Customer Reviews Eastland 1955 Edition Classic II

Eastland loafers- disappointing - The shoes I received in the Zappos order were not the same quality as the Eastland loafers I've purchased in stores. The leather is very thin and there is no arch support. Also, I ordered a wide size and it didn't fit. I am returning them.

I wear a size 8 and ordered an 8. It felt at least a whole size too small and too narrow. I couldn’t even get my foot into the shoe. Had to return.

When my regular size 8.5M was not available, tried size 8.5W. It was a bit too wide for me but luckily size 8.5M came available, so I ordered that. Sadly, this size was too narrow and hurting my left foot. Also, I've become actually stupefied by the fact that these shoes are claimed to be all leather - inside and out. I cannot believe they're not vegan leather, at best. Returned.

I ordered 9.5 wide, and received it. However, it was too big and the width was too small. I didn't like the material, very cheap.

they were way to big and I returned them.

They were quite narrow when marked as a wide width

The shoes are well made and nice looking. The color is a beautiful classic cognac/saddle tan. I wish I could keep them. Alas, they don't fit. I can sometimes get into a Wide if it's a D width, but this looked more like a C width. I couldn't get my foot into it. I'm disappointed, but that's on me for ordering the wrong size, not on the manufacturer or Zappos.

I ordered the wrong size! I have reordered in a 6.5 wide

Perfect

Very happy w the shoes and value

I have a pair of these in black, so comfortable!

I’ve been looking for the perfect pair of vintage penny loafers for some time now and these shoes are so perfect! I’m a guy and always wear a womens 10M or 41 Euro, these are marked on the shoe as a 10M / 42 euro however they fit exactly like a 41 should fit. I ordered the walnut color and I’m so happy they have just a tint of mahogany which is what I wanted. There is plenty of room in the toe box, no slip in the heel and the width was a normal medium however I put them on the shoe stretchers just to accelerate the normal stretching they would get from wearing them, that helped with that new tightness you get with new leather.

I got the size 6, they didn't look right on my feet. Well made.

too small very narrow

I need to exchange these shoes for a half size larger.

From the first time I wore them they felt like old favorites. Nice leather and style, they will be my go to shoe for shopping and casual social events. I love them!

No need to break these shoes in. Very comfortable from the start

These loafers are very cute and classy and will go with just about everything in your closet. They are very comfortable. I have normal feet, and wear a size 9M. The fit is very good.

I love my new penny loafers. They are a true classic and a great alternative to flats. They're soft and comfortable and look great with jeans .

Sadly, have to return both pairs. I think these are awesome loafers but sadly my foot is wider in the toe box than these would be comfortable for me to wear. Holding out for same shoes in a WIDE, if they make them! Wondered if they would stretch out very much. Am concerned that they might not. That's why I will hold out until they make them in a wider width.

I am very pleased

Old school classics-,love them - great with jeans or dress pants with vest.

Had to return. They were too big and there were no half sizes left