Customer Reviews Steve Madden Reilly

Grrr! Got in black, size 9. I LOVE this pair of shoes; they're so perfect, even for my big flat arch-less feet. I wore them with medium thickness stockings and was comfortable. The previous reviewer is right, probably not meant to be worn sans socks/tights. My only regrets: 1) I need a more fabulous lifestyle so I can wear this more; 2) I wish I could buy the black/white one too...

Don't blame the shoe--it might be your foot or the size - I ordered these in black/white and natural. There was no bad smell inside the box, and the natural DID NOT have a greenish tinge--it is true beige linen. (Note to other reviewer: have your eyesight checked.) I ordered my exact size. There was no slippage of my back heels. I wear them to work, and they are perfectly comfortable without pinching all day. They are best worn with trouser socks or tights. This is too heavy a shoe to wear barefoot or with thin nylons, so please resist the urge to do this then blame the shoe for your discomfort. Like all high heels, I don't recommend walking in them continuously for several hours straight. I could walk across a mall or parking lot with no pain.

Stunning - More positive comments on this shoe than any I own. Absolutely true to size, very comfortable. I ordered the black and white combo, very attractive shoe, and of course the shipping is second to none.

Love these shoes - I love these shoes; they are comfortable, fit perfectly. The heel was not a problem, worn them all day. The girls I work with love them. Would order another pair.

Love the look - Love the color. The gray is perfect to wear with charcoal. The heels were a little too high if you stand on your feet all day.

These R NICE!!!! I like the shoes...I’m 5'9 and I love high heels...so these r perfect. Short heels make my feet feel weird, but I ordered my natural size and they don’t flop off nor are they too tight...they fit just fine on my feet. Thumbs up Steve Madden.

Great Shoe! Once again, a great shoe from Steve Madden. I have this shoe in the black and gray. The gray is actually a little lighter than what is shown in the picture, it’s more of a medium gray than a dark gray. I gave the comfort a 4 because by the end of the day your feet will probably be sore. However, I was surprised with the high heel and short pointy toe I was actually able to do wear them all day at work. I am an 8 1/2 in Steven Madden and that is exactly what I ordered and they fit great. I got a ton of compliments on the gray ones! Thanks Zappos for the overnight shipping! Great customer service.

Absolutely love ‘em. Beware of the way the wine multi looks online. The patent leather is more of a brownish-burgundy color, but still, this is my absolute favorite pair of shoes. I wore them to a meeting with an admissions advisor at a fashion institute and I swear, I think they sealed the deal. These shoes make a bold statement without going overboard. Love ‘em! PS. I wouldn't recommend trying to walk long distances in them. The toes begin to feel a little tight after walking a while in San Francisco.

Lovin it!! The shoe is great, great fit, great comfort, great quality. It looks great with jeans or dress pants. Love them!

Cute shoes - Loved the look online, extremely cute. They were just too tall for me.

One of the most comfortable 4+ inch high shoes ever. Great fit, true to size. Walkable, no sliding. Great purchase.

Steve Madden - I wore this shoe for the first time yesterday. This shoe really complemented my outfit. I ordered a 1/2 size up by listen to the other reviews. They are just a little big, but with socks they fit fine. I think if I had of order the 81/2 it would have been tight. The only bad thing I have to say about this shoe was by the end of my work day my little toe started to hurt, but overall great shoe, I will continue wearing them even if though I have to wear socks.

I am originally a size 8, but because they didn’t have my size and I got a 9 and I have to return them because they are way too big. But they are really cute. I always wear heels that are 3 inch and up and because the heels of these are REALLY HIGH you can’t wear these big because your feet slide out when you walk. I have over 10 pairs of Steve Madden shoes and so I know how the sizes go and I say they are true to size....maybe a half size up if you have really, really wide feet, but I wouldn’t even recommend going a half size up. Get your original size because these types of shoes can’t be worn big or your feet will continuously fall out and you are going to wreck the pretty shoes.

Love Em! These shoes look even better in person than they do in the picture. I got the mauve ones and I'm really glad I did. My only concern is comfort, because holy cow is this heel high. I always wear high heels, so I never gave it a second thought, but they are HIGH. I can't wait until it gets a bit chillier out so I can wear them!

A Perfect Way to Fall In With Style. I ordered these in the wine multi which look great! They go perfectly with slacks and can even dress up a pair of jeans. I found them to run true to size as I ordered a 9 1/2 than returned them for the 9 which fit perfectly.

The perfect modern heeled oxford! There is a very fine line between looking fashionable and looking frumpy when it comes to the brogue/heeled oxford look. Steve Madden nailed the fashionable look with this style. The pointed toe simply makes the shoe. The heel is sky high, but I don't have any trouble walking… thanks to the slight platform. If you are looking for a comfortable style to stand in all day, this isn't it. For going out though, I think Reilly is a must-have. I usually wear a 9.5, but ordered the 10 because I had read it ran small. I'm glad I sized up. I could have even gone another 1/2 size larger if it existed.

The best of the oxford pumps for fall! When I first saw these shoes while walking the gilded halls of Nordstrom, I immediately fell in love. I adore the combination of high-sheen patent leather accents with the fabric of the shoe. I adore the fact that, unlike most high-heeled oxfords I've seen on tap for fall, they don't go up to your ankles and cut off the leg. There is adequate foot cleavage here to elongate your legs so that they will look good with just about anything. In the past few weeks it's become very apparent that high-heeled oxfords will be important for this fall, and in my opinion, these really are the creme de la creme of this style. A must-have if you are planning on sporting this trend!

Fabulous shoe! This is one of the classiest oxford styles I've seen with a perfect feminine edge. Extremely comfortable! I bought the wine and was disappointed when the black was gone in my size. This is going to be the perfect fall shoe to wear with jeans, slacks, skirts.

Steve Madden Reilly shoe - I bought this in the blk/wht parent and the natural - both good looking. The heel is wide and because of the height of the shoe, my heel is very loose (even with heel and tongue pads). While very sexy, this is not a shoe for much walking.

Sassy & Stylish - Super cute and distinctive shoes! I bought the grey/multi: beware that the grey patent is really much lighter than it appears online. It's definitely medium grey like the tweed, not nearly black like in the pic (the only reason I didn't give a 5 for looks). These shoes are fairly comfortable for being over 4" high. My heel does slip out a little too easily, but that can be easily fixed with some heel gripper inserts. All said I'm very happy with Reilly!

Adorable - but NOT made for comfort! I fell in love w/the Reilly immediately, and I HAD to have them. You absolutely have to get them in the right size or else you'll have problems. Like the one reviewer said, because the heel is so high, if you get them too big, your heel will be flopping out all the time - which is the case for me. But Steve Madden doesn't make shoes small enough for my (ridiculously) tiny feet! They were also very unconformable - not because of the heel height, which is not an issue for me - but just in general. I only had them on for about 15 minutes, in the house, and on carpet, and my feet hurt in strange places. As gorgeous as these are, 15 minutes on carpet just isn't going to cut it. I'll do a lot of things to look cute, but that's a bit much!

This is a great looking shoe. Very classic, but funky at the same time. I ordered a 9 initially because that usually works for me in a closed shoe. Not this time. Too tight. I had to go up a half size. If that doesn't work, I'll go up to a 10...I like them that much.

Too cute - These oxford heels are fabulous...esp. for this fall!!! Like any new shoes, I’m still working on breaking them in. They just rub against my ankle a bit but other than that they’re pretty comfy b/c of the platform heels. I got these in black and I feel so tall in them! Love em'! I would wear these with short shirt or knee length skirt; slacks will hide the whole shoes and that's what I want to show off. :)

Naturally...Green? I just received this shoe in Natural Multi and the look leaves much to be desired. The linen looks nothing like the photo; it has an odd green tinge to it that looks completely unnatural. Too bad because these are so cute.

I've been wearing these great boots for almost 6 years now. The leather looks nice with a vintage appearance. Frye harness boots are durable and stylish. The age adds more character to my boots and looks manly with bootcut jeans. Zappos is the real deal when it comes to shoes and boots. Lightning speed delivery is outstanding.