Customer Reviews Reef Smoothy

I love these sandals. To me they RUN SMALL (at least one size). I like that the strap is fabric and really comfortable. I have worn them for years because they look unisex and mold to your feet after wearing for a couple of weeks.

Nice comfort & fit but prefer a slightly more rigid rubberized structured shaped foot strap.

way too big for some reason - the previous purchases of same flip flops fit better than these - might return since I only out them to see how they fit.

These Reefs ran about 1/2 size smaller than usual. I've ordered Reefs before and they fit perfectly, however, these are a different style. I like the woven band but the arch support doesn't seem as substantial as the last two pair I ordered. Returning and going to try another style.

Purchased these for my husband to wear around the house, and while he said they were comfortable, they felt 1/2 a size too small. He normally wears a 9, and they did look like an 8.5.

Ok

I’ve been wearing a pair I got at Ward Warehouse on Oahu decades ago. I wanted another pair. Still a great slipper but the older one seems a bit heavier and more solid feeling.

I'm size 11 and ordered that (August 2019), but they barely fit length and width wise. So I recommend ordering a half size up. Still comfy, slight amount of arch support. Last pair of Reef Smoothly lasted 7 years - so about $4 per year for flip flops if these hold out. They've got a lifetime customer if they can keep it up.

This style has been my favorite go-to flip-flop for at least a decade, but I've noticed over the past several years that they have been running decidedly smaller than when I first started wearing them. I normally wear a size 9 in most shoes, and a couple of years ago started ordering a size 10... But the last pair of these I ordered in a size 10 is borderline too small. (Holding them up to an older pair of this same style in the same size, they are more than ½" shorter, which is just... not great.) The web strap stretches out, and the footbed will flatten out as it breaks in and compresses, but it's not going to *spread* out very much if at all. Disappointing, but I will make it work for now. TLDR: Either these run super small, or Amazon & Zappos have accidentally shipped me something in a women's size the past 3 times I have ordered these. Size up at least one size (or 2 if you have wider feet.)

My husband has worn these for the past 20+ years. We normally buy at a surf shop, but couldn't find these exact ones so we decided to order from Zappos. He has a 9 1/2 wide foot and usually wears a 10, but these barely fit the length of his foot. Ordered a bigger size for him, will keep these for myself (they fit perfect and I wear an 8.5 women's).

Very comfortable, but runs small and a little narrow (compared to the previous Reefs I've owned along with the Sanooks I ordered in same size/width in this same order)

These sandals run extremely small. I wear a women's size 9, which would usually be a men's size 7. In these, I needed a men's size 9.