Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Gigi

Cute and pretty comfy for a flat sandal!

Great looking sandal, just half size too small. Will return and hopefully larger size will work.

These are beautiful. I’m usually between an 8 and 8.5 and I went with the 8.5 which I’m glad I did. The only thing is that my big toe slides off of the shoe a bit when walking (there is enough space infront and back of shoe) I just wish that they were wider, but not a deal breaker.

Super cute shoe! They’re really flat and don’t give much when walking which makes them slightly uncomfortable after a long day of walking. I also feel like the ankle strap needs to be a smidge longer.

As expected in terms of sizing. Decided to return as I feel like the skinny strap amplifies my wide feet.

Very cute! Luckily I have somewhat narrow feet, as they run narrow. No arch support whatsoever, but that's to be expected for this type of shoe.

Sam Edelman, please make more wide option's than narrow.

I liked the fit of these sandals but I was under the impression that the almond was patent leather but it is made of all man made materials.

So cute but not good if walking all day

Cute! I knew the sizing ran small so when I placed my order I went with a half size bigger. Ultimately I went with up a whole size to make sure the fit was right.

Really love this shoe as it is dressier for going out and work. The only negative is the footbed is a little slippery due to the satiny material. Shoe fits true to size.

I ordered these to replace another similar pair (different brand). I loved the way they looked, but returned them because they weren't as comfortable between my toes as my previous pair. My previous pair had a rounded part between the toes. On these, the flat t-strap just continues all the way down to the sole of the shoe. They weren't super uncomfortable, but definitely more noticeable than my previous pair and I ultimately decided they would bother me so I returned them. They looked great and fit great other than that. If a wider between the toe area doesn't bother you they will be great.

Loved everything about these sandals but they were too narrow and my foot did not feel secure in the sandal. I even sized up, but had the same problem. I do have a somewhat wide foot but have not experienced this problem with any other sandal I own. Pretty shoe other than that

Great shoe if they were not so narrow. Had to send them back even after upsizing 1/2 size.

I'm a true size 5 and I have some what of a narrow foot. So I took the advice of all the other reviews and went with a 5 1/2. They fit that way but were way too narrow, even for my tiny foot. I bought them in two different colors and am returning them both. Unfortunately they are outta stock for both in the wide size. They are really cute and luv them but my big toe will end up going off the side. There is no arch on these, which I'm fine with, but if ya need support I wouldn't go for these.

I love these sandals. They are a bit narrow so if you have a wide foot you may want to try it on first possibly in a store before you order it. It’s really cute and comfy. I wish the strap was longer but other than that it is a great sandal!

Classic, simple, reliable.

I was very disappointed that it wasn’t stated that these are patent leather. Sam Edelman Gigi sandal is so classic.

I read through the reviews of this sandal before purchasing and am really glad I did! Most folks said order 1/2 size up because the sandal is narrow and runs small. I ordered an 8 1/2 where I normally wear an 8--the sandals fit perfectly--I absolutely love them. They have a small heel which really adds to elegant lines of the sandal. I got the metallic gold and I couldn't be happier. The sandal is narrow also but I am on the narrow side of medium so I thought I would chance ordering--the sandal is on the narrow side but it just fits--if you have wider feet--order the W! The metallic gold snake print is beautiful--a sandal I can dress up or down--everyone needs a little sparkle on their feet!

I love this sandal. I have them in multiple colors. Be aware there is no real arch support.

I bought a 1/2 size bigger based on reviews I’ve read online. I should have bought my normal size 9. The footbed is a little narrow for my foot wish I was just a smug wiser. Love the Rose gold you can dress it up or wear it casual. I’m keeping the shoes even if there a 1/2 size big

Needs more arch support / more padded footbed. Could use a more delicate construction due to pricing. Looks like a heavier sandal on than in pictures but still a pretty subtle/minimalist design.

Great shoe! I have it in gold as well. Very comfortable. But -- it is pretty narrow. My foot hits the very edge of the shoe so I also ordered my size in Wide for comparison. The wide was way too big so I'm sticking with the medium width though not ideal. Both colors fit the same.

Comfy sandals that can be dressed up or dressed down. Run slightly small. I usually wear a 10 or 10 1/2 and ordered the 10 1/2 and they fit perfectly

I love these sandals! I wear them all the time during summer and they go with pretty much everything. My feet are quite wide so this style is great since they let my toes be free! The footbed is slightly cushioned but I would not recommend walking in them for too long since there's no arch support and the materials its made of are not the softest.