Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Gigi

Cute and comfortable but the toe strap broke after one summer of light wear. I had to walk around NYC with one barefoot. I would guess I wore them 20 times.

I do not recommend, the soles of these shoes are VERY thin they offer no support. I prefer a stiff sole with these thin soles, they are flexible and bend easily and I have had some toe injuries because they bed back so easily!

I like how simple these sandals are and that they come in so many colors. I think they would probably be comfortable after they are broken in, but I cant get that far because they make so much noise when you walk! We have hardwood floors in my office and so many of my coworkers commented about my stomping the day I wore them!

So cute in animal/flamingo! But I sent them back. Even just around the house, my feet got tired. There is no support. They make a smacking sound when you walk. But they'd be uncomfortable for walking anyway.

These are so pretty but the toe section rubs and I had red marks in 5 minutes. Too uncomfortable. Sending them back.

This shoe is for people with narrow feet. I wish I were one of those people, but sadly I'm not and definitely going to return this cute sandal.

These sandals in navy Leather are not a true navy. They are a grayish-blue. Otherwise, I like the sandals.

Had to return two pairs of this style because they were too short and too narrow. A very cute shoe and would reorder in a larger size but they are out of stock.

Surprised to find that this cute shoe was too short and too narrow for my foot. Hate to return and would try an 8 but all out of stock.

I loved these until one of them came apart. The part that goes between your toes became disconnected from the sole of the shoe. I tried to super glue it back together, but in only held for a few days. Too bad, I really liked these shoes.

I really loved the look of this sandal, and wanted it to fit so badly. But it is very narrow. I usually wear regular width shoes, but this sandal was so narrow that my foot hung over the edges. Too bad, because it was exactly the style I was looking for... classic and simple yet trendy black sandal.

They are very cute, but they run really short. Buy a size larger. Unfortunately, these are going back.

I purchased these in 2 different colors. I didn't realize that the black patent was not patent "leather." I would expect better when I see the name Edelman...thinking quality leather, not plastic.

Unfortunately, I just really don't like Edelman animal print materials. Ordered a few pairs and the snakeskin just looks cheap to me. So sad, because these are really cute sandals.

These sandals are cute but if you have feet on the wider side, I don't recommend them. I ordered a 1/2 size up, as many reviewers recommended but they were then too long and looked odd. My feet are wider but not truly wide. I only buy wide shoes in athletic shoes. Other types - sandals, boots, flats, etc typically work fine in the regular B width. These, sadly, did not. Cute sandals though!

The problem for me with these was that the thong between the big toe and the next toe was so wide! it made these unwearable because it was painful! So I had to return them.

I asked about my cousin living in LA to buy me a pair of Sam Edelman Gigi Thongs Copper/Rose White size 6. I just received it and tried it. My feet are a bit wide. My pinky toes nearly fell off the sides. I just can't return it. But maybe I can find remedies for it (cross fingers).

Oops! The shoe doesn't match itself. Part is royal blue part is purplish and I think it was meant to match. It fit well and looks fine if that doesn't matter to you.

Cute sandal, but runs small. I ordered a 7.5 and I felt my feet was still hanging off the back. The sole is amazing (cushioned) which is great for all day walking. I don't have fat feet, but these were narrow even for my feet. They are cute, but not worth full price.

I ordered the Arctic White but it was more ivory than a pure white. The footbed was really comfy but the width wasn't quite wide enough for my toes. I have slightly wider feet than a B and so my big toe hung off the sides a little bit and didn't look very nice. It's too bad because I really loved the footbed. Zappos was amazing as usual and delivered in 1 business day.

I wanted an inexpensive T-strap and went with this one based on reviews. If you plan to do any amount of walking, pick another shoe. This one is cute, but it has no cushion. A pair of rubber flip flops would have been better. I wore them to work in a carpet on concrete office and had sore feet by the end of the day.

I wanted to love these sandals, I SO wanted to love them. They are the cutest I've seen all season - and would have bought them in every color left. But, I had to try three sizes (usually a 6 or 6.5 in sandals, 7 in these), and then when I found the closest to a good fit they were still INCREDIBLY narrow at the toes - and I have narrow feet, but still the ball of my foot overhung by just a hair, didn't look quite right. Also felt like the thong was going to slice my big toe off. Very uncomfortable. But so cute I would almost have put up with that much pain, if the fit were just right, waaaaaah.