Customer Reviews Naturalizer Nominate

I like to give my review about a year after I've had the shoes. If this shoe is still on the market, I would advise you to buy a better shoe. The fit was fine and so was the comfort level but they stretched out and now look sloppy but I still wear them around the house. When I purchased these I also purchased a pair of Eccos at twice the price with a Microfiber top. I took both pairs to Italy for two weeks of heavy walking, sometimes in wet weather and always on uneven ground. I alternated daily with the shoes, this pair was pretty well shot when I got home, the Eccos still look new and have survived another trip abroad.

I bought these a couple of months ago for a 3 week trip to Rome where I knew we would be doing a lot of walking on uneven surfaces, I bought a pair of Ecco's at the same time so I would be able to switch off one day to the next. These look like they're a year old, whereas the Ecco's look like they came out of the box! You get what you pay for!

This shoe has a number of comfort pluses, but is skimpy in the toe box - it pushes down on my toes, so I am returning the pair.

Cute shoes, and they felt great when I tried them on. But after half a day of walking around in them, they got so wide I had a lot of trouble even keeping them on my feet. Too bad I had to wear them to find this out, or I would return them to get a W instead.

The back of the shoe was too high and rubbed on back of my ankle. I wore them around my house for 30 minutes and had to take them off.

It seems like the Naturalizers are running a little short. I am a size 12 M and my toes touched the end of the shoes. I ordered these in black and in Brown and the Black ones were also too wide - although the Brown width was fine.

These are way too narrow! I bought the 10W. They are not wide! This is surprising from Naturalizer who usually does so well.

Comfortable enough for a desk job. If I'm on my feet too long heels hurt by the end of the day. I do like that the style is neutral enough to go with all my pants.

This shoe looks better in the picture but is rather plain. It fits okay, but rubs a blister on my heel and little toe. So only 2 stars for comfort. It looks fine for business casual and with pants or jeans. The leather is soft and flexible. I am keeping them, but will have to wear socks.

The shoe looks good for work but it had no arch support causing you to land on the ball of your foot. If you want to walk a lot, this shoe is not the one.

The shoe doesn't flex well while walking; the leather is stiff and uncomfortable. Walking Cradles are much more comfortable in comparison, but that brand has a stiff heel.

Very tight and uncomfortable. Even after I "broke" them in around the largest part of my foot, the toe area was rigid and stiff. My toes hurt for days!!

These shoes ran a little small, unfortunately, they didn't have a larger size, so I am returning them to hopefully find some everyday black shoe.

I received these shoes today and was so disappointed to find they fit more like a 7.5 B rather that the 7AA they are marked on the shoes. They need to go back.

Very unstylish for anyone under 60 years of age. Toe box is much narrower looking than I expected. Honestly, my first thought upon trying them on was, "these remind me of pilgrim shoes."

These shoes did not last long. The sole started peeling away from the leather where it is glued on and the toes got worn and scuffed prematurely. They also fit like a pair of slippers. For someone wanting to do a moderate amount of walking during the day, that is not such a good thing. They slide around on your feet and do not offer a lot of support. I am back on Zappos at the moment because I need to replace these cheaply made shoes.

The right side of the shoe was smaller and shallower than the left. It was a gift for my sister who lives in another country. She is trying to stretch it, hoping that it would fit her. It definitely was defective.

I liked the style, and the fit of the front of the shoe--usually my trouble spot and the excellent arch support. But a rough seam in the back of the heel made wearing them very uncomfortable.

I work on my feet all day and even though these fit perfectly and were comfy all the while that I wore them around my house, my feet ached within an hour of wearing them to work. I attribute it to the webbing that they use on the leather uppers, it does not allow the leather to breathe and my toes were on fire the remainder of the night.

Ordered this shoe in the brown. Just barely started wearing them because the Hush Puppies I ordered from Zappos 3 years ago (!) finally wore out. The brown ones are so uncomfortable, I can't keep the black ones.

The left shoe fit like a dream and the right shoe tore a hole into the back of my heel. My feet are the same size, so I'm thinking there was a defect in the 'bad' shoe and am sending them back.