Customer Reviews Eastland 1955 Edition Classic II

The loafers had plenty of style, but one shoe felt a half size smaller. The width was fine but my heels flopped around when I walked. These shoes were not consisted in size with each other. I'm sorry I had to return them.

Did not like how this shoe looked - just lacked style. Not what I was looking for.

heel slipping out when walking

I was disappointed that the shoes were way too big. I will be returning them for a smaller size.

These shoes are designed for a very straight feet. They were too wide for my heel and too narrow for the ball of my foot. Otherwise, they appear to be well-made, but I chose to return them because they didn’t fit well.

It was too big, exchanged for a 6.5.

Sort of cute and functional for casual wear but no support. Felt flimsy.

The color on the website was not representative of the actual color. It appears as a light tan but it is actually a dark brown.

Fit was poor. I have to return them, but there is a problem I have never encountered before with Zappos. The shoes arrived in a box that had a paper inside that said it had been repacked because it had been damaged. There was no sales slip or return slip. Not sure what I should do to return! Need help!

This is a very nice shoe but just didn't fit my foot properly. It was slightly too big and it had a gap on the inside edge that didn't look right on my foot.

The heel is too wide and my foot slips out.

I have worn the shoes around my home for a week, with socks, without socks. My biggest complaint is the shoes do not fit my narrow heel and therefore I have trouble keeping the shoes on or they rub the heel causing a painful experience. Since most shoes now do not make heel sizes to fit your feet as they did years ago, And even to find a narrow shoe is next to impossible, as the width of most shoes is medium. I guess I will have to live without wearing this type of shoe ever again. My mistake. However, having said that I certainly like the style of the shoe, it is well made and would have been just what I wanted. I wear size 7 1/2.

I've always been a solid size 6 in my shoes but now that I'm approaching 50 years old, I'm not sure if my feet are getting bigger but the size 6 was at least a size or half size too small. I'm sad. I wore these shoes throughout 7th grade and into my early 20s and loved them to death. Alas, this size 6 is going back. I will say that the leather was great, as I remembered, and is flexible. Not quite moccassin-level but not horse saddle tough.

After measuring my feet I decided on the size I ordered. I could hardly get them on and when I did they seemed small. The material seems cheap and looks cheap.

First pair normal size 8.5 was absurdly long. Tried 8W and they were too small and VERY narrow. The left one looked a bit “off” as it seemed to curve the wrong way. The width would have loosened up with break-in but the toe was painfully short. Horrible sizing. Crushed to return them.

The shoes are well made. The leather is stiff, and would most likely soften over time, however, they are very narrow. My feet would not have been able to survive the break in period to attempt to get them somewhat comfortable. Sadly, they are going back today.

I really like loafers, but have a narrow heel. Bass-generally stopped making narrow widths, and the few styles they make sell out quickly. Sebago Plaza had a nice shoe, but discontinued it, and the narrow widths are unavailable. This is the first time I've tried an Eastland. It is narrow along the foot, but unlike the other two manufacturer's the heel does not correspond to a AA. My foot was slipping, and for the price of the shoe, I should not have to buy a heel insert, and they are more and more difficult to find anyway. It's a stylish shoe, but if you have narrow heels, it is unlikely to fit properly unless you get an insert, or shuffle while you walk.

The shoe was very uncomfortable and slipped off my feet.

Too narrow, even the wide. Cute shoes but terrible fit - too snug (by a half a size) and far too narrow (even with a wide)

I really wanted a pair of loafers and had to buy these because they were the only ones that came in a narrow width. Unfortunately the shoe looks cheap with poor quality leather. The price is very reasonable so the quality is reflective of that price. I’ll be returning them.

I typically wear 7.5 but believe I purchased a 7 because it was recommended. These shoes actually look narrow to me, not wide. And, they were too small.

I have a very narrow heal. The shoe toe in the 8N was very narrow but the heal was too wide in comparison to the toe and wouldn't stay on my foot.

These shoes run a 1/2 size large. Nice looking shoes After exchanging for correct size I like them

The right shoe was too narrow.

Absolutely beautiful BUT painful across the big toe joint and a bit of heel slippage ..........I wanted to love these but couldn't. Returned.