Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Aragon Kiltie Tassel Loafer

Purchased my normal size. Shoes were tight in the toe box and loose at the heel. Not wearable. Great looking shoe, but when shoes are made in these third world countries the quality is lacking.

I have ordered 11 wide sizes in your other shoes/boots before with a great fit. However, this pair pinches my feet. I know a pair of stretch devices, and I have put my new shoes into them. Not entirely satisfied, to be honest.

This is a decent shoe but it's a far less attractive substitute for the wonderful Breland Kiltie Tassel (I have been buying them for over 30 years) that you have recently discontinued. These Aragons are the last shoes I will be purchasing from JM since I will have to find someone else that provides a shoe closer to the dressy style of the Brelands.

Fits and looks are good. Happy with these for many years. However, there is a thin, but essential, plastic piece sandwiched between lower sole and the body of the shoe. This turned brittle with time and fell out in large chunks. Not really repairable, so end of shoes. If they haven't replaced the plastic with leather, then be prepared for shorter life than other brands. I would still buy if the price is right.

Too narrow

looks nice but tassel was splitting apart - which I fixed.

Seems to be a little small. Did a stretcher and now fits pretty well. But still tight across the top of the foot. Hoping with wear this will dissipate.

The little piping around the top of the foot is made of plastic (or extremely thin leather) that wears off within a year or two. It ruins the shoe completely. I have two pair of these shoes and it's a problem on both of them. If you buy one, be aware that this will not last. You will have replace them within 24 months.

The sole has been change which gives it a much rough feel when walking . Suggest you go back to leather with the rubberized inset. Seems to rune a bit small but nut enough to return.

Not the quality that they used to be, but they are still comfortable, nice-looking shoes at a good price.

Trouble walking in these shoes. I like the shoes but they are not comfortable

The heels came off joe pagano 201 9541990

Not wide enough.

I really love the style of these shoes but they are soooooo tight I've only worn them 3 times in the five months I've had them!! I have two pairs of your golf shirts maybe the most comfortable I've ever had. I d like to get a wider lister in the same style but I haven't seen anything in recent catalogs. Your ordering staff was just helpful when I placed the orders what's my next step?

If anyone else has the same size requirement, please chime-in so that Johnston & Murphy can see the unmet need.

I have been a Johnson & Murphy customer for the last 30 plus years. For some reason this particular shoe style Size 12 Medium Width does not fit comfortably. Hard to get on and take off and not comfortable wearing. Will be calling customer service today to see if I can exchange for a 12 Size Wide Width.

Low quality shoe

Normally wear 10 1/2 M size, but it's really tight. Hope it will break in.

The shoe was tight from the start. I thought it would relax some over time, but it hasn't. Not very comfortable.