Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Gigi

I really wanted to like these sandals because they're so cute, but both buckles were so hard to get closed again that I finally gave up trying. The only way I could get the sandals on was to buckle them first, then try and stretch the heel strap far enough to get them on my feet. I was afraid that eventually the strap would break, so I'm sending them back.

These were adorable out of the box and I was excited to try them on. Unfortunately they are very sloppy-fitting. My foot slipped right off the bed of the shoe when taking steps. I have a narrow foot. The size was right. But even with a narrow foot, this foot bed is way too narrow and the straps don't keep the foot securely in the shoe.

This shoe was super cute but expensive for what it is...a non-supportive cute shoe. I am mostly returning it because the color I selected camo looked like beige suede with coffee or mud spilled on it- the leather surfaces are too small to see the camo pattern.

These shoes are very cute! I love them! They are just a bit too narrow. I am a true 8M. I have to return these.

I have at least 4 pairs of Sam Edelman Gigi Sandals in various colors. However, I am disappointed in this sandal, thong is just a very thin strip of felt, feel and looks like material is missing.

This is a very cute shoe, but it is extremely uncomfortable. I have many sandals with the thong design, but this one was painful in between my toes. I tried a 1/2 size bigger, but that did not help. I really wanted this shoe to work, but comfort trumped style in this case.

I am so sad, I wanted to love these. They are cute and the footbed is extremely comfortable. Unfortunately, the thong part is so wide at the toe insert. Perhaps mine were just defective - but there is just no way to wear these without pain.

Great looking sandal, but the part of the thong that goes between your toes was way too wide for me. I found it uncomfortable and had to return mine.

Love the style hate the thong strap. The strap is so wide between the toes that by the end of the day I couldn't get these off fast enough!

Very cute and stylish however the thong strap is way too thick. It rubbed my toes raw and by the end of the day I was almost in tears.

I absolutely loved this shoe after I took them out of the box and tried them on. They fit perfectly and they go with pretty much everything. That excitement was quickly gone after the toe strap ripped out of the bottom of the shoe the very first time I wore them. Adorable style, but poorly made. I don't suggest buying these.

Warning: I know everyone reads the few bad reviews and thinks hey, that will never happen to me. I thought that too. So I bought a pair of these. Three months later, they broke. (The toe strap pulled out.) I was so sad about that, but I loved these shoes. So I ordered another pair. A few months later, they also broke, in the same way. So cute, yes. Comfortable, yes. Durable, not at all, unfortunately. Beware.

I was really excited to receive this shoes, but was extremely disappointed when I first tried them on. They are not as comfortable as I expected; my foot constantly shifts upward and I have to clench my toes in order to keep them in place. I was also really shocked when I took off my shoes one day and discovered that they were breaking in half! I've only had them for 2 weeks! Unfortunately, I would not recommend these shoes. I'm sending them back tomorrow. Thank you, Zappos for amazing customer service. I would be heartbroken if I had to live with these.

I was really excited to receive this shoes, but was extremely disappointed when I first tried them on. They are not as comfortable as I expected; my foot constantly shifts upward and I have to clench my toes in order to keep them in place. I was also really shocked when I took off my shoes one day and discovered that they were breaking in half! I've only had them for 2 weeks! Unfortunately, I would not recommend these shoes. I'm sending them back tomorrow. Thank you, Zappos for amazing customer service. I would be heartbroken if I had to live with these.

Have already rated these and would add that every male and female who likes thong sandals should own a pair (or two).

Wonderful basic sandal I wear a lot. Have in both brown and black leather. Get many complements when I wear them.

Love these sandals. I have them in many colors.

a simple design but so cute on and adds a little fancy to a beachy sun dress. Must have for a beachy vacay.