Customer Reviews Naturalizer Legacy

I have extremely wide feet and high arch/instep. These actually fit, which is rare for a loafer-style shoe. Many loafers don't have enough room in the instep, even if they are wide enough for the rest of my foot. Not exciting to look at, but very comfortable. I also just bought Softwalk Montclaire, which I like a little better. More room in the instep and toe box.

I ordered the 8.5 Narrow, my usual size, and found them overly roomy. I was able to walk out of them and the heel slipped, but these are problems I encounter all the time in any brand shoe. I padded the ceiling of the shoe, put a slippery heel liner in them, and found that they're pretty comfortable as long as I don't expect them to cling to my feet. The heel slips like it does on my favorite Dansko clogs, but that's not necessarily bad (a clog heel is supposed to slip) and they were quite comfortable when the dog took me on a forced march this morning. I'm not crazy about the appearance when I look down at them, but they're not bad in the mirror. Obviously it's too soon for me to comment on long-term durability. Since these will be worn primarily with long pants on trips to colder climates, I think they'll be fine for that purpose. Summary: Not really narrow enough for narrow feet (needs modification); not particularly attractive, but way ahead of clogs; quite practical and unnoticeable, perfect for travel.

It looks exactly like the picture, soft leather, feminine slip-on with a little heel. It's good for everything between office and daily errands. Comfort: It's squishy enough all around to feel like winter slippers, a very comforting feeling. The odd thing is I think the shoe needs better arch support, and my feet are almost flat. Overall: Very good shoe that will fit almost anyone's foot and wardrobe.

As always, Naturalizer is very comfy. I ended up with the Legacy because they stopped making the Mae. These are a little more casual than I was looking for, but they’re close. Very cushy insole.

I purchased this shoe in my actual size - 1/2 size larger and it was still too narrow in the toes. Also, a little "plain" or "mature" looking once on foot, but seems like it would be very comfortable if you could get the right size/width. Great padding on inside of shoe.