Customer Reviews GUESS Carrie

Extremely Comfortable! The most comfortable shoe I have ever purchased. Fit is true to size. However, don't think the shoe will last very long-not well made.

Gorgeous but painful - I ordered this in a half size larger than I normally wear after reading other reviews. Unfortunately, these shoes were still painfully tight. My feet are somewhere between normal and wide and I can usually wear Guess shoes without a problem. I would have loved to keep them and even ordered them in 2 colors (note: the yellow suede is REALLY yellow and not close to n‏ude at all), and am all for suffering to a moderate extent for beauty...but these were impossible. The suede seemed to give more than the leather but the color was all wrong so both pairs are going back. The shoe is very sexy and versatile but I could not last very long in them. I would recommend these only for the narrowest of feet.

I don't know how anyone could say these are comfy - I could barely walk around my apartment in them let alone try them outside of the house! They are a beautiful shoe and I'm soo disappointed that I have to return them because I don't want to risk breaking my neck. BTW-I do wear heels all the time so that is not the issue. These are like walking on your tip toes.

Painful and narrow, but hot as a blazing arrow - I bought these in yellow after reading so many positive reviews. I was sad to find them too narrow and uncomfortable. I am returning them - LOVE Zappos easy return policy!

Disappointed - When I saw the shoe I thought it was beautiful. When I read the reviews I was even more convinced to buy it...so I did...now I'm returning them. First of all, there is a lot of room between your foot and the top of the shoe. My toes were on top of each other and it was really uncomfortable. I was not impressed with the shoe...but I was impressed with Zappos service. I will definitely shop with Zappos again. Love it.

Hot but Uncomfortable - These shoes are beautiful but they were really uncomfortable. I think you should order half a size up for it to be bearable. They will make any outfit look better! I wish I could have kept them but I pick comfort over pain any day. I know a comfortable 4" heel is possible because I have several.

Simple classic - I do love the shoe, it is very comfortable for a heel; however, the picture makes it look like it has more coverage on the top of the foot. It does cover the toes for sure, but just past that. I still like them though.

Beauty and the beast - Pretty on the eyes; painful on the foot! I wear 3 1/2 to 4 inch heels on a daily basis, but these shoes are too narrow… Sorry guys. Think again about purchasing this shoe unless you purchase at least 1/2 to one full size larger than your normal size.

Very sexy shoe but there was no arch support.

Tight Fit- While these shoes do look great, I was surprised at how small they were. I usually wear a 7 or an 8, but I ordered an 8 in these shoes and I could barely squeeze my feet into them. I've NEVER had to wear anything above an 8.5 in my life and these feet like I needed a 9 or a 9.5. The leather is so flimsy also that even in the time I was just trying them on you could see creases beginning to form.

Guess Carrie shoe is sexy, but very uncomfortable- The Guess Carrie shoe is very sexy, but very uncomfortable. It does not form to your foot, at times I felt like I was wearing my shoes on the wrong feet. Anyhow, maybe they will eventually form to my feet when they are much more broken in. until then I'll continue wearing them because they are dang sexy.

Looks good only when new - The shoe looks great the first time you wear it, however after that it develops many creases that are very noticeable. The shoe is comfortable but not the best quality.

Gave them away after one wearing. They killed my feet.

Comfort and style is 5 stars. Quality is going down hill. This shoe has been my work staple for 10 years. I've had many pair in black and a few in natural. The several few were amazing (I was able to wear them daily for several months and even replace the heal pad when needed), but I agree with another reviewer about the quality of my more recent (last two years) purchases. Specifically, the heal is detaching after having been work a couple of times. This has happened to at least 5 pair. I've been able to always return with no problem, but I wish they would just fix the issue. I keep trying, though, because I Iove the shoe and hope with each pair that I won't have the same problem..

Very cute shoe, but incredibly uncomfortable. The arch is very high, making your foot almost perpendicular to the ground. These will be going back.

Red Patent Leather Carrie by Guess - This red is VERY VERY RED...not a rich red, but more of a bright red. They sort of appear clown red to me. I have these shoes in Red Croco and they look amazing!!! They have a stable/sturdy feel for such a high heel. I haven't worn them long, but I can tell how they would be uncomfortable after a long period of time. I am going to put Foot Petals in them and see if that helps. I would recommend these shoes because they are amazing!!! I will be returning the red patent leather b/c they don't look right, and I wear a small size shoe. Just not for me.

These look much nicer online than they are in person...but I admit that I am spoiled by nice shoes. The shoe looks cheap and runs large, to me. I am an 8/8.5 and the 8.5 is way too big and looks a little "chunky" even. I'm much happier with other great Zappos purchases.

the heel was weak, almost broke it beautiful shoe but not strong enough

I bought them in January, and only used them a couple of time inside my office and they broke!!! Don't waste your money

I tried these in a 6 and a 6.5. These were the most painful shoes I've ever worn. Within no time, I had blisters on top of my foot and on my heels. I was hobbling out of the office at the end of the day. I normally wear 4-5 inch heels with no problem. I'm really surprised that there are so many awesome reviews.

I bought these because of all the glowing reviews, but they are the most painful heels I have ever worn. They rubbed blisters on my heels and around the front of the shoe within no time. I wear high heels all the time. I was disappointed that these didn't work for me.