Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

Great shoe . . . needs a little break in, but more than worth it. Looks just as good as shoes that cost $150 more. I am usually 10 1/2 EEE (even in other Johnston and Murphy shoes), but I was a 10 EEE in this shoe.

From the first time I wore them, they were totally comfortable. No breakin was needed because they fit so well and are so comfortable and attractive in design and color. Of all my JM shoes,they are number one!!

As a trial lawyer I want to always be well dressed and professional looking. My J&M's - the only shoes I've bought for years - are stylish, comfortable, take a great shine, and I never have to suffer through a break-in period.

Best pair I've had yet!!

Love them.

Great shoe, comfortable for a person with hard to find size

Wear out on town .... Great comfort

None!

I have been wearing Johnston&Murphy for years now I love the weight and comfort

Looks great dressed up or down with kackies. Comfortable and stylish at he same time.

Use the Melton's for work because of comfort and classic style. First pair lasted 14 years. These are excellent shoes. Highly recommend for any executive.

Purchased the shoes for dress with comfort in mind.

These are fantastic shoes. I have been looking for this style of shoe with this quality. The construction and sole are exceptional. My only wish is that J&M would offer more reasonably priced refurbishment services. These shoes cost [$] (MSRP). It does not make sense to pay $115 to refurbish. Please consider this value proposition.

The Melton provides great value combined with comfort and wear from J&M.

This is the third pair of black Melton cap toe shoes that I have bought. I've been waring Johnson and Murphy shoes for over 40 years. You can't go wrong with this company. The best classic dress and casual shoe that you can own.

I bought a second pair, different color. They are very comfortable after you break them in. It is a sturdy shoe that holds up to daily work wear. I still wear my first pair and they are still very comfortable and sturdy. I would recommend them to anyone. A great shoe for the money!

I use these shoes in many different situations from work to formal occasions and they still prove to great shoes

I wear this dress shoe to work every day. This is my second pair of shoes from Johnston & Murphy. I bought my first in 2000. After 2 resoles, I decided it was time to get a new pair. I'm betting these last as long as the first and I won't have to shop for dress shoes again for another 12 years.

I routinely wear this shoe with suits and (with a fresh shine) with a tuxedo. They shine fabulously -- look like patent leather. I have worn perhaps 6-7 pair over 30 years, in both black and borwn. They are long-wearing, take a half-sole and new heel nicely, and are comfortable from the first wearing. I usually discard them when I do something catestrophic -- like a gouge in the leather from my own inattention or clumsiness. Love 'em. Wear nothing else for dress.

Excellent shoes! Johnston & Murphy are the only shoes that I will buy!

This is one of the best shoes that Johnston & Murphy carries. I don't even know I have a shoe on it is so comfortable.