit black, but it washes off.

I found these shoes to be very comfortable. I bought them for vacation where I knew I'd be doing a lot of city walking and they did not disappoint. No blisters or any discomfort at all.

Probably the most comfortable shoe I own, including other Keens. I usually wear a size 7.5 but order a half size smaller in a Keen I have also gotten compliments on its looks.

I have several pairs of Keen\'s and ordered my regular size but find these run just a tad too big. But not too big to return. They are generally very comfortable, but are a little stiff and cut a bit over the toe, instep area. But with wear I\'m hoping this softens. The color is perfect and can be worn with everything. I got compliments on them from the first time I wore them. I love Keen\'s and this shoe is the perfect addition to my collection.

Let me start by saying I am a Keen freak. Out of the last 6 pair of boots/shoes - 4 have been Keen's. Once again, I have to say - I love these shoes. They have a nice streamline look, while not loosing any of the comfort or support. Great go to work shoes! Just this morning as I was experiencing the first blast of very warm weather, I was thinking that I should probably order another pair in a different color to take me through the next 6 months.

Hey there, I got these shoes for my mama! She has nasty 'bonions' and really appreciates the Keen wide shape. Also, she's kinda old and has pretty weak/messed up feet, so the comfort and the flexibility are really important. Cheers peeps.

Love this shoe! I have a fairly narrow and long foot and never thought I'd find a pair of Keens to fit well. This one is a comfy and cute style for the weekends. At first I ordered my regular size (10.5), but needed to get the 10 instead. The color is a nice neutral.

This sandal looks good with shorts, skirts, capris and long pants. This is my go-to work shoe. I wore Keen Carmel during the past 2 summers and these new Paulinas seem slightly better designed (not as long). Keens can be erratic in sizing, but these fit me true to size. I recommend them!

Very cute, but these do not have the wide-foot-friendly styling of other Keen styles. If you have narrow feet, go for them!

I love Keen shoes and have several pairs. These almost worked but my foot hung slightly over the edges and it became sore where they met the toe leather. I could tell that if I went up a size my heel would be too loose - just the wrong style for my foot which is narrow in heel but almost a wide in the footbed. Very nicely made Keen, as always. Would have been great with capris.

These are very cute. I don't think the soles are quite as thick as the Sydney II or the Verona, which I would notice if I were wanting to use them for city travel in warm-ish weather. Also, they run big. I think Keen may be changing its sizing, either that or my feet are shrinking. I am a 9 in the Sydney II, and 8.5 in the Verona Mary Jane, and an 8 in these! My usual shoe size is 8.5-9.

I usually wear a 9. I ordered 9.5 because Keen always runs small for me. Not this time! Way too big. Also, the part that hits the top of the foot cut into my food. Not comfortable. Pretty cute but would be great if there were other colors. I have returned these and I am not reordering because of cutting into my foot.

These sandals stain my feet black every time I wear them, even if it's just a short walk to the store. They are pretty comfortable (though I'd prefer more arch support) and it's nice how they're both casual and slightly dressy, but there is nothing cute about ogress feet at the end of the day! And it's very hard to wash off.

I don't know what's going on with Keen sandal styles this year, or if my foot has suddenly become very wide! I always thought Keens were made to be comfortable and have lots of toe room. I have tried two styles, and they are both too narrow in my size (while my Keen boots in the same size fit like a dream). I have to agree with a previous review that, for the price, these shoes look cheap. The sole material seems flimsy, like dollar store shoes. The toe cap looks like it will start peeling back the first day you wear them. I will not be trying any more Keen sandals this year.

I love these shoes. They are great for weather a little cold for sandals but have the same feel. The arch support is good.

All around walking living in shoes. This style Keen runs narrower than most of their shoes. That being said, it fits more like a regular street shoe. I wore a similar pair - without and with socks - hiking on trails in the Colorado mountains and they stayed in place. I felt stable, walking up and down the paths. They are lightweight and look good with shorts, capri length pants or jeans.

I'm so happy that Zappos has such a wonderful return policy because my feet are hard to fit. These are darling shoes, they just didn't have enough arch support for my funny feet.

Great casual walking shoe. Comfortable right out the box. Even though not a wide width shoe, it fit my wide foot very well.

I love this shoe. I originally ordered it in a 9.5, but it was a little large, sending it back. BUT, I ordered it again in a 9.

Great all-terrain shoes, not afraid of water, and look great with a skirt. No break-in time needed. I wear them a lot.