Customer Reviews UGG Brookfield Tall

I've had these boots for over a year, wearing them daily in study-abroad in Paris and then almost daily during the winter months in Virginia and North Carolina. They are warm, although the leg part is definitely warmer than the feet -- you'll want to wear an extra pair of ankle socks. They are comfortable enough to wear walking around all day and are easy to slip in and out of. They're not the most professional-looking shoes, but they definitely work for warm, casual wear.

I've been searching for winter boots for years that were comfortable and nice looking and practical in snow/slush. These fit the bill. They are slightly smaller than I’d like so I can't wear thick socks but I wanted them to wear with my suits and dresses to work. They aren't clunky like a lot of practical boots that have a decent tread. They do look good under dress slacks. Order a 1/2 size larger or more depending on if you want to wear thick socks.

I was very excited to get these boots given the cold winter spells we’ve had thus far. I normally wear a 7, but decided to get a 7.5, which fit just right when not using the sheepskin soles. Once I inserted the sheepskin soles, however, the boot was too tight (too narrow). I felt that my foot was being squished against the ceiling of the boot. After all, I had ordered these boots because I wanted my feet to be warm. Much to my dismay I returned the boots and am not sure if I’ll try getting an 8.

I really like these boots. They weren\'t quite as high as I would have liked and there is no arch support, which I would have liked, but I still like them. They are warm and very comfortable. Very pleased.

I bought these boots along with the Ugg tall Brooks. These Brookfield tall boots look really cute, an equestrian-type boot. However, they are not warm. There isn't any shearling in the foot bed. You can use the shearling foot pad that comes with them, but the top of your foot pressed up against leather. I like the Ugg type boots because I do not like to wear socks. These you definitely need to wear socks. I usually wear a size 8 and the size 8 in the Brookfield fit fine with a thin to medium sock. The Brooks are not as cute as the Brookfield; they have a wider foot bed with a lug sole; however, they are warm. They fit well without a sock. It was a toss-up, but comfort won out over style. I am keeping the Brooks and returning the Brookfields.

The boots do come in a little narrow, but if you wear them around the house they will loosen up. I would suggest getting your actual size, though, because mine have widened out enough that I could wear my true size.

Dress 'em up or down - I purchased the Ugg Brookfield and the Santana Vermont at the same time; while the Santana was very open about being waterproof (which I wanted) I decided to keep these Uggs instead. While I've not worn them out in full-blown rain or snow and still don't know the waterproof level, I must say that I'm very happy with them. As other reviewers have said, they are a bit snug when you first wear them, but after a few wears they stretch and loosen. Mine are quite comfortable now. I got an 8.5 (normally wear and 8) and while I’ve got plenty of toe area, they still are a bit narrow so it works. I wear them over and under jeans - and that's REGULAR jeans. I'm not into that skinny jean business so I was happy to finally find a boot that looks ok over regular jeans. That said, I think they would still look good with skirts and skinny jeans as the circumference is not too big.

I usually love the feel of Uggs - I expected the full inside to be lined as most of Ugg boots are. This style was not lined in the foot where the leather is. Arch is too flat.

Great looking - not so warm or comfortable - I LOVE the way these boots look, but they are not nearly as warm as other reviewers described. Also, when I think "Uggs" I think "warmth" and "water resistant" so I was a bit disappointed to find that these included instructions to steer clear of wet conditions -- and that they were not nearly as warm as I had hoped. The sheepskin lining does not cover the top of the foot, and the leather is very thin (though pretty) and thus does little to retain heat. I don't wear them "naked" -- but with lightweight wool socks. The tread is great on slick conditions, but these are FALL (not WINTER) boots in my neck of the woods.

Great fit right out of the box. Toe, foot and arch are very comfortable with the inserts. Sheepskin lining is so soft. I only need to bulk up my skinny heel to prevent the tiny slippage. Terrific boot to match with skirts. Uggs and Zappos - a great combination!

I love my Uggs - Although I use it without the inserts. They are very warm and comfy, and the toe space is perfect for long-haul flights and touring.

Good, basic boot - Love this boot, good for SF climate. Fit on foot is snug, but loosens with wear. Could have better arch support, but not a big deal for me.

No comparison to the Brooks (old style) I bought these boots to replace my old Ugg Brooks boots that are finally wearing out after nearly constant wear over the past 4 winters. These boots are nothing like the Brooks that they replaced! The sheepskin on the shaft is very thin and feels flimsy. The foot is not lined in sheepskin at all - the only sheepskin in the foot part is the removable insoles. Nothing on the toes, sides/tops of the feet, just plain leather. They also pinched my feet, even though I ordered the same size (8) as my old boots. So I'd say they run small. They just don't feel like quality and definitely are not warm enough for a Massachusetts winter.