Customer Reviews Florsheim Berkley Penny Loafers

I ordered these shoes based on style I like. I found the to be comfortable and well made.

The shoe appeared to be well made however the triple E width was not true to size. it was much narrower than expected. I had to return them as the fit was more like a normal D width and I could not get them on.

Ordered two pair. One black and one brown. Black fit great and look great. The brown pair is the same size as black pair. 9 1/2 extra wide. They are quite tight in width

I wear 10D normally and couldn't even get my foot in the shoe. Return was easy. I re-ordered 3E width hoping they fit since I love this style.

Florsheim Imperial Kenmore wingtip shoes are probably the best value for money classic all leatherlace up shoes on the market. And Florsheim's Berkley penny loafer is the best value for money all leather classic penny loafer. I live in Hong Kong where Florsheim previously had an excellent presence and stocked an excellent range of tradiitonal high quality men's shoes including in the largest sizes - I'm a US 12 3e - which catered for the significant Hong Kong market for high quality big shoes. Now Florsheim has only a limited market presence in Hong Kong and does not sell any of theirhigh end or large sized shoes in Hong Kong. Gone are the flourishing Florsheim outlets in Sogo and WingOn that used to sell highend large size Florsheim shoes including the lamented Cordovan line. So for the first time in my life I bought a pair of shoes online - this was no easy task because Florsheim required a USA delivery address. Fortunately I could arrange that. If I could buyt these shoes off tghe shelf in Hong Kong I would definitely give 5 Stars.

Florsheim Imperial Kenmore wingtip shoes are probably the best value for money classic all leatherlace up shoes on the market. And Florsheim's Berkley penny loafer is the best value for money all leather classic penny loafer. I live in Hong Kong where Florsheim previously had an excellent presence and stocked an excellent range of tradiitonal high quality men's shoes including in the largest sizes - I'm a US 12 3e - which catered for the significant Hong Kong market for high quality big shoes. Now Florsheim has only a limited market presence in Hong Kong and does not sell any of theirhigh end or large sized shoes in Hong Kong. Gone are the flourishing Florsheim outlets in Sogo and WingOn that used to sell highend large size Florsheim shoes including the lamented Cordovan line. So for the first time in my life I bought a pair of shoes online - this was no easy task because Florsheim required a USA delivery address. Fortunately I could arrange that. If I could buyt these shoes off tghe shelf in Hong Kong I would definitely give 5 Stars.

Have ordered many pairs of shoes in my lifetime. Have been wearing 9 1/2 extra wide for 15 years. This pair is tight and felt tight after a couple hours. Wore them for the remainder of the day and still tight in the width. Hopefully they will loosen up over time. They are very nice looking.

While these shoes are still getting "broken in," I love that they can work with a suit as well as blue jeans!

Exactly how the shoe was displayed on the website. Easy returns as the package had the return label.

My shoes are a little too large but you do not have the next lower size available.

This is my go to shoe causal or dress. The new shoe is a comfortable as the shoe that it is replacing. I like the cordovan color, since it works with any color slack. The only down side is that cordovan shoe polish is a rare find in the stores.

I ordered two pairs of 12aaa, and they are to small like they are miss marked, I have several pairs of shoes like this all of them fit perfect

Even though they are EEE, the right one is almost too tight to wear. Length is good. They are beautiful.

Even though they are EEE, the right one is almost too tight to wear. Length is good. They are beautiful.

Except for sports wear and specific purpose footwear all my shoes have to have leather soles.

I only purchase shoes with leather soles. In recent years I have had a problem have theses shoes resoled due to the welt coming off or being ripped.

This is the 2nd pair 91/2 Med that have been tight. My feet have not gotten bigger. I think the shoes are getting a bit smaller

This is the 2nd pair 91/2 Med that have been tight. My feet have not gotten bigger. I think the shoes are getting a bit smaller

Very pleased with the quality of this shoe. I wear a narrow size that can be difficult to find. These fit perfectly. They are leather soled so they are a bit slippery. It would be nice to have something with a bit more grip.

My previous penny loafers wore out. Bought them in 1995 at a brick and mortar store in a department store. Had them resoled 1 time. Hope these shoes last just as long.

The shoe seems well made however it's not perfect. For wide footers/flat feet it's not a great shoe. I bought my TTS in Nike/Jordans of 12 in regular width. It seems to flair out on the sides indicating it should be wider. It feels like I needed a 11.5 wide rather than a 12 normal.

I bought the shoe because I still own a 12 B 611 01804N6 shoe that I believe is a Florsheim that I purchased from my union back in the 80's I believe. They are the most comfortable shoe I have ever owned and now I wear it on special occasions, so I was looking for a replacement. I bought a 12 B, however the heel is loose which means my heel is still an A. Anything I can add to tighten up the heel?

These are very nice shoes and are worth the money but I wish Florsheim did not market these as "Burgundy." I purchased them through a retailer with the expectation that they would have a red oxblood/wine/cordovan/burgundy tone to them as the online pics indicate. These do not have a red tone to them and are really just a dark coffee brown.

I was well aware that this shoe was unlined. I wanted an all-leather shoe so I wouldn't suffocate my feet. I failed to comprehend this meant no meaningful arch support. If someone really needs that kind of support, the Berkley Flex may be a better option. Otherwise, I like the shoes and will keep them.

Sizing of the Berkley loafers, was impossible. My narrow foot very comfortably fits a pair of 8 1/2 Alden Cordovan Saddle Oxfords and my Florsheim Imperial Shell Cordovan Wingtips in size 8 1/2 C that I wore 20 years. But these shoes did not fit with either 8 1/2 D or E.