Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Michaela Jelly

OFF SIZING! Beware! I am a true 7.5-8, slender foot, and ordered both a size 7 and 8. Size 7 was marked size 7 and too small, length and width wise; size 8 was marked 8.5 and too big overall. Weird. The shoes are very cute, very comfy and exactly what I was looking for so I'm keeping the 8.5 despite being a tad too long in the toe. Wondering if anyone else has noticed sizing issues....? I'd love to have a true size 8 as it'd be a better fit for me but I'm guessing it doesn't exist....??

I think it runs a half size to a full size big. The US size is marked as a 9, but the EU size is marked as a 40. A more typical conversion is US 9 = EU 39 and 9.5 = 40. The EU size is definitely more correct. Even correcting for that, the shoe runs big. By my measurements, the inside of the shoe is about 26cm long, which is close to a US size 10.

I bought these just for fun--they're retro looking. I wouldn't want to wear them all day, but they're cute with certain clothes. I do have to mention that they have a strong odor, so I put them outside on the porch overnight til the smell lessened.

I wear an 8. Shoe felt true to size. I love these jellies . They are so stinking cute . I want more !!!

Happy with shoes overall.

I was influenced to buy these but the influencer was spot on. These are super cute and comfy. These are not the same jelly shoes I had as a kid in the 80s. They are sophisticated vintage fun! And the red is the perfect pop of color!

Narrow and long in the toe bed. But overall very cute

Had to exchange for the next size up.

This shoe is darling: a perfect casual look for summer. While a little bit wider and longer than a true 35M, it works fine because of the strap. Plus a little extra room is great for hot, humid summer days. And it does have a cork insole (missing from other brands) that helps keep things cool as well. Altogether a great buy.

Very long in the foot. Material had a string odor too. The pink coloring was not to my liking.

Love these and how they look however the toe bed is narrow from the top down. My toes are squished and after a while they feel uncomfortable. They don’t rub and the sole is great. I can’t size up as there would be too much visible length at the front.