Customer Reviews Justin Gemma

These shoes were big and clunky. Not feminine or fun. More like rodeo clown.

I have a pair of Ariat Fat Baby's that I really like and the reviews of the Gemma sounded good so I thought I would give them a try. I ordered my usual size and both the length and width are fine. I love the Shetland color. It's a deep brown with red undertones. I'll bet it will get more beautiful with age. Comparing the Gemma to the Russet Rebel Fat Baby: I have to say they are indeed very close. I think the Gemma is a little deeper in the toe box (from foot bed to toe leather); the Fat Baby's foot bed is a little more cushioned and has the tiniest bit more arch support. I don't know if the Gemma's leather is thinner than the Ariat, but it does feel more pliable. I think they will break in much faster. They are both very cute and comfortable boots. The Gemma is a little less expensive too. I would recommend them!

These boots were super comfortable right out of the box. I had a pair of Ariats in this similar style that needed to be replaced, when I bought the exact boot, they were horribly uncomfortable and couldn't even be worn in the house to try out. So, I've switched to Justin's and have been very pleased. I love the rich brown color and the colorful stitching. Can't believe how comfy these are. Usually there's some digging in the ankle or rubbing somewhere, but not with these. They are a wide round toe but fit nicely with a thick sock. Love.

Awesome boots! Love them. Exactly as pictured. Got the last size 7 available and they are perfect. Really comfortable.

Normally wear 8 1/2 but toe touched end so went up size. Absolutely adorable

Love this boots they’re very comfortable and very cute looking

Love them.. just what I wanted

Cute little boot! Great fit out of the box, snug as a boot should be, easy on, easy off and very comfortable. You do need a sock as the handles to pull them up can be abrasive to your leg, I imagine that as they get worn they'll soften up. Don't hesitate to get these boots, they are adorable.

Best boots I have ever bought. Great feel. Love them

Fit perfect. Love them. arrived early. Wore them for 8 hours today. well worth the money.

Ordered these boots because of a recommendation from a friend. They were comfortable right out of the box and just what I wanted! Excellent support...I was running with my horse the first time I wore them and they were so comfy. And, of course, they came so quickly...yay Zappos!!

I have three pairs of these now. I got a 7 and a 7.5 years ago and never returned the ones that didn't fit. After having two babies, my feet have decided to stay their current larger size and my boots no longer fit. I tried 3-4 other pairs and they all felt too tight/narrow. So I got another pair of these in size 8. They fit great! I'm keeping the other boots for when my three year old daughter is old enough (and has feet big enough) to wear them.

I purchased these in an 8 1/2 and a nine. I returned the 9. I always wear my boots w/medium to heavy socks and the fit is perfect. Very comfortable from the first wearing! No break-in required.

I had gotten to the dreaded moment. Time to buy new boots. I shopped and shopped and settled on these as my new Christmas boots. They arrive, I tear open the box, held them up and thought that I had ordered a child's boot. There was no way that these boots would fit But they fit perfectly. They are so wonderful I am wearing them with my pajamas on running up and down the stairs and halls. My big old feet (9½) look small. I am never taking them off! They are comfortable right out of the box.

Love. These. Boots. Oh my. I have wide feet with high insteps, my feet are so in love with these boots. And they are really snazzy to boot! (snicker). Seriously, these are my "go-to" footwear, and I get lots of compliments on them too! Well made.

My first pair of Justin boots and I am SO HAPPY with them! Ordered a 10 since my 9.5 feet need to slide in and I'll be wearing thicker socks. The fit is great and the comfort level is much better than my other brand of high end boots! At this time I am still wearing them without my tradition orthodics which is is not traditional for me!

Best boots I've ever bought! I've had them 4 years now and they just don't wear out! Fantastic buy.

Nothing like a good pair of boots! These fit like they were made for me! Easy to put on and off...no boot jack needed. Absolutely love them!

Loved the "aged bark" colored boot. No break-in time. Super looking for work and casual. Ordered "agua cow" and returned them. Comfort was there, but they were somewhat garish. Not for me.

My daughter loves these boots. We go to a dude ranch for spring break and she can't wait to wear these boots there!

I honestly love these shoes! Didn't think that I would like the shortness of them but it's amazing! I wear them under my jeans and it doesn't rube!

I absolutely love these boots. I wear this pair and my brown pair equally the same. The Gypsy style is my favorite. So far, I have had no problems with either pairs. I did add some waterproofing spray to them so I can wear them throughout the winter and not have wet feet! An Idaho girl must have a pair of Justin Gypsy boots. It just makes sense!

These are great boots! I just ordered another pair of them. Not sure if it is just a one time thing but the pair it looks like they have modified their sizing slightly because I ordered the same pair of boots in the same size and they are too small. The use to run big but it looks like they actually run true to size now.

These boots came within 3 days of me ordering them! I loved the style of the boots; they look exactly like they do in the picture. The only problem I had was that I am normally a 8 1/2-9 in shoes, but the 8 1/2 was a little to wide. My heel keeps popping up, but with some thicker socks, the problem is solved! I'd be too concerned that the size 8 would be too small length wise.