Customer Reviews KEEN Wear Around Mary Jane

I have them in every color. I have narrow heels and the elastic in the heel leather really helps it fit snugly and not move up and down. These seem to run a half size small, but if you get the larger size you will love them.

I love these shoes. I love Keens in general but they are usually big on my heel and slip while walking. In these the elastic eliminates that problem. It took a couple of days for the elastic to become comfortable, but now I wear them all the time and love them. I bought the port and am thinking of getting the black too.

Nice, but didn't fit - These run about half a size small and tend to be pretty wide, my feet kept popping out of them when I tried to walk in them. Too bad, b/c they looked cute.

Luv my Keen's Mary Jane - While I'm not very happy with the dull look of my Keen's, I do love comfort of the shoe itself. I have a large foot and the shoe feels absolutely wonderful. But I'm gonna have to do something to give the shoe a little shine. Not, high gloss though, just a little shine. A shoe polish or some Lemon Pledge. lol

My New Favorite Shoe - These are easily the most comfortable shoes I've ever worn. They are light weight and flexible but still provide a lot of support. And, for a comfortable shoe, they're pretty cute too. Love them!

Marvelous Mary Janes! I really like the look of these shoes. Had to have them! The first few times I wore them, they were very comfortable. Then there was a short time with sore spots on the back of both heels--went away after a few days. Now they are my absolutely favorite shoes. I want more! I did order a half size bigger than I normally wear and the fit was just right.

Awesome Shoes!!! These shoes are very comfortable which was what I was looking for. There was a break in period of about 4 days for the back of my heel as these shoes reach higher than most. I cannot wait to buy another pair of Keen shoes, I love these so much.

I love the shoe, the toe box, and the comfort, however the elastic at the heel doesn't give, and by the time I take them off I have a red spot and tenderness. Heel protectors don't stick due to the elastic - so it is a catch 22.

Cute shoes, but a little disappointing - So I bought these in a 9 since I usually wear an 8.5/9 and I read that they ran a little small. I also bought a pair of Keen Sienna's. So I was surprised that the Wear Around Mary Jane's were about a half size big and the Sienna's (same company, same size) fit true to size. When I tried walking around in my house, they were fine if I walked slowly, but I walked quickly (as you sometimes have to do when you have a six year old kiddo) they flopped right off the back of my foot. Then because the back is elasticized, the back of the shoe slipped under my heel for me to step on. I can tell that this is not going to work for me. Also, the leather between the rubber toe and the rest of the shoe is a matte leather, making me think that it might looked scuffed earlier than the rest of the shoe. Overall, it is a cute shoe, but the construction is making me plan on just returning the shoe and not ask for another size. Thanks to Zappos for making online shoe buying so easy!

Great shoe that goes casual and dressy. As a Keen fan, I was pleased with this shoe. Nice shoe with great looks. This shoe is comfortable, but I would recommend medium weight socks as the back of the heel rubs in low cut or thinner socks. Also, even though the shoe feels true to size, it also has a tendency to slip off the back of the foot i.e. if you stand on tip toe. Otherwise, I was very pleased with the shoe. It is comfortable and goes well with jeans and with casual dress. This shoe does not have as much arch support as other Keen styles, but again seemed comfortable to wear.

Comfortable all day shoes - At first I was a bit worried that these shoes would rub my heels, but after wearing them with socks, they are just fine without them. I got the purple color, and the dye would bleed into my socks, and even onto my toes. I have other Keens, and these have a different insole, not as pronounced as with other models I have.

I've had the same problems as other reviewers from the elastic digging into my heels. I had painful cuts on both heels the first time I wore these. I've had these shoes about a month and a half, and the left shoe is great now, but the right shoe is still awful unless I wear a band-aid. Other than that, the shoe is nicely made and looks great. The shoe fits a little narrower than many other Keens, but the leather is nice and will stretch. I ordered my normal size, which works, but I think it might have helped going up half a size. Overall, length and width seem similar to Siennas.

As an educator on my feet most of the day, I needed a shoe that would provide comfort, style, as well as not hurting my bunions. This shoe, although not hurting my bunions, has an issue with the heel. I am having to break them in as the lip of the heel is very stiff and cuts into my heel. I think that once that area is loosened up, the shoe will fit great. Otherwise the shoe is great.

These are my eighth pair of Keens and I am a major fan. These shoes are adorable but do not have the arch support that the other Keens do. I also am having trouble with heel blisters due to the elastic on the back. HOWEVER, they look so cute with skirts, capris and pants, and I am willing to work through the blister phase. Also, I probably should have ordered a half size up, that may have helped. Just purchased a pair of Siennas and they also do not have the arch support but do not have the blister issue either. They are so comfortable I could sleep in them!

Runs short - These shoes are cute and feel very light and comfy on, though I didn't get a chance to do any real walking in them because they seem to run about a half-size short. I am a 61/2-7, ordered the 7, and my toes were smushed up against the end of the shoe.

In a 6, I could run two fingers around the edge inside it was so loose and still the elastic at the raised back edge bit into my Achilles tendon.