Customer Reviews Dr. Martens 1461 3-Eye Gibson

There are always two questions Dr. Martens wearers have. Will these fit? How bad will the breaking-in process be? Well, among Mr. Martens wearers, the breaking-in process is part of the rite of passage. It's part of the mythology and heritage of this fine brand of shoes. I do have to say that the breaking-in of this particular model of shoe is short and if existent at all. My Dr. Martens model was the 1925, which seems to have been discontinued. This model number 1461 was the closest replacement. I did not realize it at the time, but this model (1461) is part of their Airlite or Airsole line of shoes. So, they felt like they were automatically broken-in, and also cushioned. That was a pleasant surprise. As for what size to wear, for US shoe sizes, I typically fit into between a man's 9 and 10 size. the rule of thumb is to order one size smaller than that. I ordered a UK 7 (man's 8), and they fit perfectly. My own rule of thumb is that you should order the same size of Dr. Marten that you do Converse Chuck Taylors. If you don't also wear Converse Chuck Taylors, then you aren't cool enough to wear these shoes either. :) Just kidding. Hope this review helps. In short, they are sturdy, thick, heavy, and comfortable, just how I like my women. :)

As always, Zappos rocked on service and delivery. As for the shoes themselves, these Docs are starting to finally break in after the first 2 weeks or so, but it was a brutal start with those deep heel cups that cut into the back of my feet. My suggestion is to wear heavier socks and put adhesive bandages on your heels when you first start wearing these. The next pair I order (albeit in 8-10 years probably) will be the same model but labeled specifically as Made in England and not the standard version that is now made in China. There is definitely a difference.

I've been a long time DM supporter (23yrs!) having several disappointments during the dodgy years of transition out of England. Comparing these to my last MIE pair, it's hard to see any difference. Leathers seem about equally good quality, no blemishes, solid stitching. These have a padded insert, whereas the old ones did not. I'm thinking they'll last me several years of wear. The only con is that they do seem a bit larger than UK 10. I've added an insole and still need to double some thinner socks. Otherwise, great! Love them bouncing soles, like walking on clouds. Thanks, DM and extra thanks to Zappos!

My first pair of DM's (at age 39). One week of pain breaking them in and then they're butter. Great shoe. Black stitch makes them perfect for work. Get 'em (and don't wait until middle age).

I wear a womens 9-9.5 and find the US mens size 7 fits me best in these. Took me about 3 weeks to break them in, wearing them for 30-40 minutes once a day. Now they are pretty comfortable & I can wear them for a full 13 hour day on my feet, no problem.

I love, love, love these shoes and Zappos! I haven't experienced any issues with breaking them in, but they are a little warm for the South Carolina summer! I originally ordered the 8 for my size 7.5 foot, but ended up returning and getting the 7, much better!

These Nappa leather 1461s are the best pair of Docs that I've ever owned, I highly recommend them. The leather is soft and has a nice grain to it, they go with any outfit, and once you break them in they're very comfortable. I've had several pairs of 1461/1460 smooths over the years, including 2 pairs that were made in England and I love these Nappa leather Docs much more than any of those other pairs. To help with sizing, I got a 10 in these 1461s and they fit me perfectly, for reference I'm a 9.5 in Converse, 10.5 in Vans, 10.5 in Adidas, and a 10.5/11 in Nikes. Cheers!

I love these shoes! They're super comfortable and look great! I have a fairly wide foot and these shoes accommodate me comfortably. They have great traction and are well made. The only thing that bothered me at first was the back of the shoe rubbed my ankle raw because it hit me just in the wrong spot... I ended up adding an insole and it made that problem disappear and worth the extra 10 bucks I paid for the insoles. I'd give 5 stars if I didn't have to add the insole since the factory soles are so comfortable without any modifications.

Comfortable, true to fit. The leather is a bit shiny and I prefer a bit matte with more of a worn look. These look brand spanking new and hospital shoe like. But with wear, they'll develop a personality.

I have had these exact Docs for years. I ordered a new pair, exact same style (1461) and size as the ones I have. They are way too big! They are also slightly different in style. The toe are is more raised/bulbous.

I'm not sure I'd add anything to what others have said. A classic shoe that's surprisingly comfortable. I normally wear a 11.5/12 and I ordered a 12 (UK size 11). Mine came with yellow laces as well for a bit of an added style. Dr. Martens brand proves once again to stand the test of time.

Dr. Marten's is the only shoe I wear! I work in food service, so I may spend as many as 12 hours on my feet, and with the patented sole I know I'm safe from slipping.

The Dr. Marten 1461 is my favorite shoe. I own one for each foot. Understated & durable. I wear them everyday and everywhere (third pair since 1999).

Ordered the shoes late Sunday and received them following Tuesday morning. Very fast service, as always from Zappos. The shoes fit great right out of the box and look good enough to wear to work. The welt hides the industrial looking stitching. They are extremely comfortable. They are little wider than expected, which is what I was hoping for, as other DMs I tried seemed tight. The quality seems great and I will probably be looking for other DMs in other colors. I generally wear a 10.5 so the UK 10 USA 11 fit perfect for me. This is my first pair of Dr. Martens and I am very satisfied with them. I and my wife have purchased a number of shoes through Zappos have been very pleased with the speed of shipment and comfort of knowing that if they don't fit, you can send them back without issues.

My comments below should be prefaced with the fact that I have been wearing Docs for 20+ years. The last pair I had was the Genuine Made in England and they were a nice fit but at the high price, I can't afford that. This Made in China pair has nice soft leather and the cushy sole like all Docs. Overall an apparently well made shoe. The problem I have with them is their sizing. I have a narrow foot so Docs are always a hair on the wide side for me but this pair is unwearable after being broken in. My foot slides around and within 5 minutes of walking at a good clip I get hot spots and soon enough blisters. I tried some Dr. Schol's inserts but they are not substantial enough to fill the shoe. Perhaps a $30 insole would help but how much does one invest in poorly fitting shoes.

A great shoe, noot my first paiir of Dr. Martens. Always a very reliable shoe that you can count on for years of comfortable wear. A bit stiff for the first few months.

These shoes are dope. Not only do they look good but they are comfy too. You should probably just buy 'em.

I used to wear this brand long ago when I was so much younger, and could not find them easily in shoe stores here in the US. I bought shoes form different brands that last 3 maybe 6 months, since I walk a lot. I stumbled upon Dr Martens again in a shoe store, where they did not have my size (size 13). So I decided to try zappos.com, since friends of mine are happy with the service. I found my shoes, in my size, ordered them, and when I tried them on it was like meeting an old friend after a long time! These are great shoes, for everyday wear, they do need to be worn in, it takes a couple of days before the leather forms to your feet, but then it is extremely comfortable. I walk back and forth to my job, a total of 3.4 miles Monday to Friday and these shoes still feel great.

Classic Dr. Martens shoe. Can't leave home without. You know the shoe, you know the quality. Zappos delivers what you need. Just remember, the full shoe size steps: means it might be on the big size.

Bought this shoe in Oct 2008 and wear them everyday to work. There was a good week or so of breaking in but they then became completely comfortable. I was worried that the made in China version of Docs would not last but 2 and a 1/2 years later there is very little wear or breaking down of the leather and sole. I had a made in England chukka style shoe that lasted 6 years of daily use so if I can get close to that with these shoes, I will be very happy.

Very comfortable, and great for the office. These don't have the classic Dr. Martens yellow stitching and are inconspicuous at work. My new favs.

I always buy from Zappos. Easy return policy. Sometimes you buy shoes from department stores, and they're stretched out - with Zappos, every time I ordered, they were brand new. I'm upset that the Docs were from China, not England and there is a difference, if you have the real ones, but they still look great and are comfy. Next month, ordering some summer shoes.

Zappos was really helpful when I messed up my order and needed to fix it. Then the shoes they sent me were the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned. You really need to try Dr. Martens 1461's. Evidently they have updated their insoles and are now better than ever.

These shoes were bought as a gift for my son. He's worn Docs for years and loves them. And Zappos is the best!

Great shoes. I've owned a few pairs in my life, and always been happy. There's a little bit of a break in period, but after they're broke in they're super comfortable. Very durable as well.