Customer Reviews Sperry AO 2 Eye Leather MM

I have been wearing these for years. The quality has gone way down since they have been making them in China. I order extra wide and they are way too narrow - I used to get wide and they fit fine. I need to order a half size bigger to get a so-so fit. Also, there is an issue with the stitching that holds the sole on. The recess for the thread is not deep enough and the thread frays and then the sole separates from the body. This has happened to the last several pairs I bought, usually after a season's use, but this last pair went after a few months. They just don't put the quality in like they used to.

Colors shoes are not a very good match. Only noticeable in bright light.

I've been wearing Topsiders for years-my first pair was when I was 13 so many years. This pair felt tight and without comfort. Unfortunately, I buy a year in advance so I have an extra pair and didn't realize it until it was too late to send them back. I hope the new pairs are better cut like the old Topsiders. I will try a new pair. Very disappointed.

Almost 3/4 of an inch shorter than the correct size I have. This is second time now. Something is wrong at Sperry.

I was so excited to get these that I just threw them on and started wearing them. The size and comfort was fine but the right shoe started making a hint of a squeak and by end of the second day of wearing them it sounded like a whoopee cushion or something. I work in real estate and I can't be showing clients homes in squeaky shoes so I called Zappos and they were helpful in returning them. I even did a walk for the customer service agent on the phone and shared my "squeak" with her. After I came back online to look for a different pair I decided to search the reviews for the word "squeak." Not to my surprise, many others have mentioned this squeak. Some have referred to it as Bozo the clown or a dog chew toy. It sucks because I really like the shoe. If you're on a boat or something maybe this wouldn't bother you but if you're often walking with other people they will definitely hear your shoes "squeaking."

Too narrow at the toe. Size 11 was squeezing my toes, so I returned those and tried 11.5 -- that was better lengthwise but the tapered toes of these shoes was still squeezing, and I have narrow feet. I could tell a blister would be coming. So I returned them. Too bad, they look nice. People with skinny tapered toes should like them.

I wore these things for the 2nd time on a hot day with lots of walking. I was not wearing socks but I think I will have to in the future. I got multiple blisters and they really did a number above my heel. There is a stitch at the top back of the shoe that basically turned to sandpaper. I really hope socks make a difference or this will be the end of my experimenting with boat shoes.

I love these Sperry's but am disappointed with my last pair. I've gone through 3 pairs of these for work and while the first two lasted over a year, the third pair got a huge crack in the bottom after 6 months of use. Long story short, I am buying something different this time. They're too expensive to have to buy that frequently.

Comfortable at first, but not at all durable. In less than 6 months, the sole had changed in shape and the leather became weirdly lopsided and started to pinch my foot to the point walking became painful. Would not buy again. I recommend Timberland's boat shoes, with their comfort soles. Same style, similar price, better comfort and durability. Wore without socks, so I bought a half size smaller than usual.

It looks great and feels really comfortable. I would have given it a 5-star rating if not for the annoying air/squeaking sound it makes every time you land on your heel. The sound is very loud; even other people can hear it. It's the air being pushed from in between the shoe and the insole. I'm not sure how to remedy this. Maybe glue the insole to the shoe so there wouldn't be any space for the air to pass through? That's my only gripe about this pair. Too bad it's so annoying.

I've heard great things about this brand so bought my pair. Big disappointment. In less than 4 months (of very minimal use) the insoles have come apart. Criminal waste of money for a brand which is supposed to be high quality.

The label inside being held down by glue and stitching peeled of after two hours of use. Or it may haven been there already and I didn't notice. Since I don't wear socks with loafers, I felt the leather stitching under my feet peeling off. Not one but both shoes. It's really annoying. I want to peel them off but afraid it may be worse. I would return them if I could. Don't buy these shoes. Zappos shouldn't eve sell them.

Like walking barefoot on tile flooring, no arch support or sole insert. Hove soaked shoe in water twice and worn until dry to try and get a better fit. Quality looks okay. Shoe tried in store felt better.

I've ordered Sperry Top-Siders twice in the past 2 years and have had to send them back twice each time until I got the right size. I love these shoes, but the sizing is reliably inconsistent.