Customer Reviews Minnetonka Cally Slipper

These are incredibly cute, but do seem to run about 1/2 size too big. It makes sizing difficult because they only come in whole sizes.

This slipper feels very nice with nice material but has a super strange fit. I have a size 7.5/8 foot and when I put the size 7 slipper on it flopped right off my foot, which I was not expecting. It definitely fits wide, which doesn't work for me because I have a narrow heel. And the toe box is very short so that doesn't help it stay on. I know slippers aren't supposed to have an exact fit, but these wouldn't work for me at all.

They stretched out in the width fairly quickly and are now floppy on my average-width feet. But the biggest annoyance is that, despite being loose and floppy, the back sections come up very high on the top of the heels, and the slippers rub against the tendons behind my ankles when I walk. It's a little painful! It's a shame that this area doesn't stretch out, but it contains the cording so I suppose it can't. I think it's a design flaw that I would have noticed if I had tried them on before buying them. I won't buy Minnetonka slippers again.

Thought Minnetonka was a good brand, but was very disappointed. Should have spent more money and got something I really liked. Too short (but stretched), too wide, top part did not come up far enough on foot. Needed them in a hurry, and wore them right away, or I would have returned them immediately.

The leather strings broke after a couple of months. That was a big problem. I couldn't wear them anymore. I was bummed.

These slippers are wide. I ordered, and the box says, narrow but even with thick socks, they are wide. They are also too long for me - I wear a 10-10½, ordered an 11 and my heel slips out entirely when I walk. I am sad though, they are lovely and cozy slippers in a gorgeous color. The 10 is too small and the 11 is too large. I feel like Goldilocks.

I wear 8-8.5 and I ordered an 8 and it was way too big. They are cute, but they gotta go back. Bummer.

Love the last 2 pair I've had but for some reason the newest pair are causing blisters in the back of my heel. Hoping they just need some breaking in but kind of a bummer!

Price so much better than Uggs; and the shoe is quite comfy -- except toe space to short. Top part of shoe does not come down far enough on my foot so I can walk without stepping out of them.

These slippers are just odd. When I put them on they feel like I have the right and left switched, and I am having to check to be sure I haven't. The toe box is pretty narrow, and the rest of the show is wide, making them slip easily. I will return and look for another pair of moccasin slippers with more comfort. My last pair were Tamaracs, and are worn down, but fit much better from the start.

These slippers are really warm and comfortable, but they stretched so much after a few wears that I cannot wear them anymore without slipping off (and I cannot return them either). I am so disappointed. Definitely order down a size. Even if a little tighter, they really stretch.

Strange fit for me. It was the right length but the backs slipped off when I walked. When I added a sock, the backs stayed on but it was too cramped up front.

Purchased these and now returning. I wear an 8 in normal shoes and 8.5 in boots and athletic shoes. The 8 was swimming on my foot. The inside fur was not very soft. Going to get Uggs instead.

I ordered these slippers in the red color. I was very excited to get them because my current slippers are falling apart. I tried them on and the two slippers fit completely differently! The left is snug and my right foot is swimming in the slipper. I thought I was crazy at first because they even looked different. The toe on the left slipper looked more pointed and the right more rounded. I took a ruler and measured a couple of places along both slippers and found the right one was bigger by up to 1/4" in some spots. I really do like the look of them, and the lining is super furry and warm. I'm going to order another pair and hope this one pair is just a fluke.

Yes, they are nice. I wish the material was more strongly made (not so bendable). But they are okay.

These are comfy when wearing, but when I take them off my feet hurt SO MUCH. Feels like I've twisted my ankle or something. Maybe due to the lack of arch support, or because they are too wide that I twist my feet and walk funny in order to get them to stay on my feet? Not really sure, but I've noticed the trend that when I wear these, my feet hurt afterwards. Ugh!

Too big. I'm a solid 8 and bought these in an 8 but they are too long and came off the back of my heels. I'd definitely need a 7 but, they weren't even that cute, so I'm just going to return them. They are overly wide at the toe and are unflattering.

My daughter wanted these for her 15th birthday. She usually wears a 7 1/2 or 8 in shoes. We tried the 8 which was a bit too long in the toe, but much too wide, they were falling off. We exchanged for the 7, which was much too short. Her big toe curled under. No way that would work. The width was about right in the 7, just too short. I personally think the soles on these slippers are not going to hold up for wearing outside as she wants, and the quality of the entire shoe did not seem any better than inexpensive Target mocs. These are marked as mainly indoor slippers from what I read, but this is the style my daughter likes. I wanted her to get the Minnetonka pile lined hardsole, as these get 5 stars and look as if they are perfect for outside and get great reviews for comfort and cute looks, along with durability! Alas, she refused. We'll have to try another brand.

I love the shoe. I love Zappos. Unfortunately they were too tight and small. I ordered a size eight, which is my normal size. It was tight. It made me sad to return them. I am a loyal loving Zappos customer. They are so fair in all areas of their business.

I wear a shoe size 8 1/2 - 9 so I ordered a 9 and it was way to small. So I ordered a 10 because no 1/2 size and they are to big, I tightened the string, helped a little. Love the slipper, I just need a 9 1/2!

I have to say I was disappointed with these slippers. They are well made, but feel stiff. The sole is good quality but thin. Mostly, it is far smaller in size. I was hoping the leather would stretch and they'd be fine, but it doesn't. I wish I had returned them and spent more on better slippers. Zappos, however is always 5 star in their service.

The slippers run a little tight/small. I normally wear an 8 1/2 and the size 9 is too small, especially with socks on. Very average slippers, not overly comfortable.

I was so excited to get these comfy looking shoes, and they are cute, though a bit tight at the big toe. However, each shoe looked different, one curved out at the side of my foot and showed a lot of fur. Plus the laces looked a bit worn.

Love them, but they run big and not available in 1/2 sizes. I suggest ordering a size smaller.