Customer Reviews Sperry Billfish 3 Eye

A very ill fitting shoe. Not nearly as comfortable as the original Topsider boat shoe. You are better off with a good running shoe.

The foot bed and finish on the inside of this particular shoe was rough and there was a big noticeable transition where the back part of the insole was sewn to the front part of the insole. Rather disappointing in terms of construction quality.

I have particular feet and they don’t like the Billfish. I had to get the Tarpon model (I think they have been discontinued) as they seem to be the ones that make my feet smile. I tried to make the Billfish work and wore for several days and since they have slight wear I’m sure they are not returnable.

They are hopelessly too narrow to be EEE. There is no last on them, the shoes are almost dead straight. Obviously made for Asian or narrow Euro feet. I have sent them back. Had 2Es and 3Es before, current pair is 2E and over half an inch wider than these that are supposed to be 3E.

I always wear 9 wide. This shoe was at least a half to a full size too large. I thought it was a mistake. My big toe was more than an inch from the end of the toe box. I returned the pair.

Ive been wearing sperry boat shoes for almost 40 years and always have at least two pairs in my closet. I've had many styles of boat shoes. Sad to say these particular ones are the most uncomfortable boat shoes Ive ever had. The leather is hard and almost seems wax coated so the looks are so-so. The shoes is very still and interior foot bed is abrasive. I really cant walk in the for more than a few minutes. Sperry does not sell replacement footbeds. My 10 year old gold cup footbed feels better. So I have not yet thrown out either my old gold cup shoes or my old original billfish. After this summer is over these new billfish will get tossed and I will look for something new next spring. Waste of money. Since I've had so many great sperry boat shoes over the years it never crossed my mind to try these out indoors first so I could return them.

Fit was off for the size 9.5 WW on the pair I received for my husband -- way too long for the size. Returned and purchased same size, same style at local shoe store which fit perfectly.

Shoes are delaminating from the soles to the leather uppers. Total junk . Never wore them on a boat, just casual outings.

Super super uncomfortable shoe. I thought after wearing them twice they would break in but they are definitely the most uncomfortable shoe I ever owned. I wish I could return them for a different show. The color, dark tan, looks nothing like the picture as well. It should be called just tan.

This shoe has never fit correctly. I had to send the shoes back 2-3 times and now I'm stuck with the last pair. Hard to buy shoes over the internet.

My husband has the shoes pictured but apparently Sperry changed the shoes. They are not the same. Very narrow and the rubber sole digs into the arch. unwearable. Guess we won't be buying these again.

Fell apart within 2 months. My son loved these for style & comfort. Unfortunately, the upper began to separate from the sole. Not durable at all.

This shoe, made in China, smelled of pungent chemicals immediately upon opening the box. I left it out of the box to "air out" but the odor remained. The odor gave me a headache and a feeling of nausea. If it continue I will consider my remedies.