Customer Reviews Taryn Rose Kelsey

WOW! I've been a Ferragammo and Stuart Weitzman wearer for years, to get a narrow heel fit. After a recent encounter with stress fractures in both feet, I decided to give these a try. The heel clings to my feet, and I have plenty of comfort in my toes. I haven't had on any other shoes since the day I bought these! They're stylish, beyond comfortable, and I've had compliments! I only worry I'll wear them out quickly. I'll save the Ferragammos, etc., for special events, but these are now my every day shoes.

Fantastic comfort - I have 3 pairs of these and have a hard time putting on any other shoes if I'm going to be traveling, walking, and need to be a little more dressed. While not the most high style shoe, I get a lot of compliments wearing them and my feet feel great. I know the Taryn Rose shoes are expensive, but when you consider how much you'll wear them it becomes more reasonable. I have other styles with higher heels that are also great (not even after the 14 hours the day of my daughter's wedding.

These shoes are very very comfortable. I love them! Look great with pants and also with black tights!

I have ordered 4 pairs of these shoes and each time the size varies considerably. The last time I ordered a whole size smaller, they were huge! I returned them, got a half size smaller and they are still a little big. The shoes are great if you can get the right size.

Expensive and hopefully worth the money - Looks better in person than on-line as I find her shoes rather "old lady" looking (sorry to all the old ladies) Although 38.5 was listed as an American 8 I needed to order one size up, 39, to get the right fit. The sole seems a little thin so I am hoping they will wear well as they are advertised as a great walking shoe.

Love these - I was reluctant to spend so much on a casual shoe but I was eager to pay anything for something styish and comfortable. I love these. I will buy another pair. They felt great out of the box and still feel great. There are imitations that are still pricey but they are not even close to the comfort of these shoes.

I have worn this style of Taryn's for a long time and this size and I was swimming in this. I will try a 1/2 size down.

As you see, I bought two pairs of these Taryn Rose shoes. I have owned these shoes and was afraid they were being discontinued, so took the opportunity to but more. However, these are not like the originals. I had to keep one pair, because I had worn them, but they were uncomfortable. I had a stiff feeling. Then I saw that they were made in China. My original Taryn Rose shoes were made in Italy and were much better quality. Seeing that, I was surprised that they were the same price as those made in Italy. If the company continues using China as their manufacturer, then my Taryn Rose days are over. Mrs. J. Sullivan

These are not the same shoes as the original Kelsey which was the most comfortable shoes that I have ever owned. I bought Kelsey four years ago when it was priced considerably higher, but well worth the money. I ordered a new pair which does not fit like a glove, is too big, has a different last and is a big disappointment. I am returning these to Zappos. What happened, Taryn Rose?

Taryn Rose shoes seem to be made for feet that are AA width. Don't be fooled and there is no B width.

This shoes are very wide. I have two pairs of the same model and they are not this wide. They will fall off my feet.

I take a 7.5. The information said to order a 1/2 size larger. I did-they were huge. Then I ordered 7.5-they are still way too big. I think these may be worth trying it just once more.

I do not think you need to order a half size up! I ordered my regular size 8 and they fit great!

I ordered these shoes to replace a pair that I have worn for years. Unfortunately, the shoe has changed - it is larger and there is less arch support.

The information on this shoe suggest ordering a 1/2 size larger. I did and they were too big - by about a 1/2 size. I reordered them in my regular size because they are high quality and comfortable.

These shoes are very comfortable, and not terribly ugly (though not too sexy either). I love wearing them but they are rather flimsily constructed. I had to return the first pair for a replacement pair because they fell apart! Thus is surprising because they're so expensive. The new pair haven't held up too well either, despite me not wearing them in the rain and not as frequently. Great comfort, but quality is lower than expected.

These shoes are incredibly comfortable, but sadly, cheaply made. The first pair I had, I wore them line crazy but they fell apart in a month. I returned them thinking I got a lemon pair. The next pair is the same. I wish they were stronger and more durable, because they are fantastic for walking long distances.

Since Taryn Rose sold her business, her shoes "disappeared" until the new owners found a new manufacturer. The original TR's were made in Italy of the finest quality, true to size (though shown in Italian/metric sizes). The new manufactured versions are lower quality and are easily recognizable by the pink lining. Nowhere on the box is a "made in USA/China/Italy" like it's a big secret (like the shoes, which are huge) - I also think undeclared manufacturing source is illegal and certainly tacky! Thank heaven I have a great inventory of the real Taryn Rose shoes - they have lasted years and are still classic. No new cheap, pink lined versions for me! FYI, if you are a size 5, Amazon still has a few pair of new ones (or so they say!).

I have this shoe in 2 other colors from 2 yrs ago. They must have changed where they are being manufactured. The sizing is all off. That might explain why the TR brand is so much cheaper than 2 yrs ago.

Heard about famous name Taryn Rose, she use to be a doctor, now she is the shoe designer. Was crazy to buy her shoes. Lucky me saw her shoes on sale, my size, very comfy, not the most gorgeous shoes. I bought them anyway. Good time came in, I on my feet all day long. Happy about my purchase. Get a lot of compliments. Second day wearing my new shoes and see the most famous shoes are falling apart second day at work. I'm shacked. Taryn Rose designer shoes are bad quality? What kind of business is this? I'm so disappointed. Going to take it back. I don't know if I love them? Did not have enough time to enjoy it. Very disappointed customer.