Customer Reviews KEEN Roatan

They need to come in half sizes. The 9 was just a little too small and the 10 was just a little too big. It's a problem for those of us with that long second toe! But, the shoes feel like socks on my feet. They are so comfy, besides the fit factor, but I kept them because I liked them so much!

Shoe's Okay - The shoe is comfortable, it stretches all over. I don't like the white stitching on a black shoe, but it has a modern look.

Soft shoe - Very soft and comfortable water shoe - however, will slide off if walking in water or waves.

Great Looking Skimmer... This little slipper shoe would be perfect if it had little more cushion in the heel. I couldn't wear it. It was way too flat feeling for me. I'm sure it would be fine for most people though. I also have heel spurs so I need plenty of bounce in the heel for protection. I was rather disappointed but not really surprised.

Cute and Comfy - I'm not sure if they're all that wide, or if they just feel a bit wides since they're Mary Jane-style instead of sock-style like most other water shoes; the breaking waves never took them off my feet. The biggest plus was that I was able to use my arch supports in these shoes, and that made them wearable even outside the water. Not really breathable, but I just went barefoot in the car, so no worries there.

Half sizes probably order down. This shoe only comes in full sizes. I am a 6.5W and bought this shoe last summer in the red in a 6. It was incredibly comfortable, my foot is hard to fit and the band across the front did not make my foot look wide, it actually looks very cute on. This summer, I thought I would try the next size up, as my toe touched the front on the six. The size eight was too big - due to the style and material of the shoe, the back heel plate sticks up and the stretchy material sinks in at the back if the shoe is too big, there was just no happy medium. I ended up getting the black (very cute and hard to find) in the six. I can wear this shoe all day, feel like I am barefoot without the pain and look great. The half size lower is a tiny bit snug, but still comfy. It would be spot-on perfect if it came in a half size.

Comfortable - I liked them. When I first tried them on I didn't think they would stay on. I bought them to wear in the water. But they stayed on no problem. They feel like you are wearing your favorite pair of house shoes out.

Great water shoe or casual shoe from Keen! This is a super comfortable stretchy shoe perfect for water sports, gardening, or everyday casual wear. My only complaint is that it slips off my heel a bit. The bright green color will be great for spring!

Comfortable, but not perfect - This is a comfortable shoe that is cuter than your typical water shoe. I used this shoe at my mother's vacation home on a lake. The beach is very pebbly. I found that when I wore these shoes in the water at the lake, they did not do a good job of keeping the pebbles out of my shoe as my other water shoes. My other water shoes come up higher on my foot. Thus, I found myself constantly having to take the shoe off to empty out the pebbles.

Weird shoes, but did what I wanted them to do well. I wanted these for kayaking, where regular Keen water sandals or Tevas are fine, but I prefer a thin sole that gives me more "feel." These are perfect for that. They feel short, but not uncomfortable, and the shortness gives them the snugness they need when wet. I didn't notice them at all when paddling and I can't say that about any other shoe. The orange is, well, very orange. If I fall out of the kayak, no one will miss my feet!

Great for Sailing - This is a great shoe for sailing as the grey bottom (bought in red) does not mark. Very comfortable but I would size up if they came in half sizes. This shoe is also great for the water but does not stay on if you try to swim in it. Overall a great shoe!

Great water shoe for getting in and out of a boat, wading, but not for swimming--heel slipped off, then the rest! Half sizes or narrow would help. LOVE the colors!

These are great water shoes! Unlike most, they don't get many rocks in them. They also have good traction, and are not bad for hiking. The only problem I had with them is that you can't tighten the strap... so they slipped off my feet a couple times in the water because they weren't tight enough (I have narrow feet though).

Love the look of the shoe. Would be nice if shoe was offered in 1/2 sizes though. Size 9 was too snug and size 10 too big.

Great for the water - These are great for a water sport-very grippy, but not very comfortable (as they are completely flat) for just walking around in.

Lightweight, soft water shoes - My experience is opposite other reviewers - I found these shoes to be a little too small. I normally wear an 8, and in this 8, my toes were rubbing against the edges. I felt it would be too uncomfortable when running around a water park all day, so I’m exchanging for an 8.5.

Great beach/pool shoe, several "cute" comments - even people who do not usually like the Keen styles. No problem walking to wherever wet place you are going. 4 instead of 5 stars due to sand getting in with no way out. Normally I wear 6 1/2 or 7, the 7 was just right after a couple of wears.

Super comfy, non-walking shoes - These are definitely not for a long walk. They are very comfortable, but have no support. These are truly a water shoe or a wear around the house and yard shoe. I like them, but will not wear them when I am doing a lot of walking.

I usually wear a 6 in Keen shoes because they run small, but the 6 in these was much too large. They felt floppy on my feet and I had to return them. Unfortunately there is no size 5 in the color I want. Too bad - I was looking forward to finally finding a water shoe that I liked. If a 5 becomes available in the color I want, I'll order them.

Funky comfort - I have been looking for a comfy Mary Jane style shoe in red for a long time. This shoe is lightweight, stylish, and durable. I wear it all day long at work, and the tootsies never tire!

Best looking water shoe I've owned - I generally dislike the look of water shoes,these were cute enough to wear from the beach to a casual restaurant. I wear a 7 1/2 so I wasn't sure which way to go because they are full size only. I strongly advise that you go up a half size, in my case to size 8 (the size 7 was way too short)...my toes still touched the front of the shoe but were not really uncomfortable. I am not a distance swimmer so I'm not sure how they would stay on in that situation but for running in and out of the water to play and to cool off they were fine.

A decent shoe - The styling of this shoe is what caught my eye (as did the other two pairs of Keen shoes I have!). I have been looking for a shoe that I can wear surf-fishing and kayaking. I've only tried this one fishing, and although it was easy to wear and comfortable (fast-drying, too)... it filled with sand! This is not the shoe's fault, of course, I have a feeling it will be better for kayaking, but I haven't tried it yet. A note about Zappos great service: I normally wear 9.5 in Keen shoes. I ordered the 9 in this one since it doesn't come in half-sizes. The 9 was too small. Rather than go through the return, refund, reorder process, I asked if I could do an exchange for the size 10 -- the 10s were at my house before I could get the 9s to the UPS store for return! (Love the pre-paid UPS label print-out option, too!)

Karen in Vermont - This is a great looking and feeling shoe. I haven't worn it to swim in yet, but as the other reviewer experienced, I have concerns it will stay on my feet. Normally I wear a size 10, but when I received these in 10 they felt as though the roominess would fill with water and become heavy and possibly fall off. So I reordered in a 9. (I ordered them last night and they were here this afternoon!) The 9 is snugger and my toe touches the end of the shoe, but because it's rubber and neoprene, it's pretty malleable. Probably a 9.5 would be perfect, but I'm going with the smaller size. I've seen all four colors because my daughter got a pair too and between us we tried them all. The colors appear a little stronger than on my screen; very pretty too. I hope these work for the price!

Cute but not comfortable - I ordered 2 colors, having read the reviews; I ordered half a size larger. The one pair fit well, the other was a bit too small. So the sizing is inconsistent in terms of length of the shoe. I like the look but I am afraid both pairs will go back because I need them for water aerobics and I do not think that the shoes will stay on my feet with vigorous movements.

All looks - no function - They float off your feet in the water! I'll be returning these shoes. Oddly, they are a combination of too short and too wide, in a sloppy kind of way.