Customer Reviews Crocs Cayman

Croc hunter - I wear a size 7.5 and ordered these as the website suggested and found them to really be too short. I will next order a size up instead of down. They are wide and I have not found my feet to sweat in them. The variety of colors is great. Shipping at Zappos is the BOMB!! I am a nurse and everyone in my office has started wearing these shoes even though they are ugly, they have an appeal that makes ya want to get a pair. Many of the physicians are wearing the highlander and aspen style of these shoes.

Fun shoes- I do not agree that you should order a size smaller. I ordered my usual size (11) and they felt fine in the width and just a bit short in the length. I think these are fun shoes to wear out to the garage, while washing the car, gardening, etc. The fit isn't precise enough for me to wear all day and be comfortable.

Go with the fakes! I have now ordered and returned 4 different sizes and colors of these -- I kept hoping that something would work better. The 9 was a little too small, the 10 was too big. I finally decided to try to LL Bean's "fake croc" clog and it was SOOO much better! Specific women's sizing means narrower and better fit. They seem just as comfortable to me... and cheaper!

Not what I expected - Despite the rave reviews I got from friends who wear Crocs, I found this shoe to be clunky looking, and it rubs my feet uncomfortably in a couple of places when I walk. I would not get it again.

Not enough cushioning - I work on cement and am disappointed that these shoes are not as cushioned as needed. So...I passed the crocs on to a friend. My Professional Birks with extra insoles work better for me.

Way too big - These shoes were huge on me - don't know if they were mismarked or what but they were easily 2 sizes too big and I will have to return.

Not for me - I don't care how comfortable these shoes might prove to be, there were too ugly for this short, plump person to sport on her feet. I have a friend with long slender legs (calves, esp) and she looks cute in these with skirts, pants, whatever. But if you are short and have wide feet, these are going to make you look like you're wearing two cinder blocks on your feet. Not worth it, when there are comfortable cute shoes out there. They ran short, too.

Crocs not for everyone - I have relatively narrow feet and take a half-size. The next size up won't stay on my foot, and the back strap doesn't even come close to my heel. The size down has my toes hitting the front, but I have to wear thick socks to keep them on my narrow feet. Since they fit so poorly, it's hard to judge comfort, and I use them only for short periods. If Crocs ever decides to make half sizes, I might try them again.

Comfy but ugly - These Crocs are great comfort wise but personally I think they’re ugly. No one in their right mind would say Crocs are cute and adorable!! But they’re great for lounging around the house in.

They just don't fit - I tried these in a size 7. They were too short and my heel kept hitting the back of the shoe. Ouch! I tried them in a size 8 and they were big all over and just as uncomfortable as the 7's. It would be nice if they made these in half sizes cause everyone raves about how comfy they are. Not true if you are between whole sizes. Maybe some day . . .

MEDIUM IS TO WIDE - I like the shoe but I have a narrow foot and the standard medium width is too large even with socks. My feet keep sliding because width is too wide! Very disappointed!

Croc's Cayman - So comfortable!! With socks for winter and holes for plenty of ventilation in the summer. Going to buy more in different colors. They mold to your feet and are extremely lightweight. Like the flippy back strap so you can wear them with or without.

Disappointing... My first pair of crocs was the beach style in silver. From the moment I took them out of the box I was in love. It was like walking on marshmallows. I have problem feet, and the first time I wore them, I did a 36 hour shift with no pain or aching whatsoever. I wanted a black pair that I could look a little more 'normal' in, and the beach were not in stock in black, so I ordered the Cayman instead. TOTAL DISAPPOINTMENT. These felt nothing like my first pair. They were hard, like regular plastic flip-flops. I figured that perhaps the newer model was just being made more cheaply. I returned them. Recently, I decided to give it one more shot, and I ordered a pair of crocs professionals in black. SAME BIG DISAPPOINTMENT. Stiff, hard plastic. Not sure if it's just that the black material is different, or if the newer models are different than the beach. Just thought I’d put it out there to save other people the hassle of shipping these things back & forth like I have.

Not bad, but Quark better - I just tried the Cayman style in size 9 women's...I just did not see the comfort that others rave about, and it ran big too! I have tried the Quark Liberty and it is still better quality and comfort, I will go back to them for a new color for fall.