Customer Reviews Sebago Sherman

The shoes were delivered on time. Unfortunately the E wide was not wide enough for my feet. I think I need the extra wide. The instep is way too narrow. I find with sebago widths are not consistent.

Very stiff shoe out of the box. Both my heels are gouged and the stiff leather upper has left painful rub marks under the knuckle of both big toes. I walk a lot (from front door to bus to train) and by the end of day one was in agony. I hope these break in soon. Nice looking dressy loafer with a suit, though.

Problem at the heel - I have been wearing this pair of shoes for 18 months. Looks good, feels good. However, there is a squeaking sound from the right side heel recently. The annoying noise comes out from every step. I plan to have heel repair and see any improvement.

Wider than advertised - This shoe appears much wider than the 'B' width I ordered...not real bad but is a bit loose.

Sturdy but sweaty - I like the shoe because it holds its shape better than the Bass Weejun and the sole doesn't separate like the Weejun. However, this shoe does not breathe as well as the Leather Weejuns.

These are the worst shoes I have ever owned, and I've tried and tried to make them work for me for many months. Basically, these are very cheaply made: insides unfinished; cheap leather won't hold polish; soles leave black marks on tiled surfaces; no arch support. I'm sick when I remember I paid so much for this junk! I would never recommend these shoes.

I like the way these look and they would likely be more comfortable if they were not a bit too small. For me, they should have been a half size (or more) larger.

The shoes are well designed and made. But they are too wide for me and are going back.